Ohio Gov. John Kasich, Jeb Bush, Sen. Ted Cruz, Donald Trump, Sen. Marco Rubio and Ben Carson participate in a CBS News GOP Debate February 13, 2016, at the Peace Center in Greenville, South Carolina.
Spencer Platt/Getty
Ohio Gov. John Kasich, Jeb Bush, Sen. Ted Cruz, Donald Trump, Sen. Marco Rubio and Ben Carson participate in a CBS News GOP Debate February 13, 2016, at the Peace Center in Greenville, South Carolina.
Now playing
02:09
The CBS Republican debate in 2 minutes
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Edward M. Pio Roda/CNN
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Now playing
02:32
Donald Trump pressed for specifics of his worldview
CNN
Now playing
00:59
Ted Cruz: Trump hand-raising pledge 'exactly backwards'
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Edward M. Pio Roda/CNN
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Now playing
01:45
Donald Trump on rally violence: It's not me
CNN
Now playing
01:54
Should the candidate with the most delegates win?
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Edward M. Pio Roda/CNN
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Now playing
01:26
Does it matter how the world sees the U.S.?
John Kasich post republican debate Miami intv serfaty ac_00002110.jpg
John Kasich post republican debate Miami intv serfaty ac_00002110.jpg
Now playing
01:07
John Kasich: I'm doing really, really well
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Edward M. Pio Roda/CNN
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Now playing
01:30
Marco Rubio: 'The climate is always changing'
Republican Presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during the CNN Debate in Miami on March 10, 2016.
RHONA WISE/AFP/Getty Images
Republican Presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during the CNN Debate in Miami on March 10, 2016.
Now playing
01:33
Reality check: Trump's ISIS oil claims misleading?
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Edward M. Pio Roda/CNN
CNN Republican Debate at the University of Miami.
Now playing
02:35
Donald Trump, Marco Rubio spar over Cuba
CNN
Now playing
01:09
Donald Trump: 'Elegant debate' that we needed
HOUSTON, TX - FEBRUARY 24:  Republican presidential candidate U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) speaks during a campaign rally at the Marriott South at Hobby Airport on February 24, 2016 in Houston, Texas. The process to select the next Democratic and Republican Presidential candidates continues.  (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
Joe Raedle/Getty Images/File
HOUSTON, TX - FEBRUARY 24: Republican presidential candidate U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) speaks during a campaign rally at the Marriott South at Hobby Airport on February 24, 2016 in Houston, Texas. The process to select the next Democratic and Republican Presidential candidates continues. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:00
Marco Rubio on insulting Trump: I'll never do it again
CNN
Now playing
02:31
Rubio to Trump: I am correct, not politically correct
CNN
Now playing
00:47
Donald Trump: Carson will be involved in education plan
CNN
Now playing
01:13
Trump, Rubio hit Disney over H-1B visa usage
CNN
Now playing
01:37
John Kasich: We need free, fair trade
Marco Rubio participates in a debate sponsored by Fox News on March 3, 2016 in Detroit, Michigan.
Chip Somodevilla/Getty
Marco Rubio participates in a debate sponsored by Fox News on March 3, 2016 in Detroit, Michigan.
Now playing
01:30
The 11th GOP debate in 90 seconds
gop debate Donald Trump Marco Rubio small hands jnd orig vstan 05_00003311.jpg
Fox News
gop debate Donald Trump Marco Rubio small hands jnd orig vstan 05_00003311.jpg
Now playing
00:45
Donald Trump: There is nothing wrong with size of my ...
gop debate donald trump hands yoga bash intv ac_00002815.jpg
CNN
gop debate donald trump hands yoga bash intv ac_00002815.jpg
Now playing
00:49
Donald Trump: I have very powerful hands
gop debate donald trump new york times tapes off the record orig vstan 06_00014005.jpg
gop debate donald trump new york times tapes off the record orig vstan 06_00014005.jpg
Now playing
02:07
Donald Trump refuses to release New York Times tape
Fox News
Now playing
01:16
Gov. John Kasich: 'I will win Ohio'
gop debate ted Cruz Donald trump fund Hillary Clinton jnd orig vstan 04_00002717.jpg
Fox News
gop debate ted Cruz Donald trump fund Hillary Clinton jnd orig vstan 04_00002717.jpg
Now playing
01:05
Ted Cruz: Donald Trump funded Hillary Clinton in 2008
Fox News
Now playing
01:33
Megyn Kelly questions Trump over Trump University
Fox News
Now playing
00:40
Donald Trump: 'I totally disavow the Ku Klux Klan'
Republican presidential candidates Sen. Marco Rubio, Donald Trump and Sen. Ted Cruz participate in a debate sponsored by Fox News at the Fox Theatre on March 3, 2016, in Detroit, Michigan.
Chip Somodevilla/Getty
Republican presidential candidates Sen. Marco Rubio, Donald Trump and Sen. Ted Cruz participate in a debate sponsored by Fox News at the Fox Theatre on March 3, 2016, in Detroit, Michigan.
Now playing
01:37
Fox anchor challenges Trump on deficit plans
Republican presidential candidate, businessman Donald Trump, second from left, gestures as Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, and Ohio Gov. John Kasich watch him a Republican presidential primary debate at Fox Theatre, Thursday, March 3, 2016, in Detroit
Paul Sancya/AP
Republican presidential candidate, businessman Donald Trump, second from left, gestures as Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, and Ohio Gov. John Kasich watch him a Republican presidential primary debate at Fox Theatre, Thursday, March 3, 2016, in Detroit
Now playing
01:14
Watch Ted Cruz pledge to support GOP nominee at debate
HOUSTON, TX - FEBRUARY 25:  Republican presidential candidates Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) (L) and Ted Cruz (R-TX)(R) listen as Donald Trump answers a question during the Republican presidential debate at the Moores School of Music at the University of Houston on February 25, 2016 in Houston, Texas. The debate is the last before the March 1 Super Tuesday primaries.  (Photo by Michael Ciaglo-Pool/Getty Images )
Pool/Getty Images North America/Getty Images
HOUSTON, TX - FEBRUARY 25: Republican presidential candidates Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) (L) and Ted Cruz (R-TX)(R) listen as Donald Trump answers a question during the Republican presidential debate at the Moores School of Music at the University of Houston on February 25, 2016 in Houston, Texas. The debate is the last before the March 1 Super Tuesday primaries. (Photo by Michael Ciaglo-Pool/Getty Images )
Now playing
01:00
20 insults from the CNN debate in 1 minute
cnn houston debate recap origwx nws_00001511.jpg
cnn houston debate recap origwx nws_00001511.jpg
Now playing
01:30
CNN's Houston GOP debate in 90 seconds
CNN
Now playing
01:15
Rubio attacks Trump over hiring illegal workers
CNN
Now playing
00:48
Marco Rubio and Donald Trump's vicious debate battle
CNN
Now playing
01:48
Donald Trump calls Ted Cruz a liar ... again
gop post debate donald trump marco rubio choke artist 13_00005506.jpg
gop post debate donald trump marco rubio choke artist 13_00005506.jpg
Now playing
01:15
Donald Trump: Marco Rubio 'is a choke artist'
CNN
Now playing
03:02
Donald Trump, Marco Rubio spar over healthcare

Story highlights

Todd Graham: GOP candidates blew it at debate, with personal attacks, a thin-skinned Trump, and Cruz unable to defend himself

He says rowdy audience made a poor showing, and moderators lost control of their debaters

Editor’s Note: Todd Graham is director of debate at Southern Illinois University. His teams have won national championships for three years, and he’s been recognized twice as the national debate coach of the year. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author.

CNN —  

The Republican debate in South Carolina Saturday on night was far below what I’d hoped for as a debate coach, so the grades generally reflected that this time. It’s like one of those “group projects” where one person in the group is so poor as to bring everyone else down. Sometimes, nobody gets an A.

I’ll begin with the best of the lot.

B-

Marco Rubio: Rubio was generally decent (solid in his discussion of child tax-credits, worse on amnesty and immigration and his record in Florida). He had a poor exchange on immigration with Cruz that somehow ended up with Cruz speaking Spanish. It wasn’t Rubio’s best debate, but since it wasn’t the disaster of his last one, where the (now gone) Chris Christie mocked him for repeating himself, people will probably give him too much credit. B minus seems appropriate.

Todd Graham
Courtesy Todd Graham
Todd Graham

C-

Ben Carson: Carson continues with two irritating trends. First, he mentions, in a tired joke or complaint, his speaking time. Enough already. Second, he answers every question asked of him by going back to the last topic, saying how he’d would have loved to answer that one, and giving a generic answer like, “I’ve got some great ideas” or “please see my policy online.”

C-

01:19 - Source: CNN
Trump hits Cruz for 'lying' and Bush for 'attack ads'

Jeb Bush: In his first exchange, of many, with Trump, Bush stuttered and stammered even when not provoked. I’ve seen it in many debates. You expect your opponent’s next argument, which causes you to lose your train of thought because you’re thinking ahead. With Bush, of course, after that, the inevitable happened. He got into many unwieldy and unprofessional arguments with Trump. Bush’s new approach was to attempt humor now and then. Note to Bush: If you aren’t a funny guy, then don’t try it out in a debate. It backfires almost every time.

C-

John Kasich: He tried to have it both ways. At times, he would pretend that he was above the rest of the raucous field with his calm demeanor (by telling us he was), but then, when he was engaged with Bush, Kasich would revert to interrupting and appearing incensed, as he has in other debating appearances. It has served him poorly.

Ted Cruz. Cruz had a decent debate in the middle, but it was bookended by awfulness. Initially, the moderator, John Dickerson, flustered Cruz. At one point, Cruz actually gave Dickerson the stink-eye. No kidding. Google the video. The debate escalated, with Cruz in an argument with Trump, who called Cruz, for the second time that night (Rubio did it earlier) a “liar,” and even the “single biggest liar.” Cruz’s comeback to Trump? “Adults don’t interrupt.” He’s got to find a way to get above this fray. Getting called a liar multiple times in a debate is something to avoid.

D

F

Donald Trump: He’s back to childish again. Trump can’t let any criticism go by. His thin-skinned approach ruins the debates and doesn’t help him. This is amateur debating. Trump–and I’m not exaggerating–lost his cool every time his name was mentioned in a negative light. His response was invariably to call people names. He constantly interrupted other candidates in mid-speech.

Losing your cool at the drop of a hat is poor form in debates. And it’s worse for a President. Indeed when asked whether he can ever be told he’s wrong, his reply was to spin it into an attack on Bush and how much money he spent in New Hampshire, only to place fourth as opposed to Trump, who won there. Not answering the questions, name-calling, interrupting…all earned Donald Trump an F.

00:44 - Source: CBS News
Voters ask Donald Trump to 'cut out profanity'

F

The live audience: Enough already! They’re annoying; they’re biased toward some candidates (they’d cheer at anything Rubio said, regardless of the merit); and biased against others (stop booing Trump and Cruz just because they disagree with your favorite son, Rubio). It’s an age-old debating trick: Stack the audience, and watch how they sway the voters (especially the voters at home). At the end it became a contest on whose supporters could yelp the loudest. What nonsense.

F-

The debate: I wrote the words “this is a terrible debate” no less than 5 times in all caps when watching.

The moderators had no control. A good moderator should study the candidates, know their debating style, and prepare to handle it. Most of the candidates — not just Trump – lacked self-control. If you have kids, here’s my analogy. It was like watching children screaming, interrupting, and insulting one another when fighting over that last scoop of ice cream.

As an example of how out-of-control the debate became, Dickerson asked Rubio to “chime in” and Rubio replied, “on anything I want?” So he did.

It ended with another episode when Rubio asked if he had 30 seconds, and Dickerson simply gave up by saying, “I’ll ask the question, you do what you want.”

It was a perfect summation of a pitiful debate.

Join us on Facebook.com/CNNOpinion.
Read CNNOpinion’s Flipboard magazine.