Now playing
04:57
Trump defends racist attacks on congresswomen
CNN
Now playing
02:02
Barr's answer draws scrutiny amid new scandal
CNN
Now playing
03:32
Watergate journalist: Trump's actions go further than Nixon's
raffensberger
CNN
raffensberger
Now playing
03:25
'This is unacceptable': Election official speaks out after threats against wife
Deep State Dogs
Now playing
03:29
See how internet sleuths are hunting down insurrectionists
Vladimir Putin NBC intv
NBC
Vladimir Putin NBC intv
Now playing
04:22
Hear how Putin compared Donald Trump to Joe Biden
Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger speaks during a news conference on Wednesday, November 11, 2020, in Atlanta.
Brynn Anderson/AP
Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger speaks during a news conference on Wednesday, November 11, 2020, in Atlanta.
Now playing
02:35
Family of GA secretary of state got death threats months after election
Pennsylvania State House
Now playing
02:04
Pennsylvania lawmaker to GOP: "Are you not 100 percent white?"
CNN
Now playing
01:28
'Fishing expedition': Honig slams Trump's DOJ
Getty Images/AP
Now playing
02:08
Trump runs into a problem in revenge quest against GOP governor
CNN
Now playing
02:32
Schiff reacts to DOJ subpoena: Shocked ... but not surprised
CNN
Now playing
04:38
Democratic lawmaker: Trump 'weaponized' DOJ against opponents
WASHINGTON, DC - DECEMBER 09: The Justice Department building on a foggy morning on December 9, 2019 in Washington, DC. It is expected that the Justice Department Inspector General will release his report on the investigation into the Justice and FBIs conduct during the FISA warrant process as it relates to the 2016 election today.(Photo by Samuel Corum/Getty Images)
Samuel Corum/Getty Images
WASHINGTON, DC - DECEMBER 09: The Justice Department building on a foggy morning on December 9, 2019 in Washington, DC. It is expected that the Justice Department Inspector General will release his report on the investigation into the Justice and FBIs conduct during the FISA warrant process as it relates to the 2016 election today.(Photo by Samuel Corum/Getty Images)
Now playing
00:54
Here's the biggest problem Justice Department watchdog faces
CNN
Now playing
03:05
Progressive Democrats grow frustrated with Sen. Sinema
ST IVES, ENGLAND - JUNE 10:  First Lady Jill Biden, wearing a jacket with the phrase "Love" on the back, stands outside the Carbis Bay Hotel on June 10, 2021 in St Ives, England. UK Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, will host leaders from the USA, Japan, Germany, France, Italy and Canada at the G7 Summit which begins on Friday, June 11 2021. (Photo by Toby Melville-WPA Pool/Getty Images)
Toby Melville/WPA/Getty Images
ST IVES, ENGLAND - JUNE 10: First Lady Jill Biden, wearing a jacket with the phrase "Love" on the back, stands outside the Carbis Bay Hotel on June 10, 2021 in St Ives, England. UK Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, will host leaders from the USA, Japan, Germany, France, Italy and Canada at the G7 Summit which begins on Friday, June 11 2021. (Photo by Toby Melville-WPA Pool/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:43
'It's a troll': CNN reporter on Jill Biden's 'love' jacket
WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 9: Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) speaks during a press conference at Black Lives Matter Plaza calling for an end to U.S. support for a Saudi Arabia-led blockade of Yemen on April 9, 2021 in Washington, DC. 26 year-old Iman Saleh is on her 12th day of a hunger strike for Yemen in Washington, DC. Millions of Yemenis, including children, are on the edge of famine, which some attribute partially to the blockade that has choked the delivery of food and fuel into the country. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Drew Angerer/Getty Images
WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 9: Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) speaks during a press conference at Black Lives Matter Plaza calling for an end to U.S. support for a Saudi Arabia-led blockade of Yemen on April 9, 2021 in Washington, DC. 26 year-old Iman Saleh is on her 12th day of a hunger strike for Yemen in Washington, DC. Millions of Yemenis, including children, are on the edge of famine, which some attribute partially to the blockade that has choked the delivery of food and fuel into the country. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Now playing
03:15
Jewish House Dems condemn Rep. Omar's controversial comments
CNN —  

President Trump’s critics may not like to admit it, but there’s an element of truth in the racist tweets he sent this weekend.

Trump told four nonwhite Democratic congresswomen that they should “go back” to the “crime infested places” where they came from, even though three of the four were born in the US and the fourth is a naturalized citizen.

Critics pounced. But in some ways those four lawmakers – Democratic Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez , Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib and Ayanna Pressley – really do belong to another country.

In one America, people react with shock when a President issues vile racist tweets against women lawmakers. In the other America, people say nothing.

In one America, people speak out in protest after a President claims that African, Haitian, and Salvadoran immigrants come from “sh**hole” countries. In the other America, people nod in agreement.

In one America, people become outraged when administration officials snatch migrant children from their mothers’ arms and detain them for weeks in filthy conditions with no repercussions. In the other America, people remain silent.

And in one America, people condemn a President for describing protestors alongside neo-Nazis as “very fine people.” In the other America, people shrug.

Trump’s tweets show a keen understanding of America

It’s been said that Trump’s comments about immigrants reveal that he really doesn’t understand America. The US was built on the concept of a melting pot, and immigrants are making the nation stronger, some say.

01:35 - Source: CNN
Tlaib: We know this is who Trump is

But Trump’s recent tweets could show that he understands America better than his critics realize.

These two Americas have long co-existed.

One is the country represented by the Statue of Liberty, and its invitation to poor and tired immigrants “yearning to breathe free.”

The other is the one that virtually wiped out Native Americans, enslaved Africans, excluded Chinese immigrants in the late 19th century and put Japanese Americans in concentration camps.

From the rarified perch of the White House, Trump’s racist tweets tap into the id of this other America.

And here’s what’s so frightening about this: It is not a big stretch to say that when a leader uses the kind of language that Trump uses against minorities, it may increase the chances of violence being used against them.

I recall what Mark Naison, a historian at Fordham University, told me after the Charlottesville violence in 2017 when talking about Trump’s racial rhetoric.

He says most Americans don’t realize how dangerous it is for a leader to talk about fellow citizens as if they’re the enemy. But some people from other countries know.

04:02 - Source: CNN
Pressley on Trump's attacks: Don't take the bait

Naison recalled a conversation he once had with some Trump supporters.

“I told these guys, ‘You can’t control this. You’re playing with fire,’” Naison says. “Open violent communal warfare is scary. You can’t control it. Look at what happened in the Balkans, Northern Ireland, Israel.”

The United States must become one thing or the other

Historical analogies, of course, are tricky.

I’ve heard commentators say we’re on the verge of a second Civil War. That makes a mockery of the carnage of that war, where at least 600,000 Americans were killed.

Yet there is another 19th-century parallel that resonates. One commentator recently said we’re on the brink of a “political civil war.”

That comment evoked another era that reminds me of this one – the decades running up to the Civil War.

02:18 - Source: CNN
Trump claims he gave 'perfect answer' on Charlottesville

Then, as now, we were splitting into two different countries. Political compromise was impossible on another issue that revolved around American identity – slavery. Congressional lawmakers carried pistols on the House and Senate floors.

The impending Civil War was described as “irrepressible conflict” – the nation would become either a slave-holding nation or a free-labor country. There was no middle ground.

That period also saw the rise of the nation’s first anti-immigration party. They were called the “The American Party,” otherwise known as the “Know-Nothings.” They blamed Irish and German immigrants for rising crime and poverty rates, and riots erupted across America in the 1840s and ‘50s.

“Party members tended to come from the working classes and had a strong anti-elitist bent,” Amy Briggs wrote in National Geographic. “Their platform sought to limit immigration and the influence of Catholicism, and they used ugly ethnic stereotypes to stir up hatred against the recent German and Irish arrivals.”

07:04 - Source: CNN
Stelter: Trump's racism becoming more obvious, frightening

Trump’s tweets show we are now in the middle of another “irrepressible conflict.” We can’t forever be a country that prides itself for welcoming immigrants and religious diversity while also being one that puts immigrant children in cages and shrugs when our President makes racist statements.

To paraphrase another President – Abraham Lincoln – we eventually “will become all one thing or all the other.”

We can become what one scholar called a “compassionate, multireligious, multiracial democracy.”

Or we can become what another called a “hollowed out” democracy, where one ethnic group rules the rest.

The outrage over Trump’s tweets will eventually fade. But the choice his racial rhetoric presents to America will be with us for years to come.