The US has been in Afghanistan for almost 16 years
Candidate Trump was skeptical of the need for a US presence there
President Donald Trump is set to announce the newest chapter in the US war in Afghanistan with an expected troop increase, a pointed focus on counterterrorism that involves regional actors, and a drive to push Pakistan to do more about terrorist groups operating within its borders.
The new strategy, which Trump will unveil in a national address at 9 p.m. Monday, has taken months to hammer down as White House officials battled over which way to take American involvement in the South Asian country.
The war has cost almost 2,300 US lives, billions of dollars, and yielded middling success since President George W. Bush launched it in October 2001. After almost 16 years, the Taliban now controls more territory than it did when the US first entered Afghanistan.
Those factors led candidate Trump to question the US presence there, a stance that recently ousted chief strategist Stephen Bannon endorsed against virtually all the President’s senior national security officials, who argued for continued engagement.
But now, after reviewing a series of options, including a complete withdrawal, the President is reportedly set to unveil a broad approach that includes a troop increase of about 4,000. He is expected to cast that step, along with the focus on counterterrorism and Pakistan, as a concrete way of making good on his “America First” commitment to protect the US from terrorism.
“It’s not about the numbers,” said James Carafano, a vice president for foreign and defense policy at the Heritage Foundation, speaking about the expected increase in troops. “It’s where they are and what they’re doing that’s important.”
Alyssa Ayres, a senior fellow for India, Pakistan and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations, says that Trump’s expected focus on “terrorist sanctuaries in Pakistan” will be crucial. “We can’t have a successful state in Afghanistan unless things change in Pakistan,” Ayres said.
State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said Secretary of State Rex Tillerson spoke Monday with Pakistani Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, Indian Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj and Afghan Foreign Minister Salahuddin Rabbani to outline how the US would like to work with each country to stabilize South Asia through “a new, integrated regional strategy.”
Analysts say the new policy emphasis could re-focus political and military attention on what could be called the United States’ longest-running military conflict, one that has often seemed like a morass. High-level attention drifted when the US launched the Iraq War. And under President Barack Obama, the US announced a surge alongside a plan to leave – a step critics considered a huge mistake as it allowed the Taliban to simply wait Washington out.
A troop increase ahead
To this point, “some might say there’s been no thought to a truly effective strategy to allow the US and NATO to do damage,” said Michael Kugelman, deputy director of the Asia Program at the Wilson Center.
So what could Trump’s new, expected strategy accomplish?
Additional troops, above current levels of about 8,500, would serve very specific purposes, Pentagon officials tell CNN, boosting training, capacity-building and allowing advisers to work more closely with Afghan troops along the front lines.
The increase was effectively approved in June, when Trump gave Defense Secretary James Mattis the go-ahead to boost levels by as many as 3,900 troops. Mattis, however, has waited to act until there was a broader strategic framework to work within.
US commanders would bring in additional advisers to support Afghan special forces, the Afghan air force, and the Afghan army and police professional schools, such as the infantry and artillery schools.
The Afghan government wants coalition backing to double the number of Afghan commandos and special forces, which have been stretched thin. “The Afghan Special Forces have been singled out as the crown jewel – more disciplined, efficient, effective than any other unit of the Afghan forces, but they’ve been over extended and overused,” Kugelman said.
Pentagon officials estimate the special forces and commandos perform 70% of offensive operations. A few thousand more US troops would the allow for the capacity to focus on the special forces and boost their numbers, which hover around 12,000.