Journalists' Syndicate in Egypt decries the proposed law as "dangerous and unconstitutional"
Proposed law has severe penalties if news organizations counter official reports in terrorism cases
A new anti-terrorism law in Egypt will make publishing news that contradicts the official version of events in terrorism-related cases a crime punishable by prison sentences, a setback for the freedom of the press, according to the local journalists union.
The anti-terrorism draft law lists more than 25 crimes, 12 of which are punishable by death. It was approved by the Cabinet and the State Council and is pending the approval of President Abdel-Fattah el-Sisi, who has legislative powers in the absence of a parliament.
A terrorist attack on military outposts in Sinai led to an hourslong battle in a town near the Gaza border, killing at least 17 soldiers and over 200 militants on July 1, the military said. Some local and international media said military casualties were between 50 and 70.
Egyptian authorities criticized such reports. In a video released by the Ministry of Defense, Al-Jazeera network and Muslim Brotherhood affiliated TV channels were singled out for spreading false news and participating in anti-military propaganda.
The military removed the Brotherhood-affiliated president Mohamed Morsy from power in 2013 after mass protests. A deadly security crackdown and a wave of terrorism left hundreds of civilians, police and soldiers dead over the past two years.
‘Chained by the law’
Last Wednesday’s attack in Sinai was “unprecedented in the number of militants involved and the weapons used,” a high-ranking security official told CNN. Together with the assassination of the prosecutor general two days prior, it prompted calls for an anti-terrorism law in a bid to combat terrorism and bring justice.
“The hands of swift justice is chained by the law,” el-Sisi said on June 30, during the funeral of the Prosecutor General Hesham Barakat.
Barakat was killed in an explosion that targeted his convoy on June 29.
“Egypt is at the forefront of the fight against terrorism. We are cooperating with our international partners,” Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry told journalists on Saturday.
The press briefing included “observations” on foreign media’s coverage of the latest terrorist attacks. Guidelines handed it out to journalists suggested the use of words such as “terrorists, rebels, slayers and eradicators” instead of “jihadists.”
El-Sisi’s call for expedited judicial procedure and implementations of verdicts was answered in the quick drafting of a number of laws, led by the anti-terrorism law.
The draft law, which got the approval of a number of political parties and regime allies, “transcends the main goal of the law of combating terrorism to appropriating freedom of the press,” the Journalists’ Syndicate said in a statement.
According to a draft of the law published by local media, the law stipulates no less than two years in prison for “publishing false news or statements about terrorist operations in contradiction to official statements.”
‘Dangerous and unconstitutional’
The Journalists’ Syndicate noted four other articles of the law that were also “dangerous and unconstitutional.”
“It appropriates the right of the journalist to acquire information from different sources and limits it to one side. This is a clear setback for the freedom of thought and press,” the syndicate was quoted as saying by the state-run daily Al-Ahram.
Eighteen journalists are in prison in Egypt, according to the Committee to Protect Journalists’ tally in June – the highest in Egypt’s history in CPJ records. “The threat of imprisonment in Egypt is part of an atmosphere in which authorities pressure media outlets to censor critical voices,” CPJ said.
“Authorities don’t want journalists to reach Egyptians, but want to control all information and be the only source of information,” Khaled El-Balshy, the head of the freedoms committee at the Journalists’ Syndicate, told CNN. The syndicate called for an emergency meeting on Monday to discuss the draft law in a bid to lobby for the removal or amendment of the controversial articles.
For rights groups, the government’s restrictive measures would be counterproductive.
“More attacks on civil and political rights and freedoms by security institutions won’t be a successful solution in the face of all these [terrorist] threats,” 14 Egyptian rights groups said in a joint statement last week.
Answering questions about that possible wide interpretations for terrorism and incitement in the draft law, the foreign minister said that “it will be up to the judge to determine what constitutes incitement.”