Carter, Dempsey paint bleak picture of Iraq situation

Updated 3:32 PM EDT, Wed June 17, 2015
iraq isis troops carter dempsey mcsally wolf_00012301.jpg
iraq isis troops carter dempsey mcsally wolf_00012301.jpg
Now playing
02:54
Sec. Carter: 'Mixed' performance from Iraqi troops
Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush speaks during the NRA-ILA Leadership Forum at the 2015 NRA Annual Meeting & Exhibits on April 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee.
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush speaks during the NRA-ILA Leadership Forum at the 2015 NRA Annual Meeting & Exhibits on April 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee.
Now playing
01:06
Jeb Bush: I would not have gone into Iraq
BAGHDAD, IRAQ ? OCTOBER 17: Ousted Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein adresses the court during his trial in the heavily fortified Green Zone October 17, 2006 in Baghdad, Iraq. Hussein and six co-defendants have been on trial since August 21, 2006 for the Anfal campaign of bombings and gas attacks against Kurdish rebels in 1987-1988. It is believed the Anfal campaign left up to 180,000 dead.  (Photo by David Furst-Pool/Getty Images)
David Furst/Pool/Getty Images
BAGHDAD, IRAQ ? OCTOBER 17: Ousted Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein adresses the court during his trial in the heavily fortified Green Zone October 17, 2006 in Baghdad, Iraq. Hussein and six co-defendants have been on trial since August 21, 2006 for the Anfal campaign of bombings and gas attacks against Kurdish rebels in 1987-1988. It is believed the Anfal campaign left up to 180,000 dead. (Photo by David Furst-Pool/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:12
Bremer: Iraq better off without Hussein
jk look back at iraq war_00001825
jk look back at iraq war_00001825
Now playing
03:30
Iraq war ends, WMDs never found
newday intv branson mandela stopping Iraq war _00002701.jpg
newday intv branson mandela stopping Iraq war _00002701.jpg
Now playing
02:40
Branson: Mandela planned to stop Iraq war
Jeb Bush ISIS Iraq War Student Debate AR ORIGWX_00003024.jpg
Jeb Bush ISIS Iraq War Student Debate AR ORIGWX_00003024.jpg
Now playing
01:42
Student to Jeb Bush 'Your brother created ISIS'
Members of the Bush family
Members of the Bush family
Now playing
01:44
The Bush family and Iraq
US Vice President Joe Biden (L) meets with General Lloyd Austin, the commander of United States Forces - Iraq (USF-I), and US ambassador in Iraq James Jeffrey (unseen) at the US embassy upon the former's arrival at Baghdad on a surprise visit on November 29, 2011, during which he is due to meet top Iraqi officials, as American troops depart Iraq ahead of a year-end deadline. AFP PHOTO/AHMAD AL-RUBAYE (Photo credit should read AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
US Vice President Joe Biden (L) meets with General Lloyd Austin, the commander of United States Forces - Iraq (USF-I), and US ambassador in Iraq James Jeffrey (unseen) at the US embassy upon the former's arrival at Baghdad on a surprise visit on November 29, 2011, during which he is due to meet top Iraqi officials, as American troops depart Iraq ahead of a year-end deadline. AFP PHOTO/AHMAD AL-RUBAYE (Photo credit should read AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:02
U.S. and Iraqi troops honored
nr phillips wiseman iraq war_00002001
nr phillips wiseman iraq war_00002001
Now playing
00:59
Pilot: Iraq War made me grow up
U.S. soldiers with the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment walk on a patrol on July 17, 2011, in Iskandariya, Iraq.
AFP/Getty Images/File
U.S. soldiers with the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment walk on a patrol on July 17, 2011, in Iskandariya, Iraq.
Now playing
02:54
White House: Iraqi troops are ready
vause 9 11 reflections_00002815
vause 9 11 reflections_00002815
Now playing
03:15
9/11 and the war on terror
Washington Post reporters Carl Bernstein, left, and Bob Woodward broke stories about the President Richard Nixon administration's cover-up after the June 1972 break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters. The coverage earned the Post a Pulitzer Price and sparked a congressional investigation that eventually led to Nixon's resignation in 1974.
Paul Slade/Paris Match via Getty Images
Washington Post reporters Carl Bernstein, left, and Bob Woodward broke stories about the President Richard Nixon administration's cover-up after the June 1972 break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters. The coverage earned the Post a Pulitzer Price and sparked a congressional investigation that eventually led to Nixon's resignation in 1974.
Now playing
01:40
Woodward & Bernstein's take on Iraq
Jewel Samad | Justin Sullivan
Now playing
01:58
First Jeb Bush, now Rubio stumble over Iraq question
Iraq Inspectors Report_00025715.jpg
Iraq Inspectors Report_00025715.jpg
Now playing
03:28
Report critical of U.S. war in Iraq
Jeb Bush Obama abandons Iraq_00002515.jpg
Jeb Bush Obama abandons Iraq_00002515.jpg
Now playing
01:00
Obama 'abandoned' Iraq, Jeb Bush says
Washington CNN —  

America’s two top defense officials presented a dismal outlook on the situation in Iraq Wednesday during testimony before the House Armed Services Committee, even addressing possible U.S. policy if the country’s current borders dissolve.

Defense Secretary Ashton Carter conceded that the U.S. did not move quickly enough to arm Iraqi Security Forces in their struggle against ISIS, and disclosed that the U.S. will train just 7,000 of the 24,000 Iraqi troops it had expected to by the fall due to a lack of recruits. Meanwhile, Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, cautioned skeptical committee members that there are limits to what America can do to stabilize a country torn by sectarian strife and the advances of ISIS, also known as ISIL.

“I would not recommend that we put U.S. forces in harm’s way simply to stiffen the spine of local forces,” Dempsey said. “If their spine is not stiffened by the threat of ISIL or their way of life, nothing we do is going to stiffen their spine.”

Carter and Dempsey delivered their outline of the Obama administration’s strategy for countering ISIS as it contributes to an increasingly unstable Iraq, 12 years after the launch of the Iraq War. They also discussed training Sunni tribes’ fighters as part of the decision announced last week to send 450 additional U.S. forces to the country.

In explaining why Iraqi forces were not equipped more quickly, Carter said the process was “sometimes delayed by bureaucracy in Baghdad, but occasionally also in Washington.”

“That is why we are now expediting delivery of essential equipment and material, like anti-tank capabilities and counter-IED equipment, to the Iraqi security forces – including Kurdish and Sunni tribal forces,” Carter said.

Carter also said that the U.S. has not been receiving the help it needs from the Iraqi government, repeating a critique he made last month that Iraqi forces showed “no will to fight” during the fall of Ramadi to ISIS forces.

Dempsey, who is retiring shortly, said that a number of factors, including the various regional governments struggling to establish legitimacy, have contributed to the instability which has slowly dragged the U.S. back into the Iraq conflict.

But, Dempsey said, “Enduring stability cannot be imposed from the outside in. Stability must be cultivated from the inside out.”

’Are we winning?’

Carter addressed what would happen if a “multi-sectarian Iraq” – a country where Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds live together – is not possible.

“If that government can’t do what it’s supposed to do, then we will still try to enable local ground forces, if they’re willing to partner with us, to keep stability in Iraq,” he said. “But there will not be a single state of Iraq.”

At one point, an exchange between Dempsey and Minnesota Republican Rep. John Kline became contentious over the situation.

“Where are we in Iraq today?” Kline asked. “Are we winning? Are we losing? Is it a stalemate? Is it a quagmire? What is Iraq today?”

A testy Dempsey pushed back against what he said was the congressman’s use of “the personal pronoun ‘we,’” saying it was up to the Iraqis, not the U.S., to prevail in the country.

“This has to be them, right? So if you’re asking, ‘Is the United States winning?’ that’s the wrong question,” the general replied.

He went on to highlight the “lily pad” strategy announced last week that could require opening multiple outposts at Iraqi bases near the front lines to build what he said Wednesday would be “a network of regional stakeholders to confront this threat, because, frankly, that’s the only way it will be resolved.”

Kline, however, was unconvinced.

“We really don’t have a strategy. You’ve articulated a piece of what would be sort of a strategy,” he said.

Washington Rep. Adam Smith, the panel’s top Democrat, asked aloud if a unified Iraq was still salvageable.