Voting booths set up inside a polling station in Christmas, Florida on November 8, 2016.
Voting booths set up inside a polling station in Christmas, Florida on November 8, 2016.
PHOTO: GREGG NEWTON/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
02:20
States push back against voter fraud commission
Now playing
00:48
Trump: 'We need to keep the ballot box safe'
PHOTO: CNN
Now playing
01:27
Kobach: Criticism against me is ridiculous
Voters cast their ballots on Election Day November 04, 2008, at Centreville High School in Clifton, Virginia. Americans crowded polling stations Tuesday to vote in their historic election, with front-running Democrat Barack Obama seeking to become the first black US president and Republican rival John McCain battling for a comeback.  AFP Photo/Paul J. Richards (Photo credit should read PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images)
Voters cast their ballots on Election Day November 04, 2008, at Centreville High School in Clifton, Virginia. Americans crowded polling stations Tuesday to vote in their historic election, with front-running Democrat Barack Obama seeking to become the first black US president and Republican rival John McCain battling for a comeback. AFP Photo/Paul J. Richards (Photo credit should read PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:22
Judge: Voter fraud panel can collect data
Now playing
00:51
Conway: Trump doesn't think he's lying
A man walks to use a voting booth March 1, 2016, at one of the Virginia primary election polling stations at Colin Powell Elementary School, in Centreville, Virginia.
Voters in a dozen states will take part in "Super Tuesday" -- a series of primaries and caucuses in states ranging from Alaska to Virginia, with Virginia the first to open its polling stations at 6:00 am (1100 GMT).  / AFP / PAUL J. RICHARDS        (Photo credit should read PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images)
A man walks to use a voting booth March 1, 2016, at one of the Virginia primary election polling stations at Colin Powell Elementary School, in Centreville, Virginia. Voters in a dozen states will take part in "Super Tuesday" -- a series of primaries and caucuses in states ranging from Alaska to Virginia, with Virginia the first to open its polling stations at 6:00 am (1100 GMT). / AFP / PAUL J. RICHARDS (Photo credit should read PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:37
US district court to hear voter fraud case
Now playing
03:01
Trump slams states refusing to hand over voter data
Now playing
00:53
McCain: No evidence of illegal voting
Voting booths set up and ready to receive voters inside a polling station in Christmas, Florida on November 8, 2016.
Voting booths set up and ready to receive voters inside a polling station in Christmas, Florida on November 8, 2016.
PHOTO: GREGG NEWTON/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
02:34
Opposition to voter fraud commission grows
david chalian trump voter fraud claims sot nr_00004210.jpg
david chalian trump voter fraud claims sot nr_00004210.jpg
Now playing
01:09
Chalian to Trump: Provide proof of voter fraud
Kris Kobach, Kansas secretary of state, arrives for his meeting with president-elect at Trump International Golf Club, November 20, 2016 in Bedminster Township, New Jersey.
Kris Kobach, Kansas secretary of state, arrives for his meeting with president-elect at Trump International Golf Club, November 20, 2016 in Bedminster Township, New Jersey.
PHOTO: Drew Angerer/Getty Images
Now playing
02:44
Kobach comments on voter fraud commission
PHOTO: ABC News
Now playing
03:14
Pew study director: Fraud just doesn't happen
Tapper Trump voter fraud Lead_00004317.jpg
Tapper Trump voter fraud Lead_00004317.jpg
PHOTO: CNN
Now playing
01:31
Tapper: No evidence of voter fraud claim

Story highlights

Joshua Douglas: Trump's voter fraud commission is a sham

It will make the public think there is a problem where none exists, Douglas says

Editor’s Note: Joshua A. Douglas is a law professor at the University of Kentucky College of Law who specializes in election law, voting rights and constitutional law. He is the co-editor of “Election Law Stories.” Follow him on Twitter @JoshuaADouglas. The opinions expressed are his own.

(CNN) —  

If we need any further evidence that President Donald Trump’s voter fraud commission is a sham, we can find it in its request for all 50 states to turn over exceedingly detailed information on its voter rolls, without any apparent justification.

The vice chairman of the commission, Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, sent a letter to all 50 states requesting the state’s publicly-available voter rolls, including such personal information as the last four digits of someone’s Social Security number and “information regarding military status.”

Joshua A. Douglas
Joshua A. Douglas
PHOTO: Courtesy Joshua A. Douglas

In the abstract, matching voter rolls with other available data may not seem like a bad idea. After all, we all want accuracy in our voter registration information.

The problems come about when one looks deeper into Kobach’s history, which I’ll discuss in a moment, and which offers some blunt clues about his true motivations.

To begin, the information he’s seeking will reveal what we know already – that some voter registration rolls are bloated – and not much else. The voter databases include extra people for a particularly innocuous reason: Individuals die or move quite frequently.

But there is no evidence whatsoever that outdated voter lists lead to any kind of voter fraud. Simply put, dead people, or those who have moved, do not vote illegally in any significant number.

In addition, election data expertsnotably lacking on this commission – know that simply comparing large lists of voters will not provide useful information because of the number of false matches. The well-known “Birthday Problem” shows that it is somewhat likely that two people with the same common name – say, John Smith – will also share a birthday. The fact that two different state voter rolls might list this same name is not evidence of voter fraud.

Yet those who peddle the rampant voter fraud canard have been looking for evidence to support their theories, all in an effort to justify ever-stricter voting laws. They cannot find any widespread voter fraud, so they use issues of bloated voter registration rolls as their evidence. But that proves nothing beyond the reality that states need a better way to update their voter rolls.

This is exactly what Trump’s Commission on Election Integrity is positioning itself to do, as well: use evidence of voter registration anomalies to promote strict voting rules that make it harder for some people to vote.

Indeed, we already know that one of Kobach’s main policy goals is to repeal the National Voter Registration Act, also known as Motor-Voter, which makes it easier to register to vote. He also supports strict proof of citizenship requirements for registration that make it harder for some people to vote – with zero corresponding “integrity benefit.”

Seen in this light, it seems obvious why Kobach has requested detailed voter data from all 50 states, and why almost half the states, like Virginia and Kentucky, are rightly refusing to comply. Setting aside the privacy concerns (of which there are many), this information will provide nothing useful while laying the groundwork for the commission to peddle its theories of massive voter fraud.

The public should not be fooled. If Kobach and his commission were serious about improving our election system, his integrity panel would be truly bipartisan, much like President Barack Obama’s Presidential Commission on Election Administration was four years ago. The co-chairs were Obama’s main election lawyer and Mitt Romney’s main election lawyer, and the commission came up with unanimous, bipartisan solutions to our nation’s election woes, offering practical solutions to reduce long lines.

Get our free weekly newsletter

If Trump’s commission were a serious endeavor, it would include top election experts from both sides of the aisle. For the commission itself to have integrity, it must look at the ways states make it harder to vote for no good reason, such as through strict voter ID requirements that serve no purpose other than to drum up concerns of voter fraud, harming actual voters in the process.

If this commission were genuine, it would consider ways to make it easier to vote and enhance the election system, such as through automatic voter registration or by increasing early voting opportunities.

Instead, Trump’s voter fraud commission has one purpose, represented even in its name: the Commission on Election Integrity. It will focus solely on “integrity” so that the public thinks there is a problem where none exists.

That approach will lead us backward, not forward, in the effort to promote and protect the right to vote, the most fundamental right in our democracy.