Threatened, assaulted, trapped: Asia’s treatment of domestic workers laid bare

“The first time she hit me was pay day; she told me to sign my name on a piece of paper, but I asked, ‘why should I sign when you didn’t give me the money?’ Then, she hit me.”

A 30-year-old Indonesian domestic worker, who now calls herself Susi, describes the start of the abuse cycle which shaped her life for nearly a year.

She was threatened, assaulted and trapped in the house of her employer in Hong Kong, Law Wan-tung, after being placed in the job by an employment agent.

“She only allowed me to sleep from 6 a.m. to 10 a.m.; every day was only four hours of sleep,” Susi said. “I was only allowed to use the bathroom three times a day. She didn’t allow me to have a day off. Nothing was allowed.”

Stories of suffering

Susi’s story is just one example of the physical and mental abuse foreign domestic workers say they face in Asia and the Middle East.

A photography exhibition currently on display at the Foreign Correspondent’s Club in Hong Kong aims to expose the extent of that suffering.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

'Beth', now 20, from rural Philippines, abused in Manila —

"My employer would bang my head on the wall and she would throw hot water on me. She would burn my skin with cigarettes. She said this was the punishment for my sins." Beth said she was sold by her sister to a couple in Manila when she was 10. She worked from 4 a.m. until late every day, cleaning and looking after their small child. She was not paid. Her female employer beat her frequently with sticks, pots or pans. When her employer's boyfriend was out, she would burn Beth with cigarettes. After seven years of being locked in the house, she escaped. Beth said, until then, she had never been to school, watched television, listened to music or the radio.

Photos: 6 stabbed at Jerusalem gay pride parade

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

Sritak, now 31, from Indonesia, abused in Taiwan —

"He took a fork that he had heated on the stove-top and put it on my hand. He pressed the hot fork onto my hand ... It's quite strange, like he had the devil inside." Sritak left her village because her family were too poor to eat every day. She worked from 6 a.m. to midnight daily. Her passport was taken away and she wasn't allowed to talk to her family or outsiders. She said her employer beat her -- once with an iron pipe. He accused her of stealing and poured hot water on her body. She has more than 20 scars, including a long slash across her face.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

Sumasri, from Indonesia, abused in Malaysia —

"I go to the clinic regularly to get medication. Now it is not painful any more. It was most painful the first four months." Sumasri's back and thighs are heavily scarred from the boiling water she said her male employer in Kuala Lumpur threw on her. The story of what exactly happened to her often changes when she recounts it.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

'Anis', now 26, from Indonesia, abused in Hong Kong —

Five days after Anis arrived, the family's barking dog woke -- and enraged -- her female employer. Shouting in Cantonese, Anis said her employer pulled Anis into the kitchen and grabbed a butcher's knife. Anis jerked away, but her ring finger tendon was sliced and the bone fractured. She escaped with the help of a security guard at her building and another domestic worker.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

Susi, now 30, from Indonesia, abused in Hong Kong —

"My employer said she's very rich. She also said, 'If I hit you and kill you, no one will know that.' The agent tried to calm me down, saying, 'I will give you a very good employer if you don't tell anyone (about this).'" Susi worked 20-hour days, only sleeping as the sun came up. Her Hong Kong employer frequently slapped her and made her sign a paper saying wages had been paid. After seven months without contact, her family forced a meeting, and Susi left the employer. The agent then placed another domestic worker in that home.
Susi's employer subsequently hired (through a different agency) another Indonesian domestic worker, Erwiana Sulistyaningsih, whose eight months of ill treatment made international headlines and resulted in criminal convictions.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

Mary Grace, now 35, from the Philippines, abused in Malaysia —

"The owner of the agency is so bad. He said to me, 'F**k you. You bitch. Your family and your young son will die.' Then he threw his coffee mug at my face." Mary Grace needed to earn money for school fees and to feed her family. She said she had two employers, neither of whom gave her enough to eat. One day she fainted while grocery shopping. She claims she woke up in an ambulance to find the attendant sexually abusing her. When she tried to report the assault at the hospital a nurse told her to be quiet. She left Malaysia with no earnings.

Photos: Asia's abused maids tell their stories

Steve McCurry

Haryatin, now 36, from Indonesia, abused in Saudi Arabia —

"I once said, 'If you don't like me, please send me to the office, please send me home.' She said, 'How nice, how lucky you are to go home. If I don't like, I just hit or I kill you.'" Haryatin needed money to pay for her daughter's education. She worked for a woman with nine children who continually insulted and hit her and made her sleep in a storage room. At 3 a.m., while Haryatin was washing the children's school uniforms, she said her employer rubbed the baby's faeces-filled diaper into her face because she hadn't been quick enough to change it. Haryatin lost her sight soon after being hit on the head with a pipe. She said she was forced to stay and keep working until the swelling disappeared.

Prev Next

One victim, an Indonesian grandmother named Sumasri, had been doused in boiling water by her employer in Malaysia, leaving painful scars on her back and legs. Another, Sritak, is covered in dozens of scars, including one from a searing hot fork that was pressed into her skin by her boss in Taiwan.

The pictures were taken by award-winning photographer, Steve McCurry, and the project was organized by the United Nations agency, the International Labor Organization (ILO).

The ILO estimates that there are more than 52 million domestic workers worldwide. But activists say that in many countries, especially in Asia, they have no legal protection.

Death threats

Susi, whose real name is Tutik Lestari Ningish, said her situation got worse when her employer started threatening to kill her family in Indonesia.

“She would say: ‘If you ever talk back, or try to leave, I could kill you and your family, because I’m very resourceful.’ That’s why I was terrified. I endured her beatings, but hoped that she wouldn’t beat me to death, because I have a son who’s very young.”

“That was my first time working in Hong Kong; I knew nothing; I didn’t even know how to make a phone call. I hated her so much, but I didn’t know how to stand up for myself,” she said.

Escape route

Eventually, Susi managed to escape after her family in Indonesia demanded to know what happened to their daughter, as they had not heard from her for so long.

Still, Susi did not report the case to the authorities, in case Law followed through on her threats.

But then Susi heard that another domestic worker, Erwiana Sulistyaningsih, had ended up in hospital after suffering more than seven months of abuse at the hands of Law.

“I immediately made up my mind to speak up, because if I didn’t, then the next person would be mistreated by her too. Even though I was afraid, I could talk about my experience. I don’t want anyone to go through what I have been through.”

Susi and Erwiana successfully testified against Law who was found guilty of 18 charges including grievous bodily harm, false imprisonment and criminal intimidation.

She was jailed for six years.

‘Like slaves’

“In some places, they earn as little as $9 a month. In others, they don’t earn any salaries at all, so they are really like slaves,” said Elizabeth Tang, General Secretary of the International Domestic Workers Federation.

Tang says attitudes won’t change until workers’ legal rights improve.

“It is time governments step in and take the lead to change the law, so that they are treated the same as any other workers,” she said.

Journalist Karen Emmons, who produced the exhibit, said she was moved to start the project documenting the abuse because she was hearing similar stories year after year.

“I wanted to show the evidence of the abuse that’s going on in the privacy of homes,” she said.

“I wanted their stories and the abuse they had endured to reach out to people who can make a difference, and reach out to employers to tell them somebody is watching; we know what’s going on.”

CNN intern Wayne Chang provided additional reporting