RENTON, WA - MARCH 14: Boeing 737 MAX airplanes, including the 737 MAX 9 test plane (L), are seen at Renton Municipal Airport, on March 14, 2019 in Renton, Washington. The 737 MAX, Boeing's newest model, has been been grounded by aviation authorities throughout the world after the crash of an Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX 8 on March 10.  (Photo by Stephen Brashear/Getty Images)
Stephen Brashear/Getty Images North America/Getty Images
RENTON, WA - MARCH 14: Boeing 737 MAX airplanes, including the 737 MAX 9 test plane (L), are seen at Renton Municipal Airport, on March 14, 2019 in Renton, Washington. The 737 MAX, Boeing's newest model, has been been grounded by aviation authorities throughout the world after the crash of an Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX 8 on March 10. (Photo by Stephen Brashear/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:55
Report: Pilots raced for manuals as plane went down
Anthony Blinken BBC intv
BBC
Anthony Blinken BBC intv
Now playing
03:27
Blinken: US will respond if Russia acts recklessly against Ukraine
Now playing
02:50
Brazil says it's ready to end deforestation in Amazon. But there's a price tag
The trial of the two US citizens charged with the murder of Italian police officer Mario Cerciello in July 2019 has concluded and a verdict is expected.
AFP
The trial of the two US citizens charged with the murder of Italian police officer Mario Cerciello in July 2019 has concluded and a verdict is expected.
Now playing
02:49
Italy charged two Californians with murder. Here are the case details
screengrab myanmar training
Reuters
screengrab myanmar training
Now playing
02:30
In Myanmar's jungles, protesters are training to fight the junta
Reuters
Now playing
01:50
Controversy around Ethiopia's Nile River dam project explained
Mexico C5 security system
Now playing
01:56
Video shows moment Mexico City metro overpass collapses
south africa cash in transit heist attempt pretoria McKenzie DNT intl ldn vpx_00004113.png
CIT Dashcam Video
south africa cash in transit heist attempt pretoria McKenzie DNT intl ldn vpx_00004113.png
Now playing
01:29
Gunmen with AK-47s ambushed cash-in-transit van. See how security team reacted
CNN
Now playing
04:59
Rare access to Ukrainian patrol boat challenging Russian navy
uruguay peoples pots feed hungry coronavirus pandemic romo pkg vpx_00000109.png
uruguay peoples pots feed hungry coronavirus pandemic romo pkg vpx_00000109.png
Now playing
02:24
This group of volunteers is on a noble mission amid pandemic
Now playing
01:21
Watch octopuses change color while they sleep
CNN
Now playing
05:00
Striking oil here could be worth billions of dollars. Not everyone is happy
screengrab myanmar journalist
DVB
screengrab myanmar journalist
Now playing
03:13
Myanmar's journalists face 'humanitarian crisis' as crackdown intensifies
Reuters
Now playing
04:19
Social media footage shows crush in Israel
screengrab myanmar thailand border
Karen National Union
screengrab myanmar thailand border
Now playing
03:06
Rare footage shows gun battle at Myanmar-Thailand border
Now playing
01:04
See Beijing launch key component of planned space station
(CNN) —  

Pilots transitioning to the Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft from older 737 models were given a short, self-administered online course that made no mention of a new system now at the center of two crash investigations, pilots’ unions spokesmen for two American carriers told CNN.

Pilots of Southwest Airlines and American Airlines took courses – lasting between 56 minutes and three hours – that highlighted differences between the Max 8 and older 737s, but did not explain the new maneuvering characteristics augmentation system, know as MCAS, the spokesmen said.

The system, designed to automatically command a plane to pitch down if it senses an imminent stall, has become the focus of October’s Lion Air crash of a 737 Max 8, and experts say it could become a major factor in the Ethiopian Airlines crash that killed 157 people earlier this month.

“The course was not instructor-led. It was self-administered,” said Mike Trevino, a spokesman for the union that represents pilots of Southwest Airlines. The set course took pilots approximately three hours to complete, Trevino said. The 8,500 pilots of Southwest Airlines exclusively fly the 737, and it is the world’s largest operator of the 737 Max 8, employing 34 of the aircraft.

“MCAS was installed in the aircraft and Boeing didn’t disclose that to the pilots,” said Trevino, while adding that Southwest pilots are experienced with 737s. “It’s not flying a whole new aircraft. It’s still a 737.”

Boeing has not responded to multiple requests for comment.

737 Max 8 transition courses did not explain the new maneuvering characteristics augmentation sysmtem which is at the center of two crash investigations, according to pilots' unions.
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
737 Max 8 transition courses did not explain the new maneuvering characteristics augmentation sysmtem which is at the center of two crash investigations, according to pilots' unions.

Hands-on experience needed

In the wake of the fatal crashes, some pilots are demanding additional training on the 737 Max series aircraft, in the form of both ground school and flight simulator time.

“This is ridiculous,” said Captain Dennis Tajer, a representative of the Allied Pilots Association, which represents 15,000 American Airlines pilots. “If you’re going to have equipment on the airplane that we didn’t know about, and we’re going to be responsible for battling it if it fails, then we need to have hands-on experience.”

The self-administered transition course for American Airlines pilots was a 56-minute online course, Tajer said, which he completed on his iPad. It was broken up into four broad sections, including a general description of changes to the aircraft, its engines, and its instrument panel. But an explanation or even an acknowledgement of the MCAS system was again missing, Tajer said.

“(The transition course) usually works. It works for us. We have pilots who have a lot of experience. When I need to do a little more study, I know where to go. And if I was to go to that place, the MCAS wasn’t even there.”

Boeing develops the courses with each individual airline, which is why Southwest’s transition training course was longer than the course for American Airlines. But Trevino and Tajer say both failed to mention or explain the MCAS system.

On November 27, one month after the Lion Air crash, the American Airlines pilots’ union met with Boeing representatives in Texas to convey “serious concerns about the issues raised by the Lion Air 737 Max accident and ongoing investigation,” according to a statement from the union.

The MCAS system is less familiar to pilots and may have casued confusion in the event of emergency situations.
Stephen Brashear/Getty Images North America
The MCAS system is less familiar to pilots and may have casued confusion in the event of emergency situations.

Part of that discussion focused on the software that triggers the MCAS system, Tajer said.

Because the FAA certified the 737 Max series to be flown without requiring simulator time, Tajer said it will be difficult to demand simulator experience before flying the aircraft. American Airlines is working to have 737 Max simulators in place by the end of the year, added Tajer. In the interim, he noted that American Airlines pilots have received intense ground school on the MCAS following the Lion Air crash.

In response to October’s Lion Air crash, Boeing has developed a software patch and a pilot training program to address the issues from the fatal flight, the Federal Aviation Administration said in an airworthiness directive Wednesday.

“The FAA’s ongoing review of this software installation and training is an agency priority, as will be the roll-out of any software, training, or other measures to operators of the 737 MAX,” the directive said.

Potential cause of confusion

Neil Hansford, an Australian aviation safety consultant who runs Strategic Aviation Solutions, condemned Boeing and the FAA for allowing such simplified courses. Even with the similarities between the 737 Max 8 and previous models of the popular airline, Hansford says aviation regulators should require ground school, at least 20 hours in a simulator, and a series of check rides to establish proficiency in the new aircraft.

Transition training through courses and bulletins has been permitted before, says John Cox, a veteran airline pilot and aviation safety expert who runs Safety Operating Systems. In cases where a pilot was moving between different models of the same or very similar aircraft, such courses could suffice without additional check rides, he said. For example, a pilot permitted to fly certain models of 757 is also qualified to fly certain models of the larger 767. But Cox says any new system should definitely be explained in transition courses.

A Lion Air 737 Max 8 aircraft crashed in October last year shortly after taking off from Jakarta, killing all 189 people on board.
ADEK BERRY/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
A Lion Air 737 Max 8 aircraft crashed in October last year shortly after taking off from Jakarta, killing all 189 people on board.

“In retrospect, knowing what we know now about the MCAS, I think that everybody or a significant number of people would have said additional training would have been a good idea,” Cox said.

Cox points to the similarities between two systems on board a 737 Max 8 series as a potential cause of confusion for pilots: The MCAS and runaway trim. Both can cause an airplane to nose down, but Cox says 737 pilots know how to deal with a runaway trim from years of experience.

The MCAS – new to the 737 Max series – is a less familiar system to pilots. In an emergency situation, with multiple in-flight warnings, Cox says it could be difficult to correctly diagnose the MCAS as the problematic system.

“I think everybody has been surprised at the possibilities of how MCAS could cause a problem,” Cox said. “I don’t think Boeing computed it that way. I don’t think their analysis showed that this was likely, and I think they convinced themselves and the FAA that this was a minor change from a pilot’s standpoint.”

The fallout from the two fatal crashes has shaken some pilots’ trust in Boeing and the FAA.

“If the FAA says it’s safe, Boeing says it’s safe, our airlines say it’s safe, we are the ones who have to stand there with them and say we agree… or we don’t agree,” said Tajer. “We want to say yes, but we will not be forced to say yes. I’m on that airplane as the last line of defense for our passengers.”