hillary clinton classified emails sot nr_00004223.jpg
hillary clinton classified emails sot nr_00004223.jpg
Now playing
01:10
Hillary Clinton denies mishandling classified emails
CNN Illustration/Getty Images
Now playing
00:46
Toobin: Not a good day for the FBI
SAN FRANCISCO, CA - MARCH 28:  Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton delivers a keynote address during the 28th Annual Professional Business Women of California conference on March 28, 2017 in San Francisco, California. Hillary Clinton delivered the keynote address at the day-long conference featuring speakers, seminars and panel discussions with industry leaders.  (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
SAN FRANCISCO, CA - MARCH 28: Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton delivers a keynote address during the 28th Annual Professional Business Women of California conference on March 28, 2017 in San Francisco, California. Hillary Clinton delivered the keynote address at the day-long conference featuring speakers, seminars and panel discussions with industry leaders. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:14
See key moments from the Clinton email scandal (2018)
title:  duration: 00:00:00 site:  author:  published:  intervention: yes description:
The Hill
title: duration: 00:00:00 site: author: published: intervention: yes description:
Now playing
01:53
Sessions: Clinton probe report will reassure US
James Comey Town Hall 4-25-18-2
CNN
James Comey Town Hall 4-25-18-2
Now playing
02:38
Comey: It was a nightmare of a decision
CNN Annotation/White House Photo
Now playing
01:55
Trump adviser pursued Clinton emails on dark web
James Comey Loretta Lynch matter investigation queasy_00000000.jpg
James Comey Loretta Lynch matter investigation queasy_00000000.jpg
Now playing
02:06
Comey: Lynch request gave me queasy feeling
U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he walks with his wife Melania to Marine One while departing from the White House on July 12, 2017 in Washington, DC. President Trump is traveling to France where he will meet with President Emmanuel Macron and will attend Bastille Day events on Friday.
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he walks with his wife Melania to Marine One while departing from the White House on July 12, 2017 in Washington, DC. President Trump is traveling to France where he will meet with President Emmanuel Macron and will attend Bastille Day events on Friday.
Now playing
02:49
The path to Trump's call for Russia to 'find' Clinton emails
Mike Pence defends private email server sot_00000000.jpg
Pool
Mike Pence defends private email server sot_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:00
Pence defends private email use
GOP operative Peter Smith committed suicide at age 81 shortly after describing to the WSJ his efforts online to track down Hillary Clinton's emails, which he believed had been hacked and stolen from her private server.
KTTC, KIMT, Twitter, Legacy.com, Chicago Sun-Times
GOP operative Peter Smith committed suicide at age 81 shortly after describing to the WSJ his efforts online to track down Hillary Clinton's emails, which he believed had been hacked and stolen from her private server.
Now playing
03:14
GOP activist hunted Clinton emails, found dead
cnnee pkg rodriguez clinton global iniciative hillary emails_00002301.jpg
cnnee pkg rodriguez clinton global iniciative hillary emails_00002301.jpg
Now playing
02:47
Hillary Clinton's explanations of her email saga
SOTU Lynch comey letter_00004405.jpg
SOTU Lynch comey letter_00004405.jpg
Now playing
01:42
Lynch: My views on Comey letter were known
hillary clinton
New York Times
hillary clinton
Now playing
02:42
Warrant sheds light on Clinton email probe
US President Barack Obama and Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton arrive at a campaign event in Charlotte, North Carolina, on July 5, 2016. / AFP / NICHOLAS KAMM        (Photo credit should read NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/Getty Images)
NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
US President Barack Obama and Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton arrive at a campaign event in Charlotte, North Carolina, on July 5, 2016. / AFP / NICHOLAS KAMM (Photo credit should read NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:04
Obama: Hillary Clinton was not treated fairly
WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 27:  FBI Director James Comey waits for the beginning of a hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee September 27, 2016 on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC. The committee held a hearing on "Fifteen Years After 9/11: Threats to the Homeland."  (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Alex Wong/Getty Images
WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 27: FBI Director James Comey waits for the beginning of a hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee September 27, 2016 on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC. The committee held a hearing on "Fifteen Years After 9/11: Threats to the Homeland." (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:32
FBI clears Clinton in email probe
Getty Images
Now playing
01:28
Trump: Clinton is guilty and she knows it

Story highlights

Hillary Clinton has denied sending classified information from personal server

Inspectors general find sample of emails contained classified information

Douglas Cox: Political stakes, voices on both sides make finding the truth challenging

Editor’s Note: Douglas Cox is an associate professor at the City University of New York School of Law. The views expressed are his own.

(CNN) —  

Of the many allegations related to Hillary Clinton’s emails – ranging from reasonable to conspiratorial – the most serious are the findings by two inspectors general that Clinton’s private email server contained classified information and a related referral to the FBI concerning a “potential compromise of classified information.” While details remain unclear, the alleged presence of classified information on a private email server undoubtedly has legal implications for the controversy – and places a strain on Clinton’s public defense.

When Clinton initially addressed the email controversy, her assurances that the emails contained no classified information were broad, unequivocal and perhaps overconfident. Indeed, for anyone who has witnessed the State Department’s liberal use of redactions of classified information in publicly released documents, the assertion that thousands of emails sent and received by a secretary of state would not contain any classified information, even if only inadvertently, strained credulity.

Douglas Cox
Douglas Cox

Predictably, once the State Department began releasing portions of Clinton’s emails, they contained redactions for classified information. Clinton’s ready response was that these were “retroactive” classifications in which previously unclassified information was upgraded to classified when it was reviewed for public release. Therefore, Clinton’s defense that at the time the emails had contained no classified information survived.

The inspectors general found, however, that a sample of Clinton’s emails contains information that was classified “when they were generated,” which therefore “should never have been transmitted via an unclassified personal system.” This is a significant, serious allegation that cannot be lightly dismissed.

Clinton has doubled down and reasserted that she is “confident” no information in her emails was classified at the time, but her confidence in the precise content of 55,000 pages of emails sent years ago has to be waning. Further, if the concerns of the inspectors general materialize that potentially “hundreds” of emails contained information classified at the time and that it is “more likely than not” that the emails Clinton kept on a private server contain some “top secret” information, the most sensitive category, Clinton might be in the unenviable position of asserting that the intelligence community is simply wrong or that their conclusions are politically motivated.

First round of Hillary Clinton State Department emails released

Clinton also argues the emails “did not contain any classified markings,” a significantly more tenuous defense. As all government employees with security clearances are advised, classified information is not always marked. The standard classified information nondisclosure agreement, for example, defines classified information as “marked or unmarked classified information,” and requires the return of such information to the government at the end of one’s employment under threat of possible criminal charges.

How should Clinton respond moving forward?

Clinton emails: Obama aides knew of private address

A more bold strategy for Clinton that might have benefits beyond her own defense would be to shine a light on this murky world of classification decisions, which are less exact science and more art – sometimes abstract art – that can be a trap for the unwary.

Differing conclusions among different agencies about what is and is not classified in Clinton’s emails is a clear example. Overclassification is unquestionably epidemic among government departments, and allegations of mishandling of classified information have increasingly been used against defendants who appear to be more whistleblower than traitor.

Still, taking up this banner might be too adventurous for Clinton, whose predicament arose, in her own retelling, simply from a desire to avoid a second device. Instead, should the allegations of the inspectors general take root, a final line of defense would be for Clinton to assert that she was simply unaware that the information in the emails was classified at the time.

Inside Clinton’s Benghazi emails

The trouble with this approach is that any ongoing review and public release of additional emails could disclose sufficient context to determine the nature or subject matter of redacted classified information, in which case the credibility of such assertions would be tested. And while a lack of knowledge may be sufficient to avoid criminal allegations, even negligent handling of classified information can provide grounds for loss of a security clearance or other sanctions. Such issues arose, for example, in the context of the leak of Valerie Plame’s identity, where certain Bush administration officials may not have known – but should have – of Plame’s covert status.

To be clear, Clinton’s “unclassified” emails containing some classified information is not as extraordinary as some would suggest. Indeed, it is likely true of the emails of most senior officials whose responsibilities implicate foreign affairs and national security. Yet this reality only underscores why it is crucial for such communications to remain in government control, as required by the federal records laws where the controversy over Clinton sequestering official emails on a private server began.

In the end, the high political stakes and aggressive voices on both sides make finding the middle – or the truth – challenging. There is, so far, no evidence Clinton has committed a criminal act, and those making such allegations risk overplaying their hand. In fact, had there actually been a criminal referral against Clinton, it would likely serve as a silver bullet for Clinton’s public defense. Such referrals rarely result in criminal investigations, much less charges, and the eventual, inevitable decision not to pursue the matter would allow Clinton to claim vindication.

Ultimately, though, details about the private email server continue. And as they do, they are making Clinton’s blanket assertions that she faithfully followed all laws and regulations related to both federal records and classified information increasingly untenable.

Join us on Facebook.com/CNNOpinion.
Read CNNOpinion’s new Flipboard magazine.