WBND-LP
Now playing
02:20
Memories Pizza receives over $700K in donations
Ellen Page, star of the movie, "Juno" questions Ted Cruz on his LGBT views at the Iowa state fair is Des Moines. August 21, 2015
KCCI
Ellen Page, star of the movie, "Juno" questions Ted Cruz on his LGBT views at the Iowa state fair is Des Moines. August 21, 2015
Now playing
01:42
Actress Ellen Page debates Ted Cruz on LGBT rights
dnt baker refuses anti-gay order_00001124.jpg
WKMG
dnt baker refuses anti-gay order_00001124.jpg
Now playing
01:30
Baker refuses anti-gay order, gets 'nasty' gestures
ac pkg tuchman georgia florists religious freedom bill_00000527.jpg
ac pkg tuchman georgia florists religious freedom bill_00000527.jpg
Now playing
02:51
Why one Georgia florist won't serve gay couples
special sot georgia state senator mckoon religious freedom bill_00041014.jpg
special sot georgia state senator mckoon religious freedom bill_00041014.jpg
Now playing
04:40
Ga. state senator fights for religious right law
US President Barack Obama stands alongside Pope Francis during an arrival ceremony on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, September 23, 2015. More than 15,000 people packed the South Lawn for a full ceremonial welcome on Pope Francis' historic maiden visit to the United States. AFP PHOTO / MANDEL NGAN        (Photo credit should read MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images)
MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images
US President Barack Obama stands alongside Pope Francis during an arrival ceremony on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, September 23, 2015. More than 15,000 people packed the South Lawn for a full ceremonial welcome on Pope Francis' historic maiden visit to the United States. AFP PHOTO / MANDEL NGAN (Photo credit should read MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:43
Pope Francis speaks about religious liberty
donald trump iowa faith freedom bts nr_00004423.jpg
donald trump iowa faith freedom bts nr_00004423.jpg
Now playing
02:15
Donald Trump vows to fight for religious liberty
Republican presidential candidate and Texas senator Ted Cruz speaks during the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition annual banquet and presidential forum  Monday June 22, 2015 in Des Moines, Iowa.
(Taylor Glascock for CNN)
Taylor Glascock for CNN
Republican presidential candidate and Texas senator Ted Cruz speaks during the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition annual banquet and presidential forum Monday June 22, 2015 in Des Moines, Iowa. (Taylor Glascock for CNN)
Now playing
01:18
Ted Cruz discusses religious liberty
Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee speaks during the third day of the Republican National Convention at the Tampa Bay Times Forum on August 29, 2012 in Tampa, Florida.
Win McNamee/Getty Image
Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee speaks during the third day of the Republican National Convention at the Tampa Bay Times Forum on August 29, 2012 in Tampa, Florida.
Now playing
02:03
Huckabee: Left won't rest until 'no more churches'
pkg memories pizza religious freedom law_00004113.jpg
WBND-LP
pkg memories pizza religious freedom law_00004113.jpg
Now playing
02:16
Restaurant owner won't serve same-sex weddings
A still photo of the Georgia state capitol in Atlanta.
Rich Brooks/CNN/File
A still photo of the Georgia state capitol in Atlanta.
Now playing
02:50
Georgia Senate passes religious freedom bill
GETTY IMAGES/FILE
Now playing
07:07
NBA legend on Indiana law: They came after gay people
tsr tom cotton arkansas religious freedom act reaction_00004429.jpg
tsr tom cotton arkansas religious freedom act reaction_00004429.jpg
Now playing
02:00
Senator: Iran will hang you for ...
Former US Congressman Asa Hutchinson announces the findings and recommendations of the National School Shield Program at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, April 2, 2013. The NRA-backed National School Shield program on Tuesday unveiled recommendations to protect schools from instances of violence, including a model program to train and enable school personnel to carry firearms. Hutchinson was tasked by the National Rifle Association following the December shooting at an elementary school in Newtown, Connecticut to develop the recommendations to bolster school security. AFP PHOTO/Jim WATSON        (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images
Former US Congressman Asa Hutchinson announces the findings and recommendations of the National School Shield Program at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, April 2, 2013. The NRA-backed National School Shield program on Tuesday unveiled recommendations to protect schools from instances of violence, including a model program to train and enable school personnel to carry firearms. Hutchinson was tasked by the National Rifle Association following the December shooting at an elementary school in Newtown, Connecticut to develop the recommendations to bolster school security. AFP PHOTO/Jim WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
01:17
Did Indiana influence the Arkansas outcome?
ar gov hutchinson religious freedom bill _00000000.jpg
ar gov hutchinson religious freedom bill _00000000.jpg
Now playing
02:28
Arkansas governor: Bill needs changes before I sign it
WXIN
Now playing
03:24
How Indiana will 'fix' controversial law
ctn sot indiana religious freedom law_00001410.jpg
ctn sot indiana religious freedom law_00001410.jpg
Now playing
04:31
Penn Jillette: No one's forcing you to have gay sex
Now playing
06:33
Lawmaker defends controversial religious freedom bill
cnn tonight don lemon indiana law opening statement _00001412.jpg
cnn tonight don lemon indiana law opening statement _00001412.jpg
Now playing
01:05
Don Lemon speaks out against Indiana law
nr sot indiana religious freedom law constitutional toobin_00005230.jpg
nr sot indiana religious freedom law constitutional toobin_00005230.jpg
Now playing
01:07
Is Indiana's 'religious freedom' law constitutional?
cnn tonight lori windham sally kohn indiana law normalizing bigotry _00004316.jpg
cnn tonight lori windham sally kohn indiana law normalizing bigotry _00004316.jpg
Now playing
01:51
Kohn: Indiana Law is about 'normalizing bigotry'
erin live hester arkansas religious freedom bill_00003723.jpg
erin live hester arkansas religious freedom bill_00003723.jpg
Now playing
04:35
State senator: This law is about freedom of speech
bts legislators speak indiana religious freedom law_00003314.jpg
WTHR
bts legislators speak indiana religious freedom law_00003314.jpg
Now playing
01:22
Lawmaker: 'Not the intent of the law to discriminate'
Now playing
02:05
Furious backlash over controversial law
pkg religious freedom bill nuts and bolts_00003519.jpg
WXIN
pkg religious freedom bill nuts and bolts_00003519.jpg
Now playing
02:10
Bill allows businesses to reject gay customers

Story highlights

Indiana town's Memories Pizza is shut down after online threat

Its owners say they'd refuse to cater a same-sex couple's wedding

CNN —  

Standing up for what you believe. What does it cost you? What do you gain?

Memories Pizza in the Indiana town of Walkerton is finding out.

The family-run restaurant finds itself at the center of the debate over the state’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act after its owners said they’d refuse to cater a same-sex couple’s wedding.

“If a gay couple was to come and they wanted us to bring pizzas to their wedding, we’d have to say no,” Crystal O’Connor told CNN affiliate WBND-TV in South Bend.

The statement struck at the heart of fears by critics, who said the new law would allow businesses to discriminate against gays and lesbians. They called for boycotts.

But supporters also rallied. And by the end of the week, they had donated more than $842,000 for the business.

The cost

Social media unloaded on the pizzeria in the community of 2,100 people that few folks outside northern Indiana knew existed before this week.

RiskyLiberal tweeted: “Dear #MemoriesPizza. No. My boycotting your business because I don’t like your religious bigotry is not a violation of your freedom to practice your religion.”

“Don’t threaten #MemoriesPizza” tweeted Aღanda. “Just mock them for their ignorance.”

Bad reviews flooded the restaurant’s Facebook page, most having little to do with the quality of the food. Many too vulgar to share.

“Do you really want to financially support a company that treats some of your fellow citizens like second class citizens? BOYCOTT MEMORIES PIZZA!!” said Rob Katz of Indianapolis. “Let’s hope they either rethink their policy or the free market puts them out of business.”

Anti-bigotry critics harass wrong pizzeria

But one outburst in particular shut down the restaurant Wednesday and was expected to do the same Thursday.

“Who’s going to Walkerton with me to burn down Memories Pizza?” Jessica Dooley of Goshen tweeted, according to the Walkerton Police Department. The account has been deleted since the tweet was posted.

Detectives who investigated have recommended charges of harassment, intimidation and threats, according to Charles Kulp, assistant police chief.

The mood was a bit more subdued on the streets of Walkerton. A man stood outside Memories simply holding a sign that reads “bigots.”

Jason Narducy bought $100 of pizza from another shop down the street and started handing it out, WBND reported. “Do you want some non-discriminatory pizza?” Narducy asked.

The gain

But for every tweet and Facebook post taking Memories Pizza to task were words of support and a groundswell of financial support.