CNN town halls with Steve Bullock and Bill de Blasio
Our live coverage of CNN's town halls with Steve Bullock and Bill de Blasio has ended. Scroll through the posts below to see how the evening unfolded.
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio, in a blunt, impassioned moment at Sunday’s CNN town hall, said Americans who believe immigrants are to blame for their economic insecurity are wrong.
“They have a lot of debt, there’s a lot of problems in their lives. They’re frustrated. They’ve been told for years and years the immigrants did it to them,” de Blasio said. “I want to be blunt about it: The immigrants didn’t do that to you.”
De Blasio said it was important to “recognize that there’s many, many people in this country who happen to be American citizens, many of them happen to be white, who they, themselves, are legitimately struggling, their American dream’s not working out, they’re economically challenged.”
But the mayor said that politicians who have sought to convince these voters that immigrants are to blame for their issues, like President Donald Trump, are lying.
“Wall Street did that to you. The big corporations did that to you. The guy in the kitchen or the guy in the fields didn’t have the power to do that to you,” de Blasio said. “Only those who had the power and the wealth could create an economy so unfair to working people and middle-class people.”
He added: “Once we unmask that truth, and I think we should all speak that truth with energy, then we can answer the rest of the equation.”
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio said he wants to "make sure people get health care from the beginning" so patients don't turn to emergency room visits as a means of health care.
"Millions and millions of Americans only have one doctor, and that's the emergency room. That is the worst place and the last place people should ever have to go for health care, and it's one of the most expensive places, and guess who pays for it? Every single one of us," he said.
Previously, de Blasio has argued that health care should be a right and said he supports moving to a government-run system like “Medicare for All” — which would create a national government-backed health care plan — as well as abolishing private health insurance.
"There should not be such a thing as an American who doesn't have insurance or doesn't have health care. That should be a thing of the past," de Blasio said at the CNN town hall.
CNN's Ana Cabrera then asked de Blasio how he'd pay for such a health care plan.
"So, first, what we should do it pay for our federal government in general is repeal the Trump tax cuts for the wealthy and the corporations," he said.
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio, during a contentious answer that drew shouts from at least one audience member, said Sunday that the death of Eric Garner at the hands of officer Daniel Pantaleo in 2014 taught him that the city “had to do pretty much everything differently.”
Five years after Garner’s death, Pantaleo was fired from the New York Police Department a week ago. De Blasio had blamed the Department of Justice over the handling of the case, but that explanation did not satisfy many in New York, some of whom vocally and directly protested the mayor.
“The first thing to say is Eric Garner should not have died, and then the next thing to say is there can never be another Eric Garner in this city or any place else in this country,” de Blasio said. “And it can be stopped.”
“What we learned immediately after the tragedy of Eric Garner was we had to do pretty much everything differently,” de Blasio said, citing implicit bias training, body cameras and retraining officers on de-escalation techniques.
Pantaleo was found guilty in a disciplinary trial earlier this month of using a chokehold on Garner, the New York man whose final words -- “I can’t breathe” -- became a rallying cry for the Black Lives Matter movement.
“There needs to be federal leadership that says de-escalation training, implicit bias training, body cameras, every police officer in America should have those. Every single one,” he said. “That’s how we end the tragedies.”
After de Blasio blamed the federal government for the five-year process to fire Pantaleo, a woman in the audience shouted, “What about Lieutenant Bannon? What about officer Ramos? What about other officers?”
De Blasio did not answer the woman’s question.
Watch the moment:
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio was just asked about how he'd ensure US military troops receive proper mental healths services.
"How can we assure you will support our troops' mental health and wellbeing when there's an evident lack of support of the men and women of the New York City police department, who have a higher than average suicide rate with nine suicides this year?" a NYPD police officer in the audience asked.
First, some background: At least nine New York City police officers have died from suicide this year. Seven of those deaths have happened since June: The recent cluster has rattled the department, with leaders trying to come up with a way to tell the rank and file that it's OK to ask for help.
De Blasio said the question was "so important," adding, we have "got to do a lot more for our officers."
"We got to do a lot more for those who serve us in the armed forces because right now in America we are not honest about mental health. That's just a truth," he said.
De Blasio said New York City is working on measures to make sure "every police officer has someone they can turn to" and said teams are striving to "do a better job allowing first responders to get the therapy and mental health services they need."
He added: "But this is part of a bigger reality. I just want to say this election may be the first election in American history where mental health is front and center as an issue."
De Blasio said he was 18 years old when his father, a decorated war hero who volunteered after the attack on Pearl Harbor to serve in World War II, committed suicide.
He said his father's physical injuries from war were "bad enough," but "the emotional toll was even greater."
"What I remember seeing was this really good, honorable, man just falling apart, and he, you know — people, some people tried to offer help. He didn't know how to accept it," de Blasio said.
Watch the moment:
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio argued on Sunday that the divide between urban and rural America, a rift that is seen as widening in recent years, is not as stark as most people believe.
De Blasio argued that all Americans want generally the same from life, telling the audience at a CNN town hall that people in “rural counties” and “folks who live in smaller town” are asking him about “literally nearly identical (issues) to what I heard from my constituents here in the five boroughs.”
“I really don’t see the divide as much as I think it’s projected to all of us,” de Blasio said. “I think there’s a lot more commonality of feeling and interest.”
The divide between urban and rural voters was most stark during the 2016 election, where President Donald Trump overwhelmingly won rural voters in 2016, while urban voters backed Democrat Hillary Clinton.
But de Blasio said that divide is not as clear as it was on Election Day in 2016.
“I actually think Americans over the years have come to have a lot more in common and so I would argue to you what matters here is being able to speak to the hearts of Americans about their reality,” he said.
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio has enjoyed success in his city on several progressive issues such as universal pre-K, raising the minimum wage and expanding paid sick leave for workers.
Here are his current positions on these key issues:
Education: De Blasio said at the first Democratic debate that the party should support “free public college for our young people.” Under de Blasio, New York City created a universal public pre-K system, which he’s held out as a success.
Health care: De Blasio argues that health care should be a right and supports moving to a government-run system like “Medicare for All” — which would create a national government-backed health care plan — as well as abolishing private health insurance. He has said he supports state moves to create public health programs in the absence of a federal system.
Climate crisis: De Blasio supports the Green New Deal, the broad plan to address renewable-energy infrastructure and climate change proposed by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, and in April announced a $14 billion version for New York. New York City’s plan aims to cut carbon emissions by 40% from the 2005 baseline by 2030 and reach carbon neutrality by 2050. De Blasio also supports the Paris climate agreement and signed an executive order to hold New York City to the standards of the agreement.
Gun violence: De Blasio is a member of Mayors Against Illegal Guns, a coalition organized by Everytown for Gun Safety, the gun control group largely financed by de Blasio’s predecessor Michael Bloomberg. In June, de Blasio called on New York City’s pension funds to divest from makers of so-called assault weapons and high-capacity magazines.
Immigration: De Blasio has taken concrete steps in New York to extend services and civil protections to undocumented immigrants, including granting them access to city ID cards and free legal advice. He has campaigned for immigration revisions, including giving some undocumented immigrants who were brought to the US as children a pathway to citizenship.
Economy: He’s expressed support for repealing Trump’s 2017 tax cuts for the wealthy and for corporations. In July, he introduced a “Fair Share” tax plan that includes a tax on assets over $10 million, a tax of 50%-60% on inheritances worth more than $1 million and an increase in top marginal tax rates on income to 50% for incomes between $1 million and $2 million and 60% for incomes over $2 million. He would also impose a one-time tax of 40% on assets above $50 million for anyone who renounces their US citizenship – what he calls a “turncoat tax.” He is calling for a $15 minimum hourly wage, paid sick leave and stronger worker protections through his 21st Century Workers Bill of Rights.
Montana Gov. Steve Bullock said Democrats begging him to run for Senate in 2020 is out of the question, telling the audience at Sunday's CNN town hall that he would emphatically not run against Republican Sen. Steve Daines.
“So that’s an absolute no,” CNN’s Alisyn Camerota asked.
“That’s an absolute no,” Bullock responded.
Bullock said his opposition to running for Senate, in large part, stems from his lack of interest to work in a legislature – something he has never done in his career – and his desire to spend time with his children.
“I know President Obama had dinner with his kids a lot more than I would as a senator from Montana,” Bullock said.
“We’re going to have good candidates in Montana. Not everybody knows everyone in Montana. I’m going to do everything I can to make sure that we elect somebody,” Bullock said. “But for me, part of it is professional. Meaning the whole time I’ve served as an executive, I’ve been able to bring people together to get things done. I think that’s where my talents are best suited.”
As eager as Democrats are to oust President Donald Trump from office, many are worried about the US Senate, where the Democratic Party is currently in the minority. That concern has extended to the presidential race, where a number of Democrats from states with important Senate races are vying for the top job.
Calls for Bullock to run for Senate grew louder recently when former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper bowed out of the presidential race and decided to run for Senate.
Bullock also got the question during a commercial break; an audience member asked the governor why he wasn’t considering it.
“We do have some good people in Montana. I think as we look at this, we also gotta figure out why are we losing places like North Dakota, why are we losing Indiana? Why is it 22 states now completely controlled by Republicans,” Bullock asked.
He added: “To be honest, I have young kids. I would actually never get to see those kids. President Obama ate dinner with his kids a lot more than I ever would, and I can’t miss their whole lives.”
Watch the moment:
Montana Gov. Steve Bullock defended his opposition to the single payer "Medicare for All" proposal on Sunday in his CNN town hall, setting him apart from more progressive Democrats running for president like Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren.
Bullock said the “greatest stride” the country has made on health care is Obamacare, the sweeping health care law signed by President Barack Obama.
“I don’t think the best way is to start all over. I don’t want to take away employer sponsored health care,” Bullock said. “I look at this as an add-on, not a complete teardown.”
He added: “The way we get to full access and affordability isn’t to start over. It’s to build on what we have.”
Medicare for All would shift control over the health care system to the federal government and essentially eliminate the private insurance industry.
Bullock’s list of concerns also include taxes. He told the audience here in New York that Medicare for All “would increase taxes on everyone in this country.”
Bullock said, as president, he would support a public option and would issue he would all the ability for the federal government to negotiate drug prices, thereby lowering costs.