The kids were "playing" and "sliding" on the patch of ice in Central Park when they "decided to take a selfie," she said. Cuevas and her family decided to do the same.
Suddenly the ice cracked and the teens plunged into the frigid water -- a terrifying incident Cuevas captured on video.
"My daughter and husband ... ran for ladders and started pulling people out," she said.
Police say seven teens were trying to take pictures when the ice gave way Monday evening.
Models to the rescue
At least three good Samaritans jumped in to try to help them, police Detective Annette Shelton told CNN. According to CNN's sister network, HLN, two of these Samaritans were models Bennett Jonas and Ethan Turnbull.
In an interview with HLN, the two young men said they were skating through Central Park when they saw some kids on the frozen ice.
"It was only a matter of seconds and it went from playing, dancing around on the ice, taking selfies to actually being in the water," said Turnbull, from Australia. "And the water was definitely pretty cold."
Jonas said the pair were not concerned for their own well being. "My main focus was just to get them all out," said Jonas, although he admitted the experience had been overwhelming. "It was scary," he said.
When the fire department responded, most of the teens had come out of the water, firefighter Eddie Long said.
Seven patients were taken to hospitals in serious condition, Long said. They were treated for hypothermia but all were expected to survive, he said. He didn't know if all of them were teens or whether the patients included good Samaritans who jumped in.
The economics site Pricenomics
found as of May 2016 the most dangerous places to take a self-portrait appeared to be high places or in water.
Researchers gathered data over three years by combing through news reports indicating a death was "precipitated by a selfie" or that a person had died while attempting to take a photo of themselves.
From 2014 onward they found 16 people died from falling off a cliff or a tall building, while 14 drowned.
Luckily, everyone in this polar plunge survived.