Do voters have the right to know presidential candidates’ health histories?

Story highlights

Over decades, some presidents have hidden their medical issues from the public

Debate continues on the public's right to know candidates' medical histories

CNN  — 

On Monday, Donald Trump released a statement by his personal physician that said he’d lost 15 pounds in the last year, takes aspirin daily and a low dose of statin and has “astonishingly excellent” lab test results and blood pressure. “If elected,” Dr. Harold Bornstein wrote, “Mr. Trump, I can state unequivocally, will be the healthiest individual ever elected to the presidency.”

With the release, Trump joins Hillary Clinton, Jeb Bush, and Chris Christie, who have recently assured the American people they are healthy and fit to lead.

Excellent or not, what right does the public have to know the intimate details of a candidate’s medical history? After all, they are shielded by the same federal privacy laws that protect each of us from undue scrutiny.

“It’s a controversial issue because some illness can be blown out of proportion and with modern medicine a person can do well,” said Jerrold Post, author of “When Illness Strikes the Leader.” “But if a person is suffering from early Alzheimer’s or another serious disease, it’s quite another story.”

Senator John McCain released medical records before the 2000 and 2008 elections.

History shows that most presidential candidates have kept their medical information private. Only recently have candidates opted to release letters from personal physicians. Few go as far as Sen. John McCain, who released thousands of carefully selected medical records to the press for a few hours during his bid for the 2000 and 2008 nominations.

“It’s a very touchy subject,” said Dr. Connie Mariano, who served as White House physician for George W. Bush and Bill Clinton. “Having been at the White House for nine years, my opinion is only as it impacts their ability to perform their job in office, which is to make decisions and communicate.”

Opinion: Is Trump in the most ‘astonishingly excellent’ health of any candidate ever?

“The public has a right to know if the candidate has a reason to believe he might die in office. Short of that, I think the president has a right to keep his medical and mental health information private,” said George Annas, chairman of the department of health law, bioethics and human rights at Boston University School of Public Health.

“Why do some open up? I think the ones who talk believe they are better off with the information out there. They must think the speculation is worse than the reality.”

Legacy of presidential coverups

History reveals an astounding list of hidden truths when it comes to the health of the commander in chief. One of the most unusual was Grover Cleveland’s 1893 coverup of his oral cancer surgery. He smuggled a surgeon and his team onto a friend’s yacht to remove a tumor from the roof of his mouth. Cleveland emerged from his “fishing trip” a week later. No one knew what had happened for nearly a quarter-century.

Related: How old is too old to be president?

Woodrow Wilson had suffered several strokes while he was serving as president of Princeton, years before he ran for president, said Post, the author who also serves as professor of psychiatry, political psychology and international affairs at George Washington University. Never did Wilson reveal his medical history to voters, Post said.

In 1919, while campaigning for the Treaty of Versailles, “he suffered a massive stroke, but they concealed it and just said he was under the weather and no one was informed,” Post said. “So we’ve already had the first woman president, his wife Edith. In fact, she was to have said, ‘I don’t know why you men make such a fuss, I had no trouble running the country while Woody was sick.’”

Decades later, “the most important event was the death of Franklin Roosevelt, back in 1945,” said Boston University’s Annas. While the public knew Franklin Delano Roosevelt was wheelchair-bound due to polio when he ran for the fourth time, they did not know he had advanced heart disease and hypertension, which is believed to have contributed to the cerebral hemorrhage that killed him months into his final term.

“The idea of a president dying in office from a disease he knew he had before he ran for election or re-election doesn’t sit quite right with most people,” Annas said.

The ability to lead

Candidates have long been wary of allowing the public to see them as less than “perfection,” as Trump claimed his health would be.

“We want a leader who is all wise and all powerful and in excellent health,” Post said. “If we thought the candidate was ill or failing it would affect his electability.”

John F. Kennedy, at 43 the youngest man to become president, was viewed as healthy and vibrant during his campaign. In reality, he took office suffering from hypothyroidism, back pain and Addison’s disease and was on a daily dose of steroids and a host of other drugs.

President John F. Kennedy was viewed as healthy and vibrant during his campaign.

“Addison’s disease affects your cortisol levels, your ability to handle stress,” said Dr. Connie Mariano, who served as White House physician for Presidents George W. Bush and Bill Clinton. “You wonder, was the Bay of Pigs an issue because he wasn’t adequately treated for Addison’s?”

“Addison’s disease affects your cortisol levels, your ability to handle stress,” said Mariano, the former White House physician. “You wonder, was the Bay of Pigs an issue because he wasn’t adequately treated for Addison’s?”

“There was also some question when George H. W. Bush was diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, or grave’s disease, around the time of the Gulf War,” Mariano continued. “Did that make Bush more hyper and aggressive? Did it affect his memory, or his ability to focus? Can you say Desert Storm was thyroid storm? It’s hard to say.”

President Ronald Reagan was diagnosed with Alzheimer's after his presidency.

Ronald Reagan was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s after his presidency. Whether it affected his ability to function while in office is a subject of debate. Today, however, medical science knows Alzheimer’s begins in the brain 20 to 30 years before symptoms begin.

“Can you rely on the politician’s physician to spot these types of issues? Some illnesses are only known by the symptoms the patient complains of,” Post said. “The softening of mental processes that begin in early Alzheimer’s, for example, may only show up if the politician complains about it.”

Related: Trump’s comb-over and the psychology of men’s hairstyles

Mariano adds that even when there are signs, “you have to remember if there is something wrong with a president that kicks him out of office, everyone who comes with him leaves. So everyone wants to keep him in; they want to silence the doctor.”

And then there’s the specter of mental illness.

Added Mariano, “If you have a mental illness, you’re depressed, you can’t get out of bed, that’s going to affect your ability to do your job.”

A 2006 study by Duke psychiatrists applied today’s diagnostic criteria to historical records of the first 37 presidents between 1776 and 1974 and found 18 of them met the criteria for psychiatric disorders, mostly depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder or alcohol abuse and dependence.

In fact, say the researchers, 10 of the 18 presidents exhibited enough symptoms of mental illness while in office to have affected their ability to lead the nation.

Independent presidential health exam?

In 2008, a high-profile panel of doctors recommended that presidential and vice-presidential candidates be required to undergo a health exam by an independent team of doctors from the American College of Physicians. Mariano was on that committee.

“So we said in a perfect world, wouldn’t it be great if we had a committee that performed physicals and said this person is good to go, just like we do for airline pilots, or in the military,” Mariano said. “It would say, ‘OK, I’m good for four to eight years, I hopefully won’t die of some disease that I’m aware of, I’m mentally sane and I don’t have any drug or alcohol or psychiatric issues and I want to run for office.’”

The recommendation didn’t go anywhere. Mariano now thinks it’s not practical in a polarized political world.

“Part of that is that you have to have compliance by the person who is running for office,” Mariano said. “A lot of them feel like that’s an invasion of their privacy; they’re not willing to share that. And part of it was they’ll say ‘Wait a minute, do the doctors reveal if they’re Democrat or Republican? You know a Republican doctor can say that a Democratic candidate is crazy.’”

Mariano feels that the only good solution is a free and inquisitive press.

“The things that happened with Woodrow Wilson and his stroke, and FDR, and Kennedy – can you do that now? It’s harder to hide things today because you have 24/7 news.”

Modern presidents such as President Bill Clinton sometimes face health questions from reporters or candidates.

“I remember with Bill Clinton: He’d be giving a statement in the Rose Garden and he’d point to a reporter and his hand would be trembling,” Mariano said, reminiscing about her time as White House physician. “And the next inquiry I had from a reporter was ‘Oh my God, does he have Parkinson’s disease?’ No, but he does have a benign essential tremor.”

Whether they have the right to privacy or not, Annas said, it can be taken away from them in the real world.

“The media can ask, or their fellow candidates can press them if they want to,” Annas said.

Which leaves us with the doctor’s letters released by candidates as the only form of assurance about the health of presidential candidates.

“I’m sure the doctors are swayed by their prestigious patient, but I think the public knows that, too,” Annas said. “We take the results with a grain of salt, but it’s better than nothing.”