Debating the role of pro-Trump voices on CNN RS_00020026.jpg
Debating the role of pro-Trump voices on CNN RS_00020026.jpg
Now playing
05:30
Debating the role of pro-Trump voices on CNN
Fox News/Twitter
Now playing
01:33
ADL wants Fox News to fire Tucker Carlson over racist comments
Now playing
01:54
'You think I'm racist': Former Fox News host storms off camera
CNN
Now playing
03:37
'The fraud is this farce': Cuomo calls out Fox News host
CNN
Now playing
05:00
Watch Alisyn Camerota sign-off CNN's New Day
Camerota Berman both
CNN
Camerota Berman both
Now playing
02:33
CNN anchor Alisyn Camerota gets surprise tribute from co-anchor
CNN/HBO/"Q: Into the Storm"
Now playing
05:35
Filmmaker says he potentially uncovered man behind QAnon
BOSTON, MA - AUGUST 30:  Anti-vaccine activists hold up signs during a protest in front of the Massachusetts State House against Governor Charlie Baker's mandate that all Massachusetts school students enrolled in child care, pre-school, K-12, and post-secondary institutions must receive the flu vaccine this year on August 30, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts.  (Photo by Scott Eisen/Getty Images)
Scott Eisen/Getty Images
BOSTON, MA - AUGUST 30: Anti-vaccine activists hold up signs during a protest in front of the Massachusetts State House against Governor Charlie Baker's mandate that all Massachusetts school students enrolled in child care, pre-school, K-12, and post-secondary institutions must receive the flu vaccine this year on August 30, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Scott Eisen/Getty Images)
Now playing
03:06
Research exec: Far-right groups pushing vaccine as 'mark of the beast'
stelter chauvin trial international coverage kethevane gorjestani sot rs vpx_00000000.png
stelter chauvin trial international coverage kethevane gorjestani sot rs vpx_00000000.png
Now playing
02:19
How the rest of the world is covering the Derek Chauvin trial
CBS This Morning
Now playing
01:57
Hunter Biden makes rare comment about seized laptop
Fox News
Now playing
03:43
Tucker Carlson's interview with Gaetz gets uncomfortable
NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 09: News headlines on the impeachment trial of Donald Trump are displayed outside of the Fox headquarters on February 09, 2021 in New York City. After listening to nearly four hours of legal arguments, the Senate has voted on Tuesday to move ahead with the impeachment trial of former President Trump. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 09: News headlines on the impeachment trial of Donald Trump are displayed outside of the Fox headquarters on February 09, 2021 in New York City. After listening to nearly four hours of legal arguments, the Senate has voted on Tuesday to move ahead with the impeachment trial of former President Trump. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Now playing
04:03
Dominion Voting Systems files $1.6 billion lawsuit against Fox News
 President Donald Trump waves as he departs on the South Lawn of the White House, on December 12, 2020 in Washington, DC.
Al Drago/Getty Images
President Donald Trump waves as he departs on the South Lawn of the White House, on December 12, 2020 in Washington, DC.
Now playing
01:35
Trump praises Capitol rioters 'hugging and kissing the police'
Now playing
01:33
Meghan McCain is, again, in the hot seat over diversity comments
Now playing
01:51
John Oliver calls out Meghan McCain's response to Atlanta shootings
CNN
Now playing
06:47
Chung: Media was 'miserably late' to covering anti-Asian hate
(CNN Business) —  

In the Trump age we often talk about “alternative universes” of information – about the administration, about impeachment, about the economy, about pretty much everything.

The divide between these two universes of information is extreme – so extreme that I sometimes find it hard to describe. That’s why I was so struck by something that John Dickerson said the other day.

I was on a panel with Dickerson, the “60 Minutes” correspondent and contributing writer to The Atlantic, when he talked about the way the discourse has changed. I don’t have a recording of the session, so I asked him to summarize the point. He replied:

“The standards of the interview have snapped. It used to be that public shame meant that people would give answers that ranged from A to D. They might not give you the God’s honest truth, but they’d be too afraid or embarrassed to go beyond D. Now many politicians have no fear. They give responses instead of answers and the range is between A and Z.”

Exactly. The range of answers used to be from “A to D” – government officials and other newsmakers would spin or deflect, but at least their answers existed in a shared reality. Not anymore. Interviews are derailed when the interviewee goes to Z by changing the subject, straight-up lying, or swerving into conspiracy theory territory.

If you think about it, this same concept applies to Trump’s tweets and on-camera comments too. He goes from A to Z multiple times a day.

To some, “A to D” might seem limiting. It may call to mind the media gatekeepers of old, who had the power to define the range of public debate on an issue. Those gates were blasted open years ago by the internet.

But I don’t think “A to D” is about gatekeeping – it’s about truthtelling.

We have words for what happens from A to D. We know how to recognize a B.S. artist. There’s certainly a long history of political lying that pre-dates Trump and his aides.

But Dickerson’s scale hits on how the dialogue has changed. X, Y and Z are another thing altogether. The Daily Beast’s Michael Tomasky recently argued that “it’s worse than lies:” He said “there’s no word in the English language for what Trump and co. are doing.”

Dickerson is a former moderator of “Face the Nation” on CBS, so he has first-hand experience with the scale.

He commented on the panel that when a guest goes to Y or Z, the interviewer has to spend his or her time there too. These are the portions of interviews that tend to go viral: The journalist challenges some crazy assertion or demands evidence or debunks a lie.

But the conversation is still happening at Z instead of, say, D. The audience has been dragged there too.

It happened when the Trump White House made bogus claims about the inauguration crowd size. It has happened dozens of times since. And it’s happening now as the president promotes conspiracy theories and likens a legal impeachment inquiry to an illegal “coup.”

The result: Viewers get fed up. They bemoan the broken state of American politicans. Some of them say networks like CNN shouldn’t book guests with a track record of lying in the first place. Others say interviews with administration aides are inherently newsworthy and necessary. We discussed some of this on Sunday’s “Reliable Sources” vis a vis CNN’s newest pro-Trump commentator Sean Duffy.

Call it “alternative universes,” blame “alternative facts,” cite the “A to Z” scale – the upshot is the media and its audience are being dragged into this uncharted territory together.

Trump has “given us reason to doubt literally everything he’s saying” because he is “proactively lying about tiny stuff all the time,” CNN fact-checker Daniel Dale said on Sunday’s program.

Still, Dale said he tries to give Trump “the maximum benefit of the doubt.” He said news outlets should give viewers and readers all the available context for Trump’s claims – in other words, how he went from A to Z.