Now playing
07:04
Stelter: Trump's racism becoming more obvious, frightening
John Avlon 0413 Wallace
CNN
John Avlon 0413 Wallace
Now playing
03:31
Avlon compares Tucker Carlson's comments to George Wallace
Fox News/Twitter
Now playing
01:33
ADL wants Fox News to fire Tucker Carlson over racist comments
Now playing
01:54
'You think I'm racist': Former Fox News host storms off camera
CNN
Now playing
03:37
'The fraud is this farce': Cuomo calls out Fox News host
CNN
Now playing
05:00
Watch Alisyn Camerota sign-off CNN's New Day
Camerota Berman both
CNN
Camerota Berman both
Now playing
02:33
CNN anchor Alisyn Camerota gets surprise tribute from co-anchor
CNN/HBO/"Q: Into the Storm"
Now playing
05:35
Filmmaker says he potentially uncovered man behind QAnon
BOSTON, MA - AUGUST 30:  Anti-vaccine activists hold up signs during a protest in front of the Massachusetts State House against Governor Charlie Baker's mandate that all Massachusetts school students enrolled in child care, pre-school, K-12, and post-secondary institutions must receive the flu vaccine this year on August 30, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts.  (Photo by Scott Eisen/Getty Images)
Scott Eisen/Getty Images
BOSTON, MA - AUGUST 30: Anti-vaccine activists hold up signs during a protest in front of the Massachusetts State House against Governor Charlie Baker's mandate that all Massachusetts school students enrolled in child care, pre-school, K-12, and post-secondary institutions must receive the flu vaccine this year on August 30, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Scott Eisen/Getty Images)
Now playing
03:06
Research exec: Far-right groups pushing vaccine as 'mark of the beast'
stelter chauvin trial international coverage kethevane gorjestani sot rs vpx_00000000.png
stelter chauvin trial international coverage kethevane gorjestani sot rs vpx_00000000.png
Now playing
02:19
How the rest of the world is covering the Derek Chauvin trial
CBS This Morning
Now playing
01:57
Hunter Biden makes rare comment about seized laptop
Fox News
Now playing
03:43
Tucker Carlson's interview with Gaetz gets uncomfortable
NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 09: News headlines on the impeachment trial of Donald Trump are displayed outside of the Fox headquarters on February 09, 2021 in New York City. After listening to nearly four hours of legal arguments, the Senate has voted on Tuesday to move ahead with the impeachment trial of former President Trump. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 09: News headlines on the impeachment trial of Donald Trump are displayed outside of the Fox headquarters on February 09, 2021 in New York City. After listening to nearly four hours of legal arguments, the Senate has voted on Tuesday to move ahead with the impeachment trial of former President Trump. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Now playing
04:03
Dominion Voting Systems files $1.6 billion lawsuit against Fox News
 President Donald Trump waves as he departs on the South Lawn of the White House, on December 12, 2020 in Washington, DC.
Al Drago/Getty Images
President Donald Trump waves as he departs on the South Lawn of the White House, on December 12, 2020 in Washington, DC.
Now playing
01:35
Trump praises Capitol rioters 'hugging and kissing the police'
Now playing
01:33
Meghan McCain is, again, in the hot seat over diversity comments
Now playing
01:51
John Oliver calls out Meghan McCain's response to Atlanta shootings
(CNN Business) —  

A version of this article first appeared in the “Reliable Sources” newsletter. You can sign up for free right here.

Peter Beinart on “CNN Tonight” on Thursday: “This is a struggle about the identity of the United States.”

“So apparently,” David Brooks writes in Friday’s NYT, “Donald Trump wants to make this an election about what it means to be American. He’s got his vision of what it means to be American, and he’s challenging the rest of us to come up with a better one.” This is the big story, but it’s incredibly hard to tell in day-of news stories and 90-second-long TV packages…

“Tell them to leave”

On Thursday Trump tried to convince everyone that he didn’t like it when his fans chanted “send her back” against Rep. Ilhan Omar.

Did anyone believe him? Anyone?

This is one of those times when there are multiple ways to dispute the president’s claim…

1: TV news anchors played the tape from Wednesday’s rally to show just how long he soaked up the chants. (Thirteen seconds.) So did late-night comics. NBC’s Seth Meyers called Trump’s disavowal “an obvious lie.”

2: Friday’s front page of the NYT shows what Trump tweeted when he arrived back in DC after the rally. “What a crowd, and what great people,” he wrote. “The enthusiasm blows away our rivals on the Radical Left.”

3: I think there’s another moment from the rally, twelve minutes after the chant, that speaks volumes. “If they don’t like it, let them leave. Let them leave,” he told the crowd. “They are always telling us how to run it, how to do this. You know what? If they don’t love it, TELL THEM to leave it.” He heard the crowd say “send her back,” and then he endorsed the chant…

4: The bottom line, as written by WaPo’s Ashley Parker: “Trump may have aimed for deniability — but his supporters seemed to know what he meant…”

Sean Hannity’s spin

He actually said this on Thursday night: “I don’t think they were saying ‘send her back” as much as they’re saying, ‘these views are repugnant.’”

2020 frame is not ‘racists vs. socialists,’ but ‘democracy vs. anti-democracy’

CNN’s Eve Bower writes: In his newsletter “The Editorial Board” on Thursday, John Stoehr responded to Lisa Mascaro’s analysis in the AP of an emerging editorial frame for the 2020 campaign. Stoehr wrote that Trump’s tweets imagine an “in-group” status for Trump and his supporters, and an “out-group” status for the four congresswomen Trump depicts as being “foreign” and having “vicious” motives in their policymaking and speech. But “when you believe the out-group always has malign intent, no disagreement can be tolerated. If there is no disagreement, it’s a democracy in name only. So if you chant send her back!, you aren’t just being horribly racist. You’re saying democracy is dead to you,” Stoehr wrote.

For these reasons, one colleague told me, it is not enough for journalists to “fact-check” Trump’s tweets by noting that all four of the congresswomen are citizens, and three were born in this country. What does that have to do with this situation? As journalists who fear that norms of free speech are being eroded, shouldn’t we be the most eager to say there is no reason people who criticize a policy, a president, or an entire country, should be made to feel unwelcome in a democracy? So why does Trump want to imply otherwise?

“This is not about Omar anymore”

“Democrats now hold the House, and they are not holding Trump back,” Adam Serwer writes in his latest must-read for The Atlantic.

He says Ilhan Omar “must be defended,” regardless of any of her views, “because the nature of the president’s attack on her is a threat to all Americans — black or white, Jew or Gentile — whose citizenship, whose belonging, might similarly be questioned. This is not about Omar anymore, or the other women of color who have been told by this president to ‘go back’ to their supposed countries of origin. It is about defending the idea that America should be a country for all its people. If multiracial democrac