Donald Trump, Pentagon differ on Mosul fight’s success

Published 6:45 PM EDT, Mon October 31, 2016
Shiite fighters from the Hashed al-Shaabi launch missiles on the village of Salmani, south of Mosul, on October 30, 2016 during the ongoing battle against Islamic State to liberate the city of Mosul.
PHOTO: AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images
Shiite fighters from the Hashed al-Shaabi launch missiles on the village of Salmani, south of Mosul, on October 30, 2016 during the ongoing battle against Islamic State to liberate the city of Mosul.
Now playing
03:28
CNN on front lines as Iraqi troops make final push to Mosul
PHOTO: CNN
Now playing
04:32
Mosul survivors search for loved ones
Now playing
01:01
Fleeing ISIS in Mosul: Their faces say it all
Haider al-Abadi Mosul 7/9/17
PHOTO: Iraqi PM Office
Haider al-Abadi Mosul 7/9/17
Now playing
02:01
Iraq's PM claims Mosul liberated from ISIS
Iraq's federal police members wave Iraq's national flag as they celebrate in the Old City of Mosul on July 9, 2017 after the government's announcement of the "liberation" of the embattled city. Iraq declared victory against the Islamic State group in Mosul on July 9 after a gruelling months-long campaign, dealing the biggest defeat yet to the jihadist group.
PHOTO: FADEL SENNA/Getty Images
Iraq's federal police members wave Iraq's national flag as they celebrate in the Old City of Mosul on July 9, 2017 after the government's announcement of the "liberation" of the embattled city. Iraq declared victory against the Islamic State group in Mosul on July 9 after a gruelling months-long campaign, dealing the biggest defeat yet to the jihadist group.
Now playing
05:33
US General: Iraq must continue to attack ISIS
Counter Terror Service (CTS) Troops climb a mound of rubble to reach a house turned fighting position just 50 meters from the Tigris river. They are engaged in fierce clashes to push out ISIS's remaining pockets of resistance.
PHOTO: Salma Abdelaziz/CNN
Counter Terror Service (CTS) Troops climb a mound of rubble to reach a house turned fighting position just 50 meters from the Tigris river. They are engaged in fierce clashes to push out ISIS's remaining pockets of resistance.
Now playing
03:03
Mosul liberation comes at a price
Now playing
01:05
On the ground in Mosul
An Iraqi rescue worker gestures towards bodies wrapped in plastic in the Mosul al-Jadida area on March 26, 2017, following air strikes in which civilians have been reportedly killed during an ongoing offensive against the Islamic State group.  
Iraq is investigating air strikes in west Mosul that reportedly killed large numbers of civilians in recent days, a military spokesman said.
PHOTO: AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images
An Iraqi rescue worker gestures towards bodies wrapped in plastic in the Mosul al-Jadida area on March 26, 2017, following air strikes in which civilians have been reportedly killed during an ongoing offensive against the Islamic State group. Iraq is investigating air strikes in west Mosul that reportedly killed large numbers of civilians in recent days, a military spokesman said.
Now playing
01:55
CNN on the ground in Mosul, Iraq
Now playing
02:10
A history of ISIS in Mosul
Now playing
01:33
Arwa and Mattar: A friendship forged in fear
iraq mosul us investigate claims civilians deaths damon lklv_00001724.jpg
PHOTO: AFP/Getty Images
iraq mosul us investigate claims civilians deaths damon lklv_00001724.jpg
Now playing
02:21
US Com.: 'chance' Iraq strike killed civilians
TOPSHOT - Relatives mourn as bodies of Iraqi residents of west Mosul killed in an airstrike targeting Islamic State (IS) group jihadists are placed and covered with blankets on carts on March 17, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / ARIS MESSINIS        (Photo credit should read ARIS MESSINIS/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO: ARIS MESSINIS/AFP/Getty Images
TOPSHOT - Relatives mourn as bodies of Iraqi residents of west Mosul killed in an airstrike targeting Islamic State (IS) group jihadists are placed and covered with blankets on carts on March 17, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / ARIS MESSINIS (Photo credit should read ARIS MESSINIS/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:57
Cmdr.: Fair chance US airstrike hit civilians
Now playing
02:22
A walk through the devastation of West Mosul
Now playing
02:17
CNN reports during Iraqi, ISIS firefight
iraq mosul us investigate claims civilians deaths damon lklv_00001724.jpg
PHOTO: AFP/Getty Images
iraq mosul us investigate claims civilians deaths damon lklv_00001724.jpg
Now playing
02:49
Over 100 bodies pulled from Mosul rubble
Tanks and armored vehicles of the Iraqi forces, supported by the Hashed al-Shaabi paramilitaries, advance towards the village of Sheikh Younis, south of Mosul, as the offensive to retake the western side of Mosul from Islamic State group fighters commenced on February 19, 2017.
PHOTO: AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images
Tanks and armored vehicles of the Iraqi forces, supported by the Hashed al-Shaabi paramilitaries, advance towards the village of Sheikh Younis, south of Mosul, as the offensive to retake the western side of Mosul from Islamic State group fighters commenced on February 19, 2017.
Now playing
01:34
Battle for Mosul: the one thing to know
Now playing
01:38
US frontline clinic treats Mosul's wounded

Story highlights

Trump has lambasted the coalition effort to re-capture the city of Mosul

Clinton has been quick to knock Trump for his criticism

(CNN) —  

Pentagon officials said Monday that the campaign to reclaim Mosul was proceeding as planned and that so far anti-ISIS forces in Iraq are succeeding in their fight against the terror group.

The military’s upbeat assessment puts Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump in an awkward position. His repeated criticism of the handling of the operation means its success could cast shadows on his argument to be the next commander in chief, while his decision to take on the Pentagon once again highlights the sacred cows he has been willing to slay during his unconventional campaign.

For weeks, Trump has lambasted the coalition effort to re-capture the city of Mosul from ISIS, calling the undertaking a “total disaster” and saying the US and its allies were “bogged-down” there even as defense officials say they are encouraged by the progress being made.

“The campaign is on track and moving forward according to plan,” Pentagon Press Secretary Peter Cook told reporters Monday. 

“There’s no question that counter-ISIL forces continue to have the momentum in this fight,” he added, using the government’s preferred acronym for the terror organization, also known as Daesh.

Yet Trump repeated his critique of the operation on Monday.

“Did we give Mosul enough advanced notice?” he asked rhetorically during a rally in Grand Rapids, Michigan. “Whatever happened to the element of surprise?”

Trump’s view contrasts with the assessment of military officials, who have laid out the reasons why they are discussing some – though not all – elements of the Mosul operation.

And, so far, they can point for back-up to developments on the ground to take back Iraq’s second-largest city and key holdout for ISIS.

Defense Secretary Ash Carter “continues to be encouraged by what he is seeing,” Cook said, describing the campaign as proceeding on schedule.

Cook’s view was also echoed by the US special presidential envoy for the counter-ISIS coalition, Amb. Brett McGurk, while speaking Friday in Rome.

While McGurk acknowledged that the campaign for Mosul “will be a long-term effort,” he said that “every single objective has been met and we continue to move forward.”

On the same day, the military spokesman for the anti-ISIS coalition, US Air Force Col. John Dorrian, went even further.

“They were able to get to those places faster than they anticipated that they would,” he said of local forces. “So, the Iraqis continue to be successful in the engagements against Daesh.”

Dorrian repeated his upbeat assessment Tuesday while appearing at a press conference with Iraqi military officials, describing the joint assault as making “rapid progress.”

Because Trump has made a concentrated effort to slam the conduct of the Mosul operation, its success could undermine his claim of superior judgment as commander in chief in the final days before the November 8 election.

Non-incumbent candidates for political office always have to walk a fine line while military operations are ongoing. Typically, this involves commending the troops on fighting on the ground while simultaneously blasting the politicians in charge.

But Trump has shown a readiness to deviate from this political playbook, as he has repeatedly done for others throughout the 2016 campaign.

RELATED: What US Special Forces are doing on the ground in Syria and Iraq

In contrast, then-Sen. Barack Obama made sure to praise the military even as he was highly critical of the 2007 “surge” in Iraq during the run-up to his own campaign for the presidency.

Obama called George W. Bush’s decision to deploy thousands of more troops as part of a counterinsurgency strategy aimed at reducing violence a “course that will not succeed” during an interview that year with PBS’s Charlie Rose.

Despite slamming the Bush administration, Obama still offered praise for the US troops on the ground, saying they had “performed brilliantly” and calling Gen. David Petraeus, the surge’s architect, an able and competent leader.

Trump’s recent statements on Mosul don’t include these qualifiers of praising the US military officers in charge or the US troops on the ground, though Trump has offered general praise for US troops in other situations.

“Donald Trump is testing lots of what we thought we knew about American politics, including that no one gets elected running against the troops,” said Kori Schake, a former senior Bush official, who has endorsed Democrat Hillary Clinton in the 2016.

Schake, who was one of the 50 Republican national security officials that penned an open-letter slamming Trump earlier this year, argued that the Republican nominee’s comments on Mosul were undercutting morale.

“The particular way he’s done it is bad for morale of American forces as well as the allies bearing the brunt of the fight,” she told CNN.

02:03 - Source: CNN
The scorched-earth presidential debate in 2 minutes
Democratic presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump speak during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016, in St. Louis.
PHOTO: Win McNamee/Getty
Democratic presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump speak during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016, in St. Louis.
Now playing
02:03
The scorched-earth presidential debate in 2 minutes
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09:  Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump listens during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election.  (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
PHOTO: Scott Olson/Getty Images
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09: Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump listens during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:39
Trump vs. the moderators at the town hall debate
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09:  Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump shakes hands with Democratic presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election.  (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
PHOTO: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09: Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump shakes hands with Democratic presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:35
Hear what Clinton, Trump respect most about each other
trump clinton debate st louis campaign exploding_00000000.jpg
trump clinton debate st louis campaign exploding_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:01
Clinton to Trump: Your campaign is exploding
trump clinton debate tape locker talk tape 1_00001115.jpg
trump clinton debate tape locker talk tape 1_00001115.jpg
Now playing
01:06
Trump: I'm not proud of tape about groping women
trump clinton debate st louis tape rebuttal_00000000.jpg
trump clinton debate st louis tape rebuttal_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:11
Hillary Clinton: Tape represents who Trump is
trump clinton 60 seconds vitriol origwx js_00000000.jpg
trump clinton 60 seconds vitriol origwx js_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:00
60 seconds of pure vitriol from Sunday's town hall debate
Now playing
01:07
Trump: Clinton has tremendous hate in her heart
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09:  Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump responds to a question during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election.  (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
PHOTO: Scott Olson/Getty Images
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09: Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump responds to a question during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:23
Trump: I'm 'not unproud' of Alicia Machado tweet
Now playing
01:51
Trump: 'I know nothing about Russia'
PHOTO: Jeff Roberson/AP
Now playing
01:59
Trump on Syria: How stupid is our country?
Trump debate 11
PHOTO: CNN
Trump debate 11
Now playing
01:38
Trump says he used $916M loss to avoid federal taxes
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09:  Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump responds to a question during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election.  (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
PHOTO: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 09: Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump responds to a question during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. This is the second of three presidential debates scheduled prior to the November 8th election. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Now playing