Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) participates in a discussion about legislation to halt the sale of some weapons to Saudi Arabia at the Center for the National Interest September 19, 2016 in Washington, DC.
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) participates in a discussion about legislation to halt the sale of some weapons to Saudi Arabia at the Center for the National Interest September 19, 2016 in Washington, DC.
Now playing
00:46
Rand Paul assault suspect pleads not guilty
rand paul
CNN
rand paul
Now playing
03:57
Rand Paul sides with Trump over US intel
CNN
Now playing
02:03
Paul: Putin will never admit to election hack
Sen. Rand Paul speaks on Capitol Hill.
POOL
Sen. Rand Paul speaks on Capitol Hill.
Now playing
02:33
Attorney: Rand Paul attack was not political
CNN
Now playing
01:26
Rand Paul: I never wanted government shutdown
Sen. Rand Paul, Mike Pompeo nomination vote
CNN
Sen. Rand Paul, Mike Pompeo nomination vote
Now playing
01:44
Sen. Rand Paul: Pompeo has reassured me
Now playing
01:42
Paul: I'll do everything to block Trump picks
rand paul assault injuries es live_00002205.jpg
rand paul assault injuries es live_00002205.jpg
Now playing
00:40
Sen. Paul's injuries worse than first reported
CNN
Now playing
00:40
Sen. Rand Paul assaulted in Kentucky home
Travel Pool material of President Trump motorcading to and from his golf outing today, plus a read-out from Sen. Rand Paul    Note from the travel pool producer:  President Trump and Sen. Paul stayed in the SUV for a few minutes before disembarking.   After that, the senator gave a brief readout of their time together (on-camera). He said they discussed tax reform and health care (Paul also praised the president's golf game).
Pool
Travel Pool material of President Trump motorcading to and from his golf outing today, plus a read-out from Sen. Rand Paul Note from the travel pool producer: President Trump and Sen. Paul stayed in the SUV for a few minutes before disembarking. After that, the senator gave a brief readout of their time together (on-camera). He said they discussed tax reform and health care (Paul also praised the president's golf game).
Now playing
00:42
Rand Paul says Trump beat him at golf
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Now playing
01:46
What's the difference between Ron Paul and Rand Paul?
rand paul
CNN
rand paul
Now playing
01:30
Rand Paul on GOP bill: Start small and build
CNN
Now playing
01:11
Rand Paul insists on 'clean repeal vote'
Now playing
01:21
Rand Paul cautions Trump not to pardon family
Now playing
00:58
Paul: 'Stupidity' preventing a Syria solution
AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:13
President Trump and Rand Paul before the thaw
(CNN) —  

The story of Rand Paul allegedly being attacked by a neighbor – and breaking six ribs in the process – is strange on its face.

The initial explanation offered by some neighbors of both men and the attacker’s lawyer – that the episode occurred due to a dispute over leaves or grass trimmings – was even stranger.

Rene Boucher pleaded not guilty Thursday morning in a Bowling Green courtroom to misdemeanor fourth degree assault charges stemming from the Nov. 3 incident in the gated community where the two men live.

Paul’s decision on Wednesday night to tweet two stories – one from Breitbart, the other from the Washington Examiner – that call into question the flora and fauna explanation is even stranger still.

Both stories feature quotes from other neighbors insisting that the initial reporting that this attack was the result of a “landscaping dispute” (how amazing is that phrase?) is, in fact, fake news.

“The stories of a ‘landscaping dispute’ or a dispute of any sort between Rand Paul and Rene Boucher are erroneous and unfounded,” a Paul neighbor named Travis Creed told the Washington Examiner. “The reason for Mr. Boucher’s bizarre attack is known only to him. Statements to the contrary are irresponsible and unnecessary.”

The two stories – which have lots of similarities, including the quote above from Creed – appear to represent a concerted effort by Paul allies to not only raise questions about the current story of the attack but also suggest that the real motivations of Paul’s attacker were political.

To that point, here’s the lede of the Washington Examiner story:

“The Bowling Green, Ky., neighbor who allegedly attacked Sen. Rand Paul last weekend, causing six broken ribs, was aggressively anti-Trump and anti-GOP in his social media, calling for the impeachment of the president and urging Russia investigator Robert Mueller to ‘fry Trump’s gonads.’”

“Captured screen grabs of Rene Boucher’s Facebook page provided to Secrets and taken down since the event also show that the anesthesiologist was a fan of the #NeverTrump clan.”

Paul himself has not said anything publicly about what he believes the motive was for the attack. But, his retweets – from his official Senate account no less! – suggest he sees things very differently than the public narrative.

That narrative was initially set by a lawyer for Boucher. In explaining the attack, lawyer Matthew Baker said:

“Senator Paul and Dr. Boucher have been next door neighbors for 17 years. The unfortunate occurrence of November 3rd has absolutely nothing to do with either’s politics or political agendas. It was a very regrettable dispute between two neighbors over a matter that most people would regard as trivial.”

So, what the heck is actually going on here? Was it a landscaping dispute? Was it that Boucher didn’t like Paul’s politics? And what exactly is a “matter that most people would regard as trivial?”

What we know is that we have a US senator who was attacked outside his home by a neighbor, an attack so severe that Paul has six broken ribs and, according to his Twitter feed, a “pleural effusion.”

The “why” is the part on which there is much dispute. Which is kind of crazy if you think about it.

Update at 1:05 p.m. ET – In a new statement to CNN’s Drew Griffin, Paul’s attorney Doug Stafford called the incident “a serious criminal matter involving serious injury.” He said both local and federal authorities are looking into it and added the two men had not spoken for years beforehand.

“This was not a ‘fight,’ it was a blindside, violent attack by a disturbed person. Anyone claiming otherwise is either uninformed or seeking media attention.”