01:29 - Source: CNN
Northwestern professor caught after manhunt

Story highlights

Killing not "domestic in nature," detective says; "It was a little bit more dark and disturbing"

Both suspects held without bond after judge hears sex fantasy allegations, affiliate reports

CNN —  

Police have formally charged a former Northwestern University professor and an Oxford University employee with first-degree murder in the July stabbing death of a 26-year-old cosmetologist, Chicago police and the US Marshals Service said Sunday.

Ex-professor Wyndham Lathem and Andrew Warren were extradited Friday to Chicago from Northern California after their arrests earlier this month in what Chicago Police Superintendent Eddie Johnson called the “savage and grisly” killing of Trenton Cornell-Duranleau.

After the killing, US marshals tracked the men from Chicago to Wisconsin to California before negotiating their surrenders through an attorney, US Marshal Donal McCarthy said.

Lathem was arrested in Oakland, and Warren turned himself in in San Francisco, the marshal said.

“What I can tell you, it was not domestic in nature – like a husband/wife or boyfriend/boyfriend or love triangle – that was not the motive. It was a little bit more dark and disturbing,” Chicago police Detective Cmdr. Brendan Deenihan told reporters.

He would not elaborate, citing an upcoming bond court hearing for the suspects.

A judge ordered the men held without bond after prosecutors alleged the two killed Cornell-Duranleau as part of a sexual fantasy of “killing others and then themselves” that Lathem and Warren hatched in an online chat room, CNN affiliate WGN reported.

“At this point, police are done and everything is in the hands of the Cook County state’s attorney,” Chicago police spokesman Anthony Guglielmi told CNN.

Stabbed 70 times?

Wyndham Lathem (left) and Andrew Warren stand charged with murder.
Chicago Police Department
Wyndham Lathem (left) and Andrew Warren stand charged with murder.

Lathem, 43, and Cornell-Duranleau were boyfriends, Deenihan said, and Warren, 56, allegedly met Lathem over the Internet before traveling to Chicago several days before the slaying. Lathem picked up Warren at O’Hare International Airport, Deenihan said.

Around 5 a.m. on July 26, witnesses heard fighting and screaming coming from Lathem’s apartment, Deenihan said. The next day, a doorman for the apartment building received a call, possibly from Lathem, urging him to check the apartment, the detective said.

There, police found Cornell-Duranleau dead from multiple stab wounds, Deenihan said. According to prosecutors, who cited the findings of the Cook County Medical Examiner’s Office, Cornell-Duranleau had been stabbed 70 times, WMAQ reported.

Police found two knives at the scene, one with a broken blade, Deenihan said. The broken knife is believed to be the murder weapon, a high-ranking police official told CNN earlier this month.

Warren and Lathem allegedly fled the state shortly after Cornell-Duranleau’s death, sparking a manhunt. Chicago police issued first-degree murder arrest warrants for the pair on August 2.

Attorney: ‘Be patient’

Lathem’s attorney, Kenneth Wine, said his client was charged for “murder and fleeing” in Illinois, but he has not been formally arraigned on those charges.

The former professor did not say much during his initial court appearance, donning a red jumpsuit and acknowledging the friends and family who were present.

Lathem was fired from Northwestern University on Monday, the school said. He has also been banned from the university’s two campuses in Evanston and Chicago.

In a statement, Northwestern’s Vice President for University Relations Alan Cubbage said Lathem was “terminated for the act of fleeing from police when there was an arrest warrant out for him.”

Speaking to reporters on Monday, Wine called the move an “administrative action” that they will deal with “down the road.”

Lathem was an associate professor of microbiology and immunology at Northwestern and joined the faculty in 2007. He had primarily researched bacteria that causes disease in humans, particularly lung infections, according to his university biography page, which has since been removed.

Library donation

Prior to the arrests, Lathem had sent a video to his friends and family in which he talks about the biggest mistake of his life, a high-level source at the Chicago Police Department told CNN.

01:40 - Source: KGO
Police: Arrests made in fatal Chicago stabbing

CNN has not seen the video and police are not releasing it, but Chicago Police spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said that Lathem could be seen “apologizing for his involvement in the murder of Trenton Cornell-(Duranleau).”

Cornell-Duranleau’s death occurred the same day one of the suspects walked into the public library of Lake Geneva, a Wisconsin resort city about an hour’s drive from Chicago, and made a $1,000 cash donation in the victim’s name.

The alleged crime unfolded at an upscale high-rise apartment complex called the Grand Plaza Apartments in the city’s River North neighborhood. Resident Richard Aili told CNN affiliate WLS he was in shock when he learned the news.

“This place is very safe,” Aili said. “I’ve been here 14 years and I’ve never heard of problems such as that.”

CNN’s Samira Said, Bill Kirkos, Tony Marco, Phil Gast and Dan Simon contributed to this report.