Defectors: ISIS is killing Muslims, not protecting them

Updated 10:42 AM EDT, Tue September 22, 2015
isis defectors todd dnt tsr_00000220.jpg
ISIS
isis defectors todd dnt tsr_00000220.jpg
Now playing
02:09
ISIS defectors recall stories of horror
Now playing
01:01
Fleeing ISIS in Mosul: Their faces say it all
women flee isis to debaga
CNN
women flee isis to debaga
Now playing
01:58
Women recount horror of life under ISIS
CNN
Now playing
01:30
ISIS survivor tells her story
Nick Paton Walsh Mosul ISIS gunfire orig_00004713.jpg
Nick Paton Walsh Mosul ISIS gunfire orig_00004713.jpg
Now playing
01:20
Iraq forces and ISIS exchange gunfire
Iraqi women react as people gather on July 9, 2016 at the site of a suicide-bombing attack which took place on July 3 in Baghdad's Karrada neighbourhood.

The Baghdad bombing claimed by the Islamic State group killed 292 people, according to a new toll issued on July 7, many of whom were trapped in blazing buildings and burned alive. A suicide bomber detonated an explosives-laden minibus early on July 3, ahead of the Eid al-Fitr holiday marking the end of the holy Muslim fasting month of Ramadan. / AFP / AHMAD AL-RUBAYE        (Photo credit should read AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images)
AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images
Iraqi women react as people gather on July 9, 2016 at the site of a suicide-bombing attack which took place on July 3 in Baghdad's Karrada neighbourhood. The Baghdad bombing claimed by the Islamic State group killed 292 people, according to a new toll issued on July 7, many of whom were trapped in blazing buildings and burned alive. A suicide bomber detonated an explosives-laden minibus early on July 3, ahead of the Eid al-Fitr holiday marking the end of the holy Muslim fasting month of Ramadan. / AFP / AHMAD AL-RUBAYE (Photo credit should read AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:24
Majority of ISIS victims are Muslim
ISIS
Now playing
01:23
Is it ISIS, ISIL or Daesh?
Now playing
02:19
ISIS' battle tactics
CNN
Now playing
00:46
Why Libya matters to ISIS
ISIS hates yazidis terrorist group target orig cm_00000923.jpg
ISIS hates yazidis terrorist group target orig cm_00000923.jpg
Now playing
01:57
ISIS hates this religious group the most
iraq isis human shields damon pkg_00013513.jpg
iraq isis human shields damon pkg_00013513.jpg
Now playing
02:44
Iraqis recount horrors of being human shields for ISIS
isis fratricide robertson pkg_00002526.jpg
SITE Monitoring
isis fratricide robertson pkg_00002526.jpg
Now playing
02:43
ISIS calls on Saudi supporters to kill relatives
ISIS released still pictures purporting to show massive parade of their militants in the city of Sirte, Libya
ISIS
ISIS released still pictures purporting to show massive parade of their militants in the city of Sirte, Libya
Now playing
02:30
Why is ISIS heading to Libya?
iraqi town suffering after isis chemical attack damon pkg cnn today_00010115.jpg
iraqi town suffering after isis chemical attack damon pkg cnn today_00010115.jpg
Now playing
02:34
Iraqi town suffering from ISIS chemical attack

Editor’s Note: Peter R. Neumann is professor of Security Studies and director of the International Centre for the Study of Radicalization (ICSR) at King’s College London.

The ICSR released a new report Monday, “The Narratives of Islamic State Defectors,” cataloging the experiences of those who leave ISIS.

London CNN —  

Much has been written about the young men and women who join the Islamic State. We are familiar with their biographies and pathways, backgrounds and motivations.

But virtually nothing is known about those who quit: the “defectors” who didn’t like what they saw, abandoned their comrades and fled the Islamic State. Yet their stories could be key to stopping the flow of foreign fighters, countering the group’s propaganda and exposing its lies and hypocrisy.

For a short paper, I collected all published stories about people who have left the Islamic State and spoken about their defection. I discovered a total of 58 – a sizable number but probably only a fraction of those who are disillusioned or ready to leave.

They are a new and growing phenomenon. Of the 58 cases, nearly two thirds of the defections took place in the year 2015. One third happened during the summer months alone.

The defectors’ experiences are diverse. Not everyone has become a fervent supporter of liberal democracy. Some may, in fact, have committed crimes. They were all, at some point, enthusiastic supporters of the most violent and viciously totalitarian organization of our age. Yet they are now its worst enemies.

The quality of their testimony varies, and the precise circumstances and reasons for leaving the Islamic State aren’t always clear. What convinced me that, as a whole, their stories are credible is how consistent their messages were.

Among the 58 defector stories, I found four narratives that were particularly strong:

One of the most persistent criticisms was the extent to which the group is fighting against other Sunni rebels. According to the defectors, toppling the Assad regime didn’t seem to be a priority, and little was done to help the (Sunni) Muslims who were targeted by it.

Opinion: What ISIS and the West get wrong about ‘jihad’

Most of the group’s attention, they said, was consumed by quarrels with other rebels and the leadership’s obsession with “spies” and “traitors.” This was not the kind of jihad they had come to Syria and Iraq to fight.

Another narrative dealt with the group’s brutality. Many complained about atrocities and the killing of innocent civilians. They talked about the random killing of hostages, the systematic mistreatment of villagers and the execution of fighters by their own commanders.

None of the episodes they mentioned involved minorities, however. Brutality didn’t seem to be a universal concern: it was seen through a sectarian lens, and caused outrage mostly when its victims were other Sunnis.

The third narrative was corruption. Though none believed that corruption was systemic, many disapproved of the conduct of individual commanders and “emirs.” Syrian defectors criticized the privileges that were given to foreigners, for which they claimed was no justification based on the group’s philosophy or Islam in general.

Opinion: When bigots use ISIS atrocities to smear all Muslims

While many were willing to tolerate the hardships of war, they found it impossible to accept instances of unfairness, inequality and racism. “This is not a holy war,” said a defector from India, whom the group had forced to clean toilets because of his color of skin.

A fourth narrative was that life under the Islamic State was harsh and disappointing. The defectors who expressed this view were typically the ones who had joined the group for “selfish” reasons – and who quickly realized that none of the luxury goods and cars that they had been promised would materialize.

For others, their experience in combat didn’t live up to their expectations of action and heroism. One of them referred to his duties as “dull” and complained about the lack of deployments, while another claimed that foreign fighters were “exploited” and used as cannon fodder.

Opinion: No, ISIS doesn’t represent Islam

These stories matter. The defectors’ very existence shatters the image of unity and determination that the group seeks to convey. Their narratives highlight the group’s contradictions and hypocrisies. Their example may encourage others to follow, and their credibility can help deter wannabes from joining.

In my view, governments and civil society should recognize the defectors’ value and make it easier for them to speak out. Where possible, governments should assist them in resettlement and ensure their safety. They also need to remove legal disincentives that prevent them from going public.

Not every defector is a saint, and not all of them are ready or willing to stand in the public spotlight. But their voices are strong and clear: “The Islamic State is not protecting Muslims. It is killing them.” They need to be heard.