Alleged killer took the nuns' car but nothing from their home, law enforcement source says
Margaret Held and Paula Merrill were nurse practitioners
Suspect charged with two counts of capital murder
A man has been arrested in the stabbing deaths of two nuns whose bodies were found in their home in rural Mississippi, authorities said.
Margaret Held and Paula Merrill, both nurse practitioners, failed to show up for work Thursday at a clinic in Lexington, where they served one of the state’s poorest counties.
Authorities believe the killer took the victims’ car, a blue Toyota Corolla, which was later found on an abandoned road less than a mile from their home. But nothing was taken from the house, according to a law enforcement official who has been briefed on the investigation.
Clinic workers called police when the pair didn’t arrive at the clinic, said Maureen Smith, a spokeswoman for the Catholic Diocese of Jackson.
When authorities arrived at their home in Durant, 13 miles away from the clinic, they saw evidence of a break-in and found their bodies, she said.
Rodney Earl Sanders, 46, has been charged with two counts of capital murder in connection with the killings, the Mississippi Department of Public Safety said early Saturday.
“Sanders was developed as a person of interest early on in the investigation,” said Lt. Col. Jimmy Jordan, director of MBI.
After an investigation that included the sheriff’s department and the attorney general’s office, “this heinous crime has been resolved,” he said.
He did not provide additional information on the arrest.
Sanders appears to have been released from prison last December after serving nine months for a felony conviction for driving under the influence, according to the Mississippi Department of Corrections. He also did prison time from the mid 1980s to early 1990s for armed robbery, records show.
Shortly after the women’s bodies were found, authorities said the motive for the killings remained unclear, adding that calling it a “robbery would be premature.”
The victims’ religious orders – the Sisters of Charity of Nazareth and School Sisters of St. Francis – thanked investigators Saturday.
“There is still much we do not know about the suspect and the circumstances that led to this brutal and senseless crime,” the School Sisters of St. Francis said in a statement posted on Facebook.
‘They didn’t bother anybody’
Those who knew the two nuns described them as outgoing and compassionate.
“They were sweet, very loving … easy to get along with,” Patricia Wyatt Weatherly, who lived next door to the victims, told CNN affiliate WLBT-TV. “They didn’t bother anybody.”
The Rev. Greg Plata of St. Thomas Catholic Church, where they attended Mass, said they were “just good women, women of prayer.”
The sisters were loved by the doctors and residents in the area, and were the primary caregivers at the clinic, he said.
Plata’s parishioners mourned their passing Thursday night at the church.
“We basically cried and told our stories about them and talked about how important they were to us,” he said.
Merrill was a nurse practitioner in Mississippi for more than 30 years and had been at the Lexington Medical Clinic since 2010. The clinic tends to thousands of patients, many poor and uninsured.
“Many people have no health insurance because they can’t afford the premiums,” Merrill said in an interview posted on the Sisters of Charity of Nazareth website. “They make minimum wage.”
Held moved to Mississippi in 1983, and had lived in Durant for 13 years, officials said.
CNN’s Carma Hassan, Khushbu Shah, Joe Sutton and Steve Almasy contributed to this report.