Rex Tillerson
PHOTO: CNN
Rex Tillerson
Now playing
02:18
Rex Tillerson addresses rumors on quitting
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson makes a statement to the press at the State Department in Washington, DC, October 4, 2017.
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson denied Wednesday he had considered resigning from Donald Trump's cabinet and dismissed a report that he had called the president a "moron" as "petty nonsense." "The vice president has never had to persuade me to remain as secretary of state because I have never considered leaving this post," Tillerson said, denying an NBC News report.
 / AFP PHOTO / JIM WATSON        (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson makes a statement to the press at the State Department in Washington, DC, October 4, 2017. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson denied Wednesday he had considered resigning from Donald Trump's cabinet and dismissed a report that he had called the president a "moron" as "petty nonsense." "The vice president has never had to persuade me to remain as secretary of state because I have never considered leaving this post," Tillerson said, denying an NBC News report. / AFP PHOTO / JIM WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:30
Did Tillerson just take a veiled shot at Trump?
US President Donald Trump speaks alongside Secretary of State Rex Tillerson (L) during a Cabinet Meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, DC, October 16, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB        (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
US President Donald Trump speaks alongside Secretary of State Rex Tillerson (L) during a Cabinet Meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, DC, October 16, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:34
Trump fires Tillerson, hints at more changes
TILLERSON: MY HOPE YOU WILL BE GUIDED BY VALUES -
PHOTO: CNN
TILLERSON: MY HOPE YOU WILL BE GUIDED BY VALUES -
Now playing
01:58
Tillerson: Washington a 'mean-spirited town'
PHOTO: pool
Now playing
01:44
Tillerson speaks after being fired
Tillerson statement 03132018
PHOTO: POOL
Tillerson statement 03132018
Now playing
00:37
Tillerson calls out 'troubling' Russia actions
PHOTO: cnn
Now playing
00:37
Rex Tillerson: I'll be here for all of 2018
tillerson trump tenure orig vstan me_00000423.jpg
tillerson trump tenure orig vstan me_00000423.jpg
Now playing
01:50
Trump and Tillerson's tense relationship
PHOTO: CNN
Now playing
00:29
Tillerson calls resignation rumors 'laughable'
US President Donald Trump speaks alongside Secretary of State Rex Tillerson (L) during a Cabinet Meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, DC, October 16, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB        (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
US President Donald Trump speaks alongside Secretary of State Rex Tillerson (L) during a Cabinet Meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, DC, October 16, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:56
Source: WH wanted to publicly shame Tillerson
Now playing
02:19
Tapper to Tillerson: Did you call Trump a moron?
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson pauses during a briefing at the Department of State   on August 22, 2017 in Washington, DC.
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson acknowledged Tuesday that North Korea has shown a "level of restraint" in not conducting nuclear or missile tests since new UN sanctions were imposed. And he expressed the hope that it was a sign of Pyongyang's readiness to enter peace and disarmament talks with Washington "sometime in the near future."
 / AFP PHOTO / Brendan Smialowski        (Photo credit should read BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson pauses during a briefing at the Department of State on August 22, 2017 in Washington, DC. US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson acknowledged Tuesday that North Korea has shown a "level of restraint" in not conducting nuclear or missile tests since new UN sanctions were imposed. And he expressed the hope that it was a sign of Pyongyang's readiness to enter peace and disarmament talks with Washington "sometime in the near future." / AFP PHOTO / Brendan Smialowski (Photo credit should read BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:25
Tillerson under fire for turmoil at State Dept.
Now playing
01:30
Corker: Tillerson not getting support he needs
Now playing
00:20
Trump: Total confidence in Rex Tillerson
rex tillerson non answers origwx bw_00000000.jpg
rex tillerson non answers origwx bw_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:18
Rex Tillerson perfects the non-answer

Story highlights

Miller and Sokolsky: Secretary of State Rex Tillerson clearly doesn't plan to resign

But he faces a difficult road ahead, as the President continues to undermine his authority and legitimacy, write Miller and Sokolsky

Editor’s Note: Aaron David Miller is a vice president and distinguished scholar at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars and author of “The End of Greatness: Why America Can’t Have (and Doesn’t Want) Another Great President.” Miller was a Middle East negotiator in Democratic and Republican administrations. Follow him @aarondmiller2. Richard Sokolsky is a non-resident senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. From 2005-2015, he served as a member of the Secretary of State’s Office of Policy Planning. The views expressed in this commentary are their own.

(CNN) —  

Secretary of State Rex Tillerson made a remarkable statement on Wednesday, rejecting reports he had considered resigning and reaffirming his commitment to the President’s domestic and foreign policies. This was both stunning and unprecedented. It was not quite a hostage video, but it seemed awkward that a secretary of state felt compelled to defend himself in response to a press report.

Indeed, Tillerson has good instincts on many foreign policy issues and is ready to provide independent advice. But his road ahead won’t be easy, particularly given that Donald Trump is ready and willing to undercut him.

Still, Tillerson clearly doesn’t plan to resign, despite an NBC report that he referred to the President as a “moron” – a claim his spokeswoman denies. And even if he did, it might not matter much who succeeded him. Unless the bureaucratic environment in Trumpland changes, his successor will likely confront the same challenges Tillerson is facing now.

So, what are these challenges?

First, our decades of experience in the Department of State allow us to report that the dynamic playing out now between the President and Tillerson has not existed before in modern US foreign policy history. Granted, Tillerson has not helped himself. He was not necessarily the President’s first choice, lacks Washington experience, has an aversion to the media and has some misplaced priorities in how he has tried to reform the State Department.

But none of this can explain the current level of dysfunction that exists between the two. Secretaries of state and presidents have argued privately before over process and substance. But it’s rare – indeed unprecedented – that these differences surface publicly. In the modern period, only two secretaries of state have resigned over principle: William Jennings Bryan in 1915, over Woodrow Wilson’s policies toward Germany in the run-up to World War I, and Cyrus Vance in 1980, in opposition to Jimmy Carter’s efforts to rescue the American hostages in Iran.

And that there is serious talk of Tillerson’s resignation less than 10 months into his tenure is shocking. Since the 1950s, only two secretaries of state have had significantly abbreviated tenures: Edmund Muskie, who served out the remainder of Vance’s term, and Alexander Haig, who left early because of inter-cabinet tensions generated by his brash style. While Muskie served just shy of a year, Haig served for a year and a half before his departure.

Second, that the President would mishandle and undermine his secretary of state at a time when the world is filled with foreign policy challenges – indeed crises that require 24/7 focus and attention – is also without precedent. And whatever Tillerson’s flaws and failings, when it comes to matters of substance, such as recertifying the Iran deal, not picking sides in the Saudi-Qatar cold war, or probing diplomatic options on North Korea, his instincts are far sounder than the President’s.

And yet Trump has consistently undermined – even humiliated – his top diplomat on these issues, most recently tweeting that Tillerson was wasting his time on North Korea. It would be one thing if the President were experienced in foreign policy or had other advisers who had both experience and influence on these issues. Both Secretary of Defense James Mattis and National Security Adviser HR McMaster have plenty of experience (though in national security and war-making – not in diplomacy). But even their influence is limited.

President Richard Nixon and National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger cut Secretary of State William Rogers out of many of the decisions on China and the Middle East. But they had the experience to make foreign policy decisions. Unfortunately, there is no other go-to person with diplomatic experience in Trump’s administration.

Third, whatever responsibility Tillerson bears for his own misfortunes, he simply cannot function effectively as the nation’s top diplomat unless the President makes it unmistakably clear that the secretary of state is his sole repository of authority and public voice when it comes to foreign policy. It takes Washington and the world all of five seconds to figure out when there’s daylight between the two. And once that’s established, you might as well hang a “closed for the season” sign on the secretary’s door.

Get our free weekly newsletter

The truth is Trump has not even tried to grant Tillerson this kind of authority. In fact, he has done the opposite, assigning key foreign policy briefs to others – such as Jared Kushner, who is charged with handling the Arab-Israeli negotiations – and allowed individuals, including UN Ambassador Nikki Haley, to speak on a variety of issues – from Iran to Syria – as a de facto secretary of state.

Finally, we’d argue that even if Tillerson departed, it might not change much. The challenge for any secretary of state is the diminishing role of the State Department as the Defense Department and National Security Council play larger roles. (The other challenge is in confronting the cruel and unforgiving world, which has problems seemingly without solutions.)

But the real dysfunction begins at the top. And we wonder whether personal and substantive differences may have reached a point of no return. The combination of a thin-skinned President and reports like Tillerson’s alleged “moron” comment, combined with substantive differences on a variety of foreign policy issues, may have compromised Tillerson’s effectiveness.

We hope not. But we increasingly wonder whether there’s really room for Tillerson in the volatile world that’s Trumpland.