How liberals should spend their Trump-gotten gains

Wall Street doesn't fear President Trump
Wall Street doesn't fear President Trump


    Wall Street doesn't fear President Trump


Wall Street doesn't fear President Trump 01:19

Story highlights

  • Since Election Day, the Dow Jones is up more than 8%
  • John MacIntosh: Liberals who've profited from stock market gains should channel their returns to fighting Trump policies

John MacIntosh was a partner at a leading global private equity firm, where he worked from 1994 to 2006 in New York, Tokyo and London. He now runs a nonprofit in New York. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his.

(CNN)Opponents of President-elect Donald Trump with significant stock market investments have a problem. We've made a lot of money since Election Day (the Dow is up almost 9%), yet it feels morally wrong to have profited from the victory of a man we consider unfit for office and whose policies we viscerally oppose. It's like possessing stolen property or being the unwilling beneficiary of a nefarious scheme.

Worse yet is the reason for the market's rise. At a time when interest rates are rising, stock prices should be under pressure. Yet we've seen outsized gains because the market expects that corporate profits will go up under the Trump administration. And they probably will.
John MacIntosh
But where will these extra profits come from? They are unlikely to be the result of improved productivity, technological innovation or increased capital investment. Trump has no coherent policies on these issues.
    What seems far more likely is that the additional profits are just the extra money that corporations will be allowed to extract from the American people under the Trump administration. An extraction that is particularly objectionable since corporate profits are already at an all-time high (as a percentage of GDP) and the money will be taken from those who can least afford it: subprime borrowers (Goldman and the banks are up), young people (for-profit education organizations are up), future generations (if corporate taxes go down now, taxes will have to go up later), those living in climate-exposed areas (oil stocks are up) and other vulnerable citizens (for-profit prisons are up).
    So to me, my post-Election Day profits are just the present value of other people's future misery. How can I rid myself of these ill-gotten gains? There are four options:
    Convert: "The market is usually right. It likes Trump. So I've changed my mind about the incoming administration, and I'll keep the money."
    Deny: "The money might not be tainted, or it might prove illusory. To be on the safe side, I'll keep it."
    Hoard: "The incoming administration is so bad that I'll need all the money I can get. Winter is coming."
    Repudiate: "The money makes me sick. I'm giving it back."
    Conversion and denial are the easy options for any moderate Trump opponent. And they probably would have been good enough for me were Trump a "normal" pro-business Republican. But Trump's extremism makes conversion impossible. And while I generally believe in the "wisdom of the market," I am opposed to Trump for reasons that don't show up in market prices. The market does not respond to the increased possibility of nuclear or climate catastrophe, disregards the past (including a history of Russian hacking), largely ignores the poor (who are reliant on nonprofits, government and other nonmarket actors), and takes no position on the important social issues: immigration, criminal justice, racism, sexism, LGBT equality, reproductive rights, gun control, etc.
    Dems vow confirmation fight for 8 Trump cabinet picks
    democrats targeting trump picks congress 115th confirmation bash lead_00011824


      Dems vow confirmation fight for 8 Trump cabinet picks


    Dems vow confirmation fight for 8 Trump cabinet picks 02:57
    And for the same reasons, hoarding is impossible to justify. Anyone affluent enough to have meaningful stock market investments won't need extra money under a Trump administration. Our taxes will go down, and we don't need the things -- affordable health insurance, reproductive health services, Medicaid, fair treatment by the police -- that are poised to get very tough over the next four years.
    So that leaves only one option: Give the money back. But since that's easier said than done even for the most generous among us, I've created "Giving Pledge 2.0" to help. While less glamorous than Warren Buffett and Bill Gates' nonpartisan, billionaire-focused original, it allows opponents of Trump to dispose of their ill-gotten gains and fight him at the same time.
    Giving Pledge 2.0 simply requires that you commit to spend the majority of any stock market gains earned from Election Day to the inauguration fighting those policies of the Trump administration that are most antithetical to your values. And there will be plenty to choose from.
    Follow CNN Opinion

    Join us on Twitter and Facebook

    And it's easy to do. One way is to set up a donor-advised fund at your broker or community foundation (e.g., the "Keep America Decent Fund"). After the inauguration, simply donate 50% (or more) of gains you've made since Election Day to the fund and then spend it down over the next four years by supporting nonprofits most aligned with your values.
    Will even the wealthiest and most ardent Trump opponents take my pledge? I don't know. But with the stock market up $2 trillion since Election Day, Democrats in the "top 1%" alone are probably sitting on $400 billion in gains. We can hardly sit on our hands bemoaning what is to come while enjoying the spoils of his victory. The adversary has given us the money we'll need for the fight if we only have the courage to spend it.