This handout photo taken on February 28, 2013 and received from the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) on April 13, 2015 shows an aerial shot of a structure after a large-scale reclamation by China on the Chinese-held Johnson South Reef -- also claimed by the Philippines and Vietnam -- in what is part of the disputed Spratly chain. The Philippines released photographs on May 15, 2014 to back its claim that China was reclaiming land on the disputed reef, known as Mabini Reef in the Philippines, in the South China Sea in an apparent effort to build an airstrip. Beijing reaffirmed its right to build on disputed islands in the South China Sea on April 9, 2015 after new satellite imagery emerged of construction operations further south in the Spratly islands at Mischief Reef, turning tropical reefs into concrete artificial islands. The Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan all have overlapping claims in the area. AFP PHOTO / Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs
China, U.S. exchange barbs over artificial islands
05:33 - Source: CNN

Story highlights

U.S. "deeply concerned" about Beijing's activities in South China Sea

State-run media: Claims of Chinese militarization "sensationalized" by West

CNN  — 

As China rapidly builds new artificial islands in the South China Sea to expand its territory claim there, Washington is adamantly refusing to recognize those claims.

On Saturday, U.S. Defense Secretary Ash Carter called for “an immediate and lasting halt” to the practice.

“The United States is deeply concerned about the pace and scope of land reclamation in the South China Sea,” Carter said in a speech before diplomats in Singapore. “The prospect of further militarization as well as the potential for these activities to increase the risk of miscalculation or conflict among claimant states.”

Carter’s Australian and Japanese counterparts weighed in with similar statements as well on Saturday, but a Chinese defense official fired back, dismissing concerns over militarization as “incomplete and (lacking) jurisprudential evidence.”

“Freedom of navigation should be for the benefits of economic development, rather than sending military aircraft and vessels everywhere,” Rear Adm. Guan Youfei said of Carter’s speech to state-run news agency Xinhua.


Last week, a U.S. surveillance plane carrying a CNN crew swooped over such artificial islands, triggering eight warnings from the Chinese navy to back off. U.S. officials are concerned about China’s militarization of some of the islands and is trying to create public awareness of it, but Chinese media slammed the issue as being manufactured and “sensationalized on purpose” by the West.

As reported in Xinhua, Huang Jing, the director of the Center on Asia and Globalization at the National University of Singapore, said that “(t)he South China Sea issue has been there for decades. Why was it not a big issue previously, but (is) one now? In some sense, the South China Sea issue was sensationalized on purpose.”

Fear of conflict

Anger has simmered over the South China Sea among China and neighboring countries, such as Vietnam and the Philippines, which have argued about existing territorial claims and mineral rights underneath them.

Some of those nations have also built up a few new artificial islands as well.

But of the governments participating in land reclamation, Carter singled out Beijing for particular criticism.

“One country has gone much further and much faster than any other, and that’s China. China has reclaimed over 2,000 acres, more than all other claimants combined and more than in the entire history of the region. And China did so in only the last 18 months.” Many of China’s artificial islands are much closer to other countries’ mainland shores than they are to its own.

Carter called for an immediate stop to land reclamation by all nations and a stop to the militarization of the existing ones.

A depiction of where exactly China is building islands out of nothing, 600 miles off the coast of its mainland.

Former CIA Deputy Director Michael Morell told CNN this week that the confrontation could “absolutely” present a risk of the U.S. and China going to war sometime in the future.

Carter was speaking to diplomats at an Asia-Pacific security conference in Singapore.

It is part of President Barack Obama’s strategic and economic “pivot to Asia” policy.

Although he expressed concerns over possible conflicts, Secretary Carter said solutions are limited. “We all know there’s no military solution to the South China Sea disputes,” he said.

He called for renewed diplomacy.

CNN’s Jim Sciutto and Ashley Corum contributed to this report.