Now playing
02:05
Tillerson slams China over South China Sea
CNN gets rare access on board a US military surveillance flight over the hotly-disputed islands in the South China Sea.
PHOTO: Paul Devitt/CNN
CNN gets rare access on board a US military surveillance flight over the hotly-disputed islands in the South China Sea.
Now playing
02:43
CNN's rare view of contested South China Sea
A US Navy ship had an "unsafe" interaction with a Chinese warship September 30 while the US vessel was conducting a freedom of navigation operation near the disputed Spratly Islands in the South China Sea, causing the US ship to maneuver "to prevent a collision," according to US defense officials.
PHOTO: U.S. Navy
A US Navy ship had an "unsafe" interaction with a Chinese warship September 30 while the US vessel was conducting a freedom of navigation operation near the disputed Spratly Islands in the South China Sea, causing the US ship to maneuver "to prevent a collision," according to US defense officials.
Now playing
03:42
Photos show encounter with Chinese warship
us navy plane warned south china sea watson dnt vpx_00030107.jpg
PHOTO: CNN
us navy plane warned south china sea watson dnt vpx_00030107.jpg
Now playing
03:02
US Navy plane warned over South China Sea
Now playing
01:17
Why it's so tense in the South China Sea (2018)
Kristie Lu Stout South China Sea graphic explainer    _00003005.jpg
Kristie Lu Stout South China Sea graphic explainer _00003005.jpg
Now playing
01:55
South China Sea: A virtual explainer
James Mattis, US Secretary of Defense, speaks during the IISS Shangri-La Dialogue Asia Security Summit in Singapore, on Saturday, June 2, 2018. Mattis blasted Chinas deployment of military assets in the South China Sea, expanding the Trump administrations criticism of the country amid a continued dispute over trade. Photographer: Paul Miller/Bloomberg via Getty Images
PHOTO: Bloomberg/Bloomberg/Bloomberg via Getty Images
James Mattis, US Secretary of Defense, speaks during the IISS Shangri-La Dialogue Asia Security Summit in Singapore, on Saturday, June 2, 2018. Mattis blasted Chinas deployment of military assets in the South China Sea, expanding the Trump administrations criticism of the country amid a continued dispute over trade. Photographer: Paul Miller/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Now playing
01:06
Mattis: America is in the Indo-Pacific to stay
Now playing
01:47
US destroyer sails near China-claimed island
160612-N-BL637-685 PACIFIC OCEAN (June 12, 2016) A MV-22B Osprey, from Marine Operational Test and Evaluation Squadron 1, lifts off from the flight deck of the aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson (CVN 70). The V-22 Osprey is being tested, evaluated and is slated to be planned replacement for the C-2Q Greyhound as the singular logistics platform on an aircraft carrier for future carrier on-board delivery operations. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Sean Castellano/Released)
PHOTO: Specialist 3rd Class Sean Castellano/US Navy
160612-N-BL637-685 PACIFIC OCEAN (June 12, 2016) A MV-22B Osprey, from Marine Operational Test and Evaluation Squadron 1, lifts off from the flight deck of the aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson (CVN 70). The V-22 Osprey is being tested, evaluated and is slated to be planned replacement for the C-2Q Greyhound as the singular logistics platform on an aircraft carrier for future carrier on-board delivery operations. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Sean Castellano/Released)
Now playing
00:46
US starts 'routine' patrols in South China Sea
PHOTO: Drew Angerer/JOHANNES EISELE/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:26
Trump and China: What's at stake?
china's role with north korea rivers pkg_00015608.jpg
china's role with north korea rivers pkg_00015608.jpg
Now playing
02:18
Can China help the US deal with North Korea?
south china seas disputed island ivan watson pkg_00015514.jpg
south china seas disputed island ivan watson pkg_00015514.jpg
Now playing
02:21
War of words over islands in South China Sea
beijing rejects south china sea ruling lklv rivers _00013601.jpg
beijing rejects south china sea ruling lklv rivers _00013601.jpg
Now playing
02:18
Beijing rejects South China Sea ruling
US President Barack Obama delivers remarks at the National Convention Center in Hanoi on May 24, 2016.
Obama, currently on a visit to Vietnam, met with civil society leaders including some of the country's long-harassed critics on May 24. The visit is Obama's first to the country -- and the third by a sitting president since the end of the Vietnam War in 1975. / AFP / JIM WATSON        (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: JIM WATSON/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
US President Barack Obama delivers remarks at the National Convention Center in Hanoi on May 24, 2016. Obama, currently on a visit to Vietnam, met with civil society leaders including some of the country's long-harassed critics on May 24. The visit is Obama's first to the country -- and the third by a sitting president since the end of the Vietnam War in 1975. / AFP / JIM WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:56
President Obama: 'Sovereignty should be respected'
vietnam fishermen south china sea dispute mohsin pkg_00001216.jpg
vietnam fishermen south china sea dispute mohsin pkg_00001216.jpg
Now playing
02:41
Fishermen caught up in South China Sea tensions
FILE PHOTO -- The RC-135U Combat Sent, located at Offutt Air Force Base, Neb., provides strategic electronic reconnaissance information to the president, secretary of defense, Department of Defense leaders and theater commanders.  (U.S. Air Force photo)
PHOTO: U.S. Air Force
FILE PHOTO -- The RC-135U Combat Sent, located at Offutt Air Force Base, Neb., provides strategic electronic reconnaissance information to the president, secretary of defense, Department of Defense leaders and theater commanders. (U.S. Air Force photo)
Now playing
01:24
Chinese jet makes 'unsafe' intercept

Story highlights

Secretary of State nominee Rex Tillerson took a hardline stance on the South China Sea

He said China's access to artificial islands should be halted

Editor’s Note: Ashley Townshend is a research fellow at the United States Studies Centre at the University of Sydney. The views expressed here are solely his.

(CNN) —  

President-elect Donald Trump has not minced words on the South China Sea.

In the past few months, he’s called-out Beijing in tweets and speeches for its “brazen” island-building activities and the construction of a “massive military complex.”

He’s also vowed to use Washington’s economic leverage over Beijing as a way to push back – a tactic that, if it’s used, would open a brand new front in US-China competition, setting the scene for a possible Chinese economic retaliation in kind.

Trump’s pick for secretary of state Rex Tillerson, unexpectedly, has gone even further. During his Senate confirmation hearings this week, the former Exxon Mobil chief boldly declared that China’s militarization of artificial islets in the South China Sea was “akin to Russia’s taking Crimea” from Ukraine – a comparison that will ruffle feathers in Beijing.

01:03 - Source: CNN
Tillerson: Deny China access to sea, islands

Echoing the views of many Asia analysts in Trump’s team and across the political spectrum in Washington, Tillerson criticized President Barack Obama’s South China Sea policy for being inadequate – implying that periodic naval patrols were not a sufficiently muscular response to stop China from continually “pushing the envelope.”

But his most controversial remarks concerned what America’s South China Sea goals should be going forward. Beyond convincing Beijing to stop its island-building – which the Obama administration has tried but been unable to do – Tillerson said: “We’re going to have to send China a clear signal that first, the island-building stops, and second, your access to those islands also not going to be allowed.”

01:55 - Source: CNN
South China Sea: A virtual explainer

No one in Washington has seriously entertained this option. Blocking Chinese naval vessels from accessing South China Sea reefs would almost certainly trigger a US-China clash. More to the point: as many of the reefs are effectively a part of international waters, preventing Chinese ships from sailing to or near them would undermine the very freedom of navigation rules that the US has been trying to uphold.

While we shouldn’t read too much into this aspect of Tillerson’s remarks – after all, people make mistakes during hours-long grillings by Senate committees, especially when they’re new to the issues – the overall tone of his testimony was tough on China.

If Obama’s team was at times too cautious in taking China to task, Tillerson’s blunt talk of China’s “extremely worrisome” and “illegal” actions will bring a sharpness to State Department policy that hasn’t previously been present.

Counterproductive on North Korea?

Trump and Tillerson have also harshly criticized Beijing for its failure to help the US enforce United Nations sanctions on North Korea – a hawkish approach that may ultimately backfire.

Although the President-elect began by tweeting about his disappointment earlier this month, Tillerson, in his hearing, turned up the heat. In unusually frank terms, he stated Washington can no longer accept Beijing’s “empty promises” on North Korea and should consider putting “secondary sanctions” on Chinese entities that are violating sanctions in order to “compel” Beijing to finally comply.

They are correct Beijing should do more to enforce UN Security Council sanctions that seek to place pressure on Kim Jong Un’s regime for its nuclear and ballistic missile tests. Despite agreeing to two rounds of ostensibly tough sanctions in 2016, China has consistently found ways to avoid truly enforcing these measures – such as not sufficiently cracking down on the vast number of small Chinese companies that import North Korean coal in excess of the UN’s restrictions.

07:38 - Source: CNN
Keilar points out Fox News host's hypocrisy
Now playing
07:38
Keilar points out Fox News host's hypocrisy
Now playing
01:23
'There should be no threats': Biden's message to union-busters
Ashley Vanderbilt Former QAnon believer
PHOTO: CNN
Ashley Vanderbilt Former QAnon believer
Now playing
07:40
Former QAnon believer shares bonkers conspiracy theory about Biden
snl.fauci.vaccine.orig_00005420.png
snl.fauci.vaccine.orig_00005420.png
Now playing
01:24
'SNL' has 'Dr. Fauci' helping people get vaccinated
The Pokémon Company announced new games during its 25th Anniversary Celebration
PHOTO: The Pokémon Company
The Pokémon Company announced new games during its 25th Anniversary Celebration
Now playing
01:01
See the new Pokémon games coming soon
PHOTO: nickelodeon/from youtube
Now playing
01:33
'Real World,' 'Frasier,' 'Spongebob:' See the reboots coming to this new streaming service
Now playing
02:28
Fisker is making its next electric vehicle with Foxconn
Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky speaks onstage during "Introducing Trips" Reveal at Airbnb Open LA on November 17, 2016 in Los Angeles, California.  (Photo by Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb)
PHOTO: Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb
Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky speaks onstage during "Introducing Trips" Reveal at Airbnb Open LA on November 17, 2016 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb)
Now playing
03:51
Airbnb CEO: This is how we outperformed our competitors in 2020
PHOTO: ABC's "Jimmy Kimmel Live!"
Now playing
01:46
Watch people struggle to identify second gentleman Doug Emhoff
PHOTO: "The Late Late Show with James Corden" / Youtube
Now playing
01:37
See Prince Harry and James Corden tour LA on open-air bus
north korea missile launch threat trump hancocks lok_00001824.jpg
PHOTO: Getty Images
north korea missile launch threat trump hancocks lok_00001824.jpg
Now playing
02:39
N. Korea: ICBM can launch anytime and anywhere
Now playing
07:38
Keilar points out Fox News host's hypocrisy
Now playing
01:23
'There should be no threats': Biden's message to union-busters
Ashley Vanderbilt Former QAnon believer
PHOTO: CNN
Ashley Vanderbilt Former QAnon believer
Now playing
07:40
Former QAnon believer shares bonkers conspiracy theory about Biden
snl.fauci.vaccine.orig_00005420.png
snl.fauci.vaccine.orig_00005420.png
Now playing
01:24
'SNL' has 'Dr. Fauci' helping people get vaccinated
The Pokémon Company announced new games during its 25th Anniversary Celebration
PHOTO: The Pokémon Company
The Pokémon Company announced new games during its 25th Anniversary Celebration
Now playing
01:01
See the new Pokémon games coming soon
PHOTO: nickelodeon/from youtube
Now playing
01:33
'Real World,' 'Frasier,' 'Spongebob:' See the reboots coming to this new streaming service
Now playing
02:28
Fisker is making its next electric vehicle with Foxconn
Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky speaks onstage during "Introducing Trips" Reveal at Airbnb Open LA on November 17, 2016 in Los Angeles, California.  (Photo by Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb)
PHOTO: Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb
Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky speaks onstage during "Introducing Trips" Reveal at Airbnb Open LA on November 17, 2016 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Mike Windle/Getty Images for Airbnb)
Now playing
03:51
Airbnb CEO: This is how we outperformed our competitors in 2020
PHOTO: ABC's "Jimmy Kimmel Live!"
Now playing
01:46
Watch people struggle to identify second gentleman Doug Emhoff
PHOTO: "The Late Late Show with James Corden" / Youtube
Now playing
01:37
See Prince Harry and James Corden tour LA on open-air bus

But publicly deriding China for its failure to fully comply with sanctions only pushes Beijing onto the defensive. Chinese officials have already rejected Trump’s accusations and talked up their own efforts to build stability on the Korean Peninsula, and will rile at Tillerson’s latest rebuke. The net effect will be an acrimonious bilateral context in which US-China coordination on North Korea, or quiet pressure on Beijing, will be more difficult.

As any long-term solution to restraining North Korea’s nuclear ambitions will require the active participation of China, creating a public rift on this issue is counterproductive. Trump’s foreign policy team should instead continue to place behind-the-scenes pressure on China over poor sanctions enforcement, using private diplomatic avenues that won’t cause Beijing to clam up on cooperation.

A more unstable US-China relationship

While there is a need for firmer American action in the South China Sea and on North Korea, the Trump administration is shaping up to have a hardline China policy across the board.

Since winning the election, Trump has continued to announce that China is stealing US jobs, manipulating its currency, and regularly hacking US institutions. He and his team have stoked uncertainty over the future of US-Taiwan relations – a core concern for Beijing – and talked up a larger US military footprint in the Asia-Pacific, all while criticizing Chinese inaction on North Korea and its maritime assertiveness in Asian waters.

02:20 - Source: CNN
'One China,' explained

This is a mistake. Getting tough on China on everything at once isn’t going to induce Beijing to cooperate or make difficult concessions.

A purely muscular approach, if this comes to pass, will make Beijing a more truculent partner for Washington across the board. The consequences will be negative for US-China relations globally – making it harder for the two powers to work together on issues of mutual interest, such as crisis management and environmental protection, while deepening friction in major areas of disagreement, like Asia’s future strategic order.

Instead, Tillerson and the rest of Trump’s foreign policy team should prioritize areas where a tougher approach to China is warranted – such as in the South China Sea – and concentrate their efforts to affect changes there. This will, at times, require strong public statements and US actions, but should be coupled with private diplomatic pressure that’s not tweeted in 140 characters or less.