Cyclists use cameras to document reckless driving

Updated 12:50 PM EDT, Wed May 13, 2015
Courtesy Alan Crocker
Now playing
01:20
Assault caught on biker's helmet cam
A thatched dwelling in the deep Amazon belonging to an uncontacted tribe, seen from a drone.
National Indian Foundation/Funai
A thatched dwelling in the deep Amazon belonging to an uncontacted tribe, seen from a drone.
Now playing
00:46
Never before seen Amazon tribe filmed by drone
title: File uploaded by user duration: 00:00:00 site:  author:  published:  intervention: no description:
Rob Morin
title: File uploaded by user duration: 00:00:00 site: author: published: intervention: no description:
Now playing
00:55
Camera catches mailman stealing family's tomatoes
Krystina Reyes
Now playing
01:07
Man trapped in SUV as floodwaters rise
A1 OPEN-no govt shutdown/clues inside bomber's home/cheerleader chases laptop thief-TN    A3-SENAYTE PASSES SPENDING BILL-EG    A4-TEASE AHEAD-LAWMAKER REAX-EG    A6-WHO IS BOLTON-GERGEN SOT-LT    A98-MCDOUGAL TALKS ABOUT TRUMP-EF    A98-ATLANTA CITY HACKED-AB         B2-BRIDGE COLLAPSE 911-NUSOT-EG    B98-$$TZ AHEAD-FACEBOOK-AB         C3-CHEERLEADER CHASES THIEF-TN    C5 TRENDING TOSS-BL    C6-CHRISSY TEIGEN-LAST NAME TWITTER SMACKDOWN-BL    C7-WILSD TURKEY BREAK-IN GOES VIRAL-MR    C12-HL: MCMASTER OUT-BOLTON IN-LT    C12-MSD DSTUDENTS FIGHT CLEAR BACKPACKS-TD    C13-MCDOUGAL TALKS ABOUT TRUMP-NUSOT-EF    C14-TOOBIN ON MCDOUGAL-EF    C15-SPENDING BILL-MALVBEAUX-EG    C98-sacramento protests-ef         D98-NEW NEXT HOUR: $10K TO GIVE UP SEAT-AB              E4-TOSS MONEY-AB    E5-ATLANTA CITY HACKED-AB    E98-TRUMP VS BIDEN FUNNIES-TD         F1-TRUMP VS BIDEN-MOOS-TD    F2-NEW MUSIC-CLARKSON/MUSGRAVES
KGO
A1 OPEN-no govt shutdown/clues inside bomber's home/cheerleader chases laptop thief-TN A3-SENAYTE PASSES SPENDING BILL-EG A4-TEASE AHEAD-LAWMAKER REAX-EG A6-WHO IS BOLTON-GERGEN SOT-LT A98-MCDOUGAL TALKS ABOUT TRUMP-EF A98-ATLANTA CITY HACKED-AB B2-BRIDGE COLLAPSE 911-NUSOT-EG B98-$$TZ AHEAD-FACEBOOK-AB C3-CHEERLEADER CHASES THIEF-TN C5 TRENDING TOSS-BL C6-CHRISSY TEIGEN-LAST NAME TWITTER SMACKDOWN-BL C7-WILSD TURKEY BREAK-IN GOES VIRAL-MR C12-HL: MCMASTER OUT-BOLTON IN-LT C12-MSD DSTUDENTS FIGHT CLEAR BACKPACKS-TD C13-MCDOUGAL TALKS ABOUT TRUMP-NUSOT-EF C14-TOOBIN ON MCDOUGAL-EF C15-SPENDING BILL-MALVBEAUX-EG C98-sacramento protests-ef D98-NEW NEXT HOUR: $10K TO GIVE UP SEAT-AB E4-TOSS MONEY-AB E5-ATLANTA CITY HACKED-AB E98-TRUMP VS BIDEN FUNNIES-TD F1-TRUMP VS BIDEN-MOOS-TD F2-NEW MUSIC-CLARKSON/MUSGRAVES
Now playing
00:59
See NBA dancer chase after laptop thief
ABC15 Arizona
Now playing
01:32
Video shows self-driving Uber hit pedestrian
Nottingham Trent University
Now playing
00:57
Racist chants caught on camera at university
Ministry of Interior of Egypt
Now playing
00:40
Policemen catch child falling from balcony
Hot air balloon crash Australia_00000000.jpg
Seven Network
Hot air balloon crash Australia_00000000.jpg
Now playing
00:45
Hot air balloon crash caught on camera
title:  duration: 00:00:00 site:  author:  published:  intervention: yes description:
Jukin Media
title: duration: 00:00:00 site: author: published: intervention: yes description:
Now playing
01:07
Camera captures kangaroo collide with cyclist
Turpin children
KCAL/KCBS and home video
Turpin children
Now playing
01:05
Surveillance shows Turpin siblings' escape
NS Slug: FL: STOPLIGHT SHOOTOUT IN PENSACOLA (CAUGHT ON CAM)  Synopsis: Video from a motorist's dash cam show two suspects exchanging gunfire at a stop light in Florida.  Keywords: FLORIDA STOPLIGHT SHOOTING DASH CAM VIDEO ESCAMBIA COUNTY
Escambia County Sheriff's Office
NS Slug: FL: STOPLIGHT SHOOTOUT IN PENSACOLA (CAUGHT ON CAM) Synopsis: Video from a motorist's dash cam show two suspects exchanging gunfire at a stop light in Florida. Keywords: FLORIDA STOPLIGHT SHOOTING DASH CAM VIDEO ESCAMBIA COUNTY
Now playing
00:39
Stoplight shootout caught on dashcam
houston jewlery heist caught on camera pkg_00004517.jpg
KTRK
houston jewlery heist caught on camera pkg_00004517.jpg
Now playing
01:24
Million-dollar jewel heist caught on camera
Sea lion drags girl into wharf orig vstan dlewis_00000000.jpg
Jukin
Sea lion drags girl into wharf orig vstan dlewis_00000000.jpg
Now playing
01:05
Sea lion drags girl into water
Storyful
Now playing
01:06
Road-rage incident caught on camera
title: You have to see this!! BUOY 10 BOAT CRASH  CONTEST TIME! DO ALL 3 AND WIN A ONYX SELF INFLATING LIFE JACKET.  2 WINNERS WILL BE SELECTED!  RULES 1.LIKE... duration: 00:00:00 site: Facebook author: null published: Wed Dec 31 1969 19:00:00 GMT-0500 (Eastern Daylight Time) intervention: no description: null
Salmon Trout Steelherder
title: You have to see this!! BUOY 10 BOAT CRASH CONTEST TIME! DO ALL 3 AND WIN A ONYX SELF INFLATING LIFE JACKET. 2 WINNERS WILL BE SELECTED! RULES 1.LIKE... duration: 00:00:00 site: Facebook author: null published: Wed Dec 31 1969 19:00:00 GMT-0500 (Eastern Daylight Time) intervention: no description: null
Now playing
01:13
See terrifying boat crash caught on video

Story highlights

Some cyclists are arming themselves with cameras to capture worst-case scenarios

Proponents of bike cameras say they're key to holding reckless drivers accountable

Some worry that cameras perpetuate the idea that cycling is inherently dangerous

(CNN) —  

Cyclist Alan Crocker regrets flipping off the driver of the blue pickup that buzzed past him on a recent Saturday morning in Rome, Georgia.

He’s not proud of it, and he’ll never do it again – especially now that he knows how unpredictable the response might be.

Crocker was wearing a helmet camera that recorded the driver getting out of his vehicle and knocking him over on his bike. He showed the footage to the Floyd County police officer who responded to his 911 call. According to a police report, the footage convinced the officer that the driver was “the aggressor,” refuting his claim that Crocker provoked him by kicking his car.

The driver, who did not return requests for comment, was arrested on charges of assault and battery and released on bail. He is awaiting a court date.

Meanwhile, Crocker wonders whether things would have turned out different if he wasn’t wearing his helmet camera that day.

“I was able to show the officer the video right there on the side of road,” he said. “It’s not every day that there’s clear evidence showing a cyclist was mistreated.”

Starting a movement

It’s National Bike to Work Week, but bike-friendly roads are still hard to come by in many states, according to rankings released Monday by the League of American Bicyclists. The uneasy relationship between drivers and cyclists can also keep would-be riders off the road.

It’s rare for drivers to respond to bicyclists with intentional acts of aggression. But with more bicycles and cars sharing the road, some cyclists are arming themselves with helmet or mounted cameras for the worst-case scenarios.

“Years of experience with law enforcement teaches most frequent and enthusiastic riders that you unfortunately can’t rely on police officers to know the traffic laws as they relate to bikes, or to believe a cyclist’s version of what happened,” said Andy Clarke, president of the League of American Bicyclists.

“There is a pervasive sense that cyclists shouldn’t be in the road or should be in the gutter and therefore are in the wrong or just sort of deserved what was coming to them, so video footage can be quite helpful.”

Bike enthusiasts tend to be early adopters of technology, especially if it helps them document (or show off) their rides, Clarke said. Chances are the most hardcore cyclists in your neighborhood have long been donning helmet cameras, GPS trackers or fitness monitors for their rides.

It’s rare for a cyclist to successfully use helmet camera footage against a motorist, but Crocker’s case is the latest example of a cyclist using a camera to document reckless driving. Much of the footage ends up on online, where a movement is growing to catalog repeat offenders, dangerous roads and intersections and make laws intended to protect cyclists more effective.

Crocker uploaded his video to Close Call Database, where cyclists log incidents involving vehicles. The database catalogs incidents by geography and sends out alerts to users in an area where an incident is reported.

Ernest Ezis launched Close Call Database in December after his own close encounter. He was on a group ride outside Boulder, Colorado, on a two-lane highway with a bike lane. A semi accelerated past them at about 60 mph, so close that the side mirror nearly clipped one of his friends and rattled the rest of them off their bikes.

“You have a few close calls that are really dangerous, but usually you forget about them and move on,” he said. “This particular time, I stayed angry, and I wanted to do something about it.”

The main goal of the site is to be a centralized database to catch repeat offenders and identify roads that are more dangerous than they might seem. Ezis has come to believe that incidents documented on camera are the best evidence to bring to law enforcement.

“I think you’ll be much less likely to pass me at 60 mph and only give me 6 inches of space if you realize that might be caught on camera.”

He realizes that most close calls are not malicious or intended to hurt cyclists. But ignorance of laws intended to protect cyclists, like safe passing distances, can be just as deadly.

“Drivers need to realize that when they make a mistake, it’s often fatal to the cyclist,” he said.

Helpful or harmful to bicyclists?

A small share of cyclists use cameras for the express purpose of documenting negligent driving. A YouTube search for “bicycle camera” and related terms yields more videos of Spandex-clad cyclists zipping down mountains than collisions between cars and bicycles.

It’s a touchy subject for the cycling community. On one hand, safety and advocacy groups worry that cameras perpetuate the idea that cycling is inherently dangerous or that cameras are prerequisites for bicycle safety.

In fact, sometimes the footage shows that the cyclist wasn’t as blameless as he or she thought, said lawyer Peter Wilborn, who specializes in laws relating to cyclists’ rights.

Wilborn said he has handled cases in which video helped clients and others in which it hurt them. Overall, the effect is more likely to be positive than negative, he said, but it’s not a panacea for easing tensions between cyclists and motorists.

“What’s important is infrastructure, and in places with infrastructure accidents go down, ridership goes up, and none of it has to do with special accessories,” he said.

But proponents of the cameras say they’re key to holding reckless drivers to account where legislation meant to protect cyclists falls short.

As cyclist Craig Davis pointed out, the first “3-foot law” creating a protective barrier around cyclists from cars was passed in Wisconsin in 1973. And yet, in his experience cycling for more than three decades, “no one pays attention to it.”

Davis started advocacy group 3FootCycling in 2014 to increase enforcement of safe passing laws. Like the Close Call Database, the group’s website lets users log close calls on the road involving vehicles.

The group also has partnered with law enforcement and bicycling groups to lead webinars and campaigns on enforcement of 3-foot laws for commercial drivers and law enforcement officers.

“Education doesn’t work. Wearing a T-shirt saying ‘three feet, please’ doesn’t work. So what can we do to change driver behavior?” he asked.

Davis sees bike cameras as “the only way” to change the tide, by providing law enforcement with “irrefutable evidence” in cases of one person’s word against another.

Crocker said that drivers in his community are “almost uniformly courteous” and that he has ridden tens of thousands of miles with his helmet camera without incident. But it was worth it to have evidence for the time he needed it, he said.

He hopes cyclists learn a lesson in etiquette, too.

“Flipping people off isn’t the best course,” he said. “You never know who’s in that car.”