Venezuela crisis: Putin’s new Cold War on America’s doorstep?
Analysis by Nathan Hodge, CNN
Updated
1:48 AM EST, Sat February 2, 2019
Russian President Vladimir Putin (R) shakes hands with his Venezuelan counterpart Nicolas Maduro during a meeting at the Novo-Ogaryovo state residence outside Moscow on December 5, 2018. (Photo by MAXIM SHEMETOV / POOL / AFP) (Photo credit should read MAXIM SHEMETOV/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO:
MAXIM SHEMETOV/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:56
Venezuela crisis may open rift between Trump, Putin
PHOTO:
Indonesia Search and Rescue Agency
Now playing
02:09
Woman who is trapped underneath earthquake's rubble captured on video
Barrie's aunt speaks about how the police brought her the news about the death of her nephew Ibrahima.
PHOTO:
VTM
Now playing
01:26
Aunt of Black man who died after arrest in Belgium: We want justice
screengrab US social media
PHOTO:
Getty Images
Now playing
04:35
Tech companies ban Trump, but not other problematic leaders
WASHINGTON, DC - JANUARY 13: Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) presides over the vote to impeach U.S. President Donald Trump for the second time in little over a year in the House Chamber of the U.S. Capitol January 13, 2021 in Washington, DC. The House voted to impeach Trump on the charge of "incitement of insurrection," 232-197 after a mob of his supporters attacked the U.S. Capitol where Congress was working to certify the Electoral College victory of President-elect Joe Biden on January 6. 10 Republicans voted to impeach. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
PHOTO:
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Now playing
02:35
How the world is reacting to Trump's second impeachment
Indonesia sriwijay air crash search for victims wang pkg intl hnk vpx_00000920.png
Now playing
02:21
Family members wait in anguish as search for crash victims continues
africa china coronavirus vaccine diplomacy lu stout pkg vpx _00025522.png
PHOTO:
CCTV
Now playing
03:09
How China is hoping to use its vaccine as a diplomatic tool
PHOTO:
CIRO FUSCO/AFP/ANSA/AFP via Getty Images
Now playing
00:38
Huge sinkhole appears in Italian hospital parking lot
TOPSHOT - Rescue workers carry recovered debris at the port in Jakarta on January 10, 2021, during the search operation for Sriwijaya Air flight SJY182 which crashed after takeoff from Jakarta on January 9. (Photo by Dany Krisnadhi / AFP) (Photo by DANY KRISNADHI/AFP via Getty Images)
PHOTO:
Dany Krisnadhi/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
02:16
Indonesian jetliner crashes after taking off from Jakarta
HONG KONG PRO DEMOCRACY ACTIVIST VENTUS LAU BEING ESCORTED BY POLICE.
PHOTO:
VENTUS LAU FACEBOOK PAGE/Reuters
Now playing
03:15
See Hong Kong police arrest former pro-democracy lawmakers
Tensions between the United States and Iran are likely to further escalate once again after Tehran seized a South Korean-flagged chemical tanker in the Persian Gulf, according to semi-official Iranian news agencies, and announced it had resumed enriching uranium to 20% purity, far beyond the limits laid out in the 2015 nuclear deal. President Donald Trump walked away from the agreement in 2018. CNN's Paula Hancocks reports.
PHOTO:
YJC
Now playing
02:37
Footage shows chemical tanker seized by Iranian forces
A European health worker prepares a shot of the coronavirus vaccine.
PHOTO:
Reuters
Now playing
02:14
Frustration in Europe over pace of coronavirus vaccine rollout
Jack Ma, the co-chair of the UN High-Level Panel on Digital Cooperation, founder of Alibaba Group, attends the Bund Summit in Shanghai. He says that the essence of finance is credit management. We must change the pawnshop idea of Finance and rely on the credit system. Shanghai, China, 24 October 2020.
Jack Ma, the co-chair of the UN High-Level Panel on Digital Cooperation, founder of Alibaba Group, attended the Bund Summit in Shanghai. He says that the essence of finance is credit management. We must change the pawnshop idea of Finance and rely on the credit system.No Use China. No Use France.
PHOTO:
Zhao Yun/Oriental Image/Reuters
Now playing
03:05
Chinese tech tycoon has not been seen in months
Now playing
02:19
Country has 2nd highest Covid-19 cases. See their vaccine plan
Swedish environmentalist Greta Thunberg arrives for a meeting at the Europa building in Brussels on March 5, 2020. (Photo by Kenzo TRIBOUILLARD / AFP) (Photo by KENZO TRIBOUILLARD/AFP via Getty Images)
PHOTO:
KENZO TRIBOUILLARD/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:24
Greta Thunberg urges public to listen to the experts (2020)
Now playing
01:00
Boris Johnson condemns Trump's actions
Bystanders and a soldier stand near a damaged portion of the airport of Yemen's southern city of Aden's after an explosion, Wednesday, Dec. 30, 2020. The blast struck the airport building shortly after a plane carrying the newly formed Cabinet landed on Wednesday. No one on the government plane was hurt. (AP Photo/Majid Saleh)
PHOTO:
Majid Saleh/AP
Now playing
02:27
See moment of deadly explosion at Yemen airport
(CNN) —
The crisis in Venezuela appears to be shaping up like a Cold War-style confrontation: The Kremlin is throwing its support behind embattled Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, while Washington backs Juan Guaido, the self-proclaimed interim president.
The story at first glance seems to have all the elements of a spy thriller. In recent days, rumors have swirled about Russian mercenaries, massive bullion shipments and murky assassination plots.
Maduro has cast himself as a latter-day Fidel Castro in this drama. In an interview with Russia’s state-owned news agency RIA-Novosti, Maduro hinted at a US-backed attempt on his life, saying, “Without a doubt, Donald Trump gave the order to kill me, told the Colombian government, the mafia of Colombia to kill me.”
That sounded like an episode ripped from one of the CIA’s failed plots to kill the Cuban leader. And the crisis carries echoes of the Cuban Missile Crisis: Late last year, Russian bombers capable of delivering nuclear weapons flew to Venezuela, signaling that Russian President Vladimir Putin was willing to play in America’s backyard.
So are we about to watch a Netflix-era remake of the 1961 Bay of Pigs invasion? Is Venezuela another arena for proxy conflict between Russia and the United States, much like the way Moscow and Washington back opposing sides in the Syrian civil war?
Certainly, Maduro’s conspiracy theories – and his language about resisting American neocolonialism – are reminiscent of the old contest between the US and the USSR in Latin America. But Russia is not backing his government in Venezuela to spread the ideology of Marxism. For starters, Moscow sees Venezuela in large part as a business proposition.
Russia’s state-controlled oil company Rosneft has been a major backer of Maduro’s government, and Russia and Rosneft have provided billions in loans and lines of credit for cash-strapped Venezuela.
Venezuelan state oil company PDVSA is covering almost all of those debts with shipments of oil. In a research paper published last year, analyst Julia Gurganus noted that Venezuela “has relied on Rosneft for prepayments of future oil deliveries to meet its financial commitments and to market physical volumes of Venezuelan crude to refiners in the United States and other countries.”
But in addition to Moscow’s economic bet on Maduro, there’s a geopolitical dimension to Russia’s interest in keeping the president in power. Russian state television in recent days has cast the Venezuela crisis in terms of US-Russian confrontation, sometimes comparing Guaido and the Venezuelan opposition to Ukraine’s pro-democratic Maidan revolution in 2014 or to the Arab Spring uprising that, among other things, toppled longtime Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi.
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Supporters of Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido wave a Venezuelan flag as they wait for him to make an appearance in the country's capital of Caracas on Monday, March 4.
PHOTO:
Matias Delacroix/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido greets supporters upon arriving at a Caracas airport on March 4. He crossed the border to Colombia in late February before embarking on a South American tour, meeting the presidents of Colombia, Brazil, Paraguay and Ecuador, along with US Vice President Mike Pence. By doing so, Guaido ignored a travel ban imposed on him by the country's Supreme Court.
PHOTO:
Carlos Jasso/REUTERS
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido shakes hands with Pence in Bogota, Colombia, on Monday, February 25. The room was filled with humanitarian aid destined for Venezuela. Guaido's wife, Fabiana Rosales, is pictured at left.
PHOTO:
Martin Mejia/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Demonstrators clash with Venezuelan soldiers at the Simon Bolivar International Bridge in Cucuta, Colombia, on Saturday, February 23.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Supporters of President Maduro take part in a march in Caracas on February 23.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido supporters take part in a march in Caracas on February 23. Venezuelan security forces fired tear gas and rubber bullets to disperse a crowd demanding to cross the Venezuela-Colombia border, which was ordered closed by Maduro.
PHOTO:
Cristian Hernandez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Demonstrators push a bus that was set on fire during clashes with the Venezuelan National Guard in Urena, Venezuela, on February 23.
PHOTO:
Rodrigo Abd/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Maduro waves the national flag during a pro-government march in Caracas on February 23. During the rally at the Venezuelan capital, Maduro told supporters he is breaking all diplomatic relations with Colombia and is calling for its ambassadors and consuls to leave Venezuela. Maduro recently began a second term after a 2018 vote that his political opposition and many in the international community denounced as a sham.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
People attempt to salvage packages from a truck loaded with humanitarian aid after it was set ablaze on a bridge between Cucuta, Colombia, and Urena, Venezuela, on February 23.
PHOTO:
Schneyder Mendoza/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Venezuelan opposition supporters protested in Caracas on Tuesday, February 12, calling on Maduro to let humanitarian aid into the economically crippled country.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido addresses the crowd in Caracas on February 12.
PHOTO:
Ariana Cubillos/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A man wearing a Venezuelan flag sits on a traffic light during the demonstration in Caracas on February 12.
PHOTO:
Ariana Cubillos/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido waves to supporters during the rally in Caracas on February 2.
PHOTO:
Marco Bello/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
An anti-government protester wears glasses with a Venezuelan flag motif at the demonstration in Caracas on February 2.
PHOTO:
Fernando Llano/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Protesters gather for the Caracas rally on February 2.
PHOTO:
Rodrigo Abd/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Maduro supporters gather in Caracas on February 2.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Opposition demonstrators protest against Maduro's government on Wednesday, January 30.
PHOTO:
JUAN BARRETO/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
In this handout photo released by the Miraflores Presidential Press Office, Maduro flashes a "V for victory" hand gesture after arriving at the Fort Tiuna military base in Caracas on January 30.
Members of the National Police line up to guard the entrance of Venezuela's Central University in Caracas during an anti-government protest on January 30.
PHOTO:
LUIS ROBAYO/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido speaks to reporters in Caracas on January 30. The United States and more than a dozen other countries have recognized Guaido as Venezuela's legitimate ruler.
PHOTO:
Ariana Cubillos/AP
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A Maduro mural is seen in the Petare slum of Caracas on Tuesday, January 29.
PHOTO:
Ignacio Marin/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido listens to deputy Rafael Veloz during a session at the National Assembly in Caracas on January 29. The Assembly met to debate a legal framework for creating a transitional government and calling new elections. Simultaneously, Venezuela's attorney general asked the Supreme Court to freeze Guaido's assets and bar him from leaving the country.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A view of the National Assembly building in Caracas on January 29.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
The president of Venezuela's Supreme Court, Maikel Moreno, speaks at a news conference in Caracas on January 29.
PHOTO:
Federico Parra/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A man pumps fuel at a gas station in Caracas on January 29. A day earlier, the United States announced sanctions against Venezuela's state oil company, Petroleos de Venezuela, S.A.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Supporters of Venezuela's opposition hold up letters that read "Justice" at a rally to hear Guaido speak in Caracas on Saturday, January 26.
PHOTO:
Federico Parra/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido speaks to reporters after attending Mass in Caracas on Sunday, January 27.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Government supporters in Caracas hold a rally in support of Maduro on January 26.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Maduro holds a news conference in Caracas on Friday, January 25. The Venezuelan strongman has accused Guaido and the United States of trying to orchestrate a coup against him.
PHOTO:
Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Portraits of former Venezuelan leaders Simon Bolivar and Hugo Chavez hover in the background as Venezuelan Defense Minister Vladimir Padrino Lopez, bottom left, addresses a news conference in Caracas on Thursday, January 24. Venezuela's top military officials swore their allegiance to Maduro after other nations recognized Guaido as head of state.
PHOTO:
Carlos Becerra/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A man wrapped in a Venezuelan flag raises his arms in front of security forces during anti-government protests in Caracas on Wednesday, January 23.
PHOTO:
Rayner Pena/picture alliance via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Opposition supporters in Caracas protest Maduro on January 23.
PHOTO:
Adriana Loureiro/REUTERS
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Opposition supporters react to tear gas as they take part in the Caracas rally on January 23. Sporadic clashes erupted, but Maduro's military response to the protests seemed more measured than in the past.
PHOTO:
Manaure Quintero/REUTERS
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Police secure an area in Caracas on January 23.
PHOTO:
Manaure Quintero/REUTERS
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A National Police officer fires rubber bullets in Caracas.
PHOTO:
Manaure Quintero/REUTERS
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
People raise their hands to show solidarity with Guaido, who was declaring himself interim president on January 23.
PHOTO:
Federico Parra/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A wounded protester in Caracas on January 23.
PHOTO:
Miguel Gutierrez/EPA-EFE
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Security forces stand in a street full of stones after clashing with demonstrators in Caracas.
PHOTO:
Rayner Pena/picture alliance via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Maduro, speaking to a crowd of supporters at the Miraflores Palace in Caracas, holds up a document that says his government is breaking off diplomatic ties with the United States. "We cannot accept the invasive policies of the empire, the United States, the policies of Donald Trump," he said to cheers from the crowd on January 23. "Venezuela is a land of liberators."
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A wounded protester shows his back as riot police clashed with opposition demonstrators in Caracas on January 23.
PHOTO:
Federico Parra/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A man walks by a bus that had been set on fire in Caracas.
PHOTO:
Luis Robayo/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
An opposition demonstrator runs with a tear-gas canister on January 23.
PHOTO:
Federico Parra/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Guaido greets a crowd in Caracas on January 23.
PHOTO:
Miguel Gutierrez/EPA-EFE
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Protesters set up barricades to block a road in Caracas.
PHOTO:
Roman Camacho/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
A National Police officer fires tear gas at demonstrators in Caracas while another shoots the scene with a cell phone.
PHOTO:
Rayner Pena/picture alliance via Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Demonstrators in Caracas protest Maduro's government.
PHOTO:
Edilzon Gamez/Getty Images
Photos: In photos: Venezuela in crisis
Venezuelan banknotes were thrown on the ground during the Maduro protests on January 23.
PHOTO:
Roman Camacho/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Russia spreads its global reach
The rhetoric mirrors official thinking in Russia, where the Kremlin routinely accuses the US of illegitimately pursuing a policy of “regime change” or “color revolutions” aimed at toppling Washington’s opponents around the globe.
“Going back to the days of [former US President] George W. Bush, color revolutions are a neuralgic issue for the Kremlin,” said Andrew Weiss, vice president for studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. “And they have no shortage of people inside the Russian government who spin elaborate conspiracy theories or see indicators that the US goes around the world under the convenient flag of democracy removing regimes it doesn’t like.”
Weiss noted another rationale for Russia’s support for Maduro: Showcasing Moscow’s global reach.
“There is also a big thread in Russia’s behavior in Latin America that is aimed at rattling the United States and making Russia’s role seem larger than it actually is,” he said. “It’s part of a headgame … a way of saying, ‘We can cause trouble in America’s backyard.’”
Venezuela is a long way from Russia’s borders, and Moscow no longer has any military bases in the Western Hemisphere. But that has done little to discourage conspiracy theories.
Maduro, for instance, did not halt speculation that Russian private military contractors may have augmented his security detail when he said that he had “no comment” about whether Russian private security guards might be providing him protection.
Russia certainly has a track record of sending private military contractors to advance its foreign-policy aims. The Russian government has never fully and officially acknowledged the existence of private military companies such as Wagner, the shadowy Russian firm the US Treasury has sanctioned for recruiting mercenaries to fight alongside pro-Russian separatists in eastern Ukraine. However, the existence of the group became more difficult to conceal after paramilitary contractors were killed in US airstrikes in Syria.
But Konstantin Kosachev, a Russian senator who heads the foreign affairs committee of Russia’s Federation Council, or upper house of parliament, cast doubt on Russians being brought in to protect Maduro.
“I don’t think that there will be a request directly for protection by Russia,” Kosachev told RIA-Novosti, adding that the army is on the side of the current president, and that Maduro himself expressed confidence that he was well defended.