Obama attacks Netanyahu’s credibility ahead of speech
By Alexandra Jaffe, Jeremy Diamond and Eric Bradner, CNN
Updated
9:16 AM EST, Tue March 3, 2015
bts netanyahu israel speech aipac iran obama_00001906.jpg
Now playing
03:34
Netanyahu: U.S.-Israel alliance 'stronger than ever'
PHOTO:
Abid Katib/OREL COHEN/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
00:51
What's the Israeli-Palestinian two-state solution?
embassy move to jerusalem liebermann lklv_00000411.jpg
Now playing
01:26
Israeli ambassador endorses moving US embassy
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
04:09
W.H.: US would veto plan for Palestinian state
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
01:15
Kerry: US not driving force behind resolution
netanyahu kerrry
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
01:23
Netanyahu: Israel blamed for lack of peace
PHOTO:
GALI TIBBON/AFP/Win McNamee/Getty Images
Now playing
01:57
Israel cuts working ties with 12 nations
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
00:47
Kerry: One-state path won't give Israel peace
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
01:31
Kerry: US acted to save 2-state solution
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (R) and Daniel B. Shapiro (L) the US Ambassador to Israel listen to the US national anthem during the 14th annual International Conference on Counter-Terrorism in the coastal city of Herzliya, north of Tel Aviv, on September 11, 2014. Netanyahu showed his support for US President Barak Obamas call for united actions against ISIS, calling for "all civilized countries" to stand together in the fight against radical terrorism. AFP PHOTO / JACK GUEZ
(Photo credit should read JACK GUEZ/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO:
JACK GUEZ/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
00:46
Israel summons US ambassador over UN vote
International flags fly in front of the United Nations headquarters on September 24, 2015, before the start of the 70th General Assembly meeting.
PHOTO:
DOMINICK REUTER/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
01:35
Israel: US helped craft UN resolution
Now playing
02:11
US refuses to veto resolution on Israel
US President Barack Obama meets with President-elect Donald Trump on transition planning in the Oval Office at the White House on November 10, 2016 in Washington,DC. / AFP / JIM WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
PHOTO:
JIM WATSON/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
02:01
Trump contradicts Obama throughout transition
powers
PHOTO:
CNN
Now playing
00:59
US ambassador to UN: Israel treated differently
Trump Israel ambassador Labott pkg_00003611.jpg
PHOTO:
Getty Images
Now playing
02:14
Trump picks Friedman as ambassador to Israel
(CNN) —
The differences between President Barack Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu were on display Monday when the two offered dramatically divergent takes on a nuclear deal with Iran – even as Netanyahu struck a conciliatory tone during his visit to Washington.
Obama told Reuters that a deal with Iran to freeze its nuclear activity for at least 10 years, with verification measures, would be “far more effective in controlling their nuclear program than any military action we could take, any military action Israel could take and far more effective than sanctions will be.”
He also said Netanyahu has been wrong before – pointing to the 2013 interim deal with Iran.
“Netanyahu made all sorts of claims. This was going to be a terrible deal. This was going to result in Iran getting $50 billion worth of relief. Iran would not abide by the agreement. None of that has come true,” Obama said. “It has turned out that in fact, during this period we’ve seen Iran not advance its program. In many ways, it’s rolled back elements of its program.”
Netanyahu, meanwhile, reaffirmed that the U.S.-Israeli relationship remains strong and, despite controversy surrounding his Tuesday address to Congress, said the two nations “will weather this current disagreement.”
“Our friendship will weather the current disagreement as well, to grow even stronger in the future — because we share the same dreams…because the values that unite us are much stronger than the differences that divide us,” he said in his address to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee annual policy conference, drawing enthusiastic applause from the crowd.
Polling has shown Americans disapprove of House Speaker John Boehner’s move to invite Netanyahu to speak to Congress without notifying the White House. That, and the timing of the speech so close to the Israeli election, has critics accusing Boehner and Netanyahu of politicizing the issue of Iranian nuclear talks, and a growing number of Democrats are planning to boycott what they see as an attack on the president.
But in his address to AIPAC, the prime minister refuted those critics, insisting that his Tuesday speech is “not intended to inject Israel into the American partisan debate,” and reaffirming his support for Obama.
“My speech is not intended to show any disrespect to Obama or the esteemed office that he holds—I have great respect for both,” he said.
Netanyahu instead framed his Tuesday address as part of a “moral obligation” to sound the alarm on Iran, which he warned has “vowed to annihilate Israel, and if develops nuclear weapons, it can achieve that goal.”
“As prime minister of Israel, I have a moral obligation to speak up in the face of these threats while there is time to avert them,” he said.
While he’ll face a more skeptical audience on Tuesday, Netanyahu’s speech Monday was punctuated with enthusiastic applause and multiple standing ovations from an auditorium packed with thousands of pro-Israel activists, business leaders and others in town for the annual AIPAC policy conference.
Netanyahu is expected to use his Tuesday speech to lay out what he believes are the emerging contours of a deal with Iran and warn Congress against accepting a bad deal, and to push for tougher sanctions.
Closing out Monday’s AIPAC events, National Security Adviser Susan Rice took a direct jab at Netanyahu, declaring that “soundbites won’t stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon.”
And while she sought to diffuse some of the tension between the two nations with a speech peppered with Hebrew and recollections of her personal experiences with Israel, she offered a direct refutation to the goal of many in the room to deny Iran nuclear capabilities entirely.
She received her biggest applause of the night after mentioning the possibility of having Iran “forego its domestic enrichment capacity entirely,” but immediately shot the crowd down.
“But as desirable as that would be — it is neither realistic or achievable,” she said.
“The plain fact is no one can make Iran unlearn the scientific and nuclear expertise it already possesses,” Rice added, and cautioned that it wasn’t a “viable negotiating position” to attempt to block Iran from using its nuclear capacity for domestic energy reasons.
But she emphasized that the U.S.’ and Israel’s goals and security concerns are the same, and sought to reassure the pro-Israel crowd that the White House had Israel’s best interests in mind during the negotiations.
“We have Israel’s back come hell or high water,” she said.
Last week top White House officials warned the way it’s been handled has damaged ties between the two nations. Obama has declined to meet with Netanyahu during his visit, and will not be attending the speech.
Netanyahu acknowledged during his Monday address that disagreements between the U.S. and Israel are “only natural from time to time,” because there are “important differences” between the two nations.
He said that Israel exists in a far more dangerous region of the world, and while “America’s the strongest power in the world, Israel is strong, but it’s much more vulnerable.”
“We believe firmly that Israel’s security and the U.S.- Israel partnership transcends politics. It always will,” Power said. “This partnership should never be politicized and it cannot and will not be tarnished or broken.”
Power insisted that the “bond between the United States and Israel is still a national commitment,” and declared that relationship “should never be a partisan matter.”
“We cannot and we will not lose sight of that,” she said.
AIPAC activists will fan out across Capitol Hill on Tuesday to lobby legislators to support a bill slapping tougher sanctions on Iran and one subjecting any eventual deal to congressional approval.
Because of the increasingly tense atmosphere surrounding the speech, it risks backfiring on Netanyahu, and even some of his allies have expressed concerns that he may ultimately undermine his cause.
AIPAC CEO Howard Kohr acknowledged Sunday that “the way this speech has come about has created a great deal of upset among Democrats,” but said the situation hasn’t risen to the level of a crisis yet, and “frankly, it’s up to us to not let it become a crisis.
He said the speech would be “important,” and added that “we hope and urge members of Congress to be there to hear what he has to say.”
Congressional Republicans have broken with Obama, with Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, saying the United States should “not do this through appeasement.”
“The biggest problem we have on the face of the planet is Iran getting a nuclear weapon,” he said on CNN’s “The Situation Room.” “And we have to do anything and everything we can in our powers to make sure that won’t happen.”
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu chairs the weekly cabinet meeting at his office in Jerusalem on October 27.
PHOTO:
Gali Tibbon/AFP via Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, right, sits with a friend at the entrance to his family home in Jerusalem on July 1, 1967. The Israeli prime minister was born October 21, 1949.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Imges
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, right, with a friend in the Judean Desert on May 1, 1968.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu serves in the Sayeret Matkal, an elite commando unit of the Israeli army, in 1971. He spent five years in the unit.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu shakes hands with Israeli President Zalman Shazar during a November 1972 ceremony honoring the Sayeret Matkal soldiers who freed hostages in a hijacking earlier that year.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his first wife, Miriam, in June 1980.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his daughter, Noa, in June 1980.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu speaks in July 1986 with Sorin Hershko, one of the Israeli soldiers wounded in Operation Entebbe. It was the 10th anniversary of Operation Entebbe, a dramatic rescue of Jewish hostages at Uganda's Entebbe Airport. Netanyahu's brother, Yonatan, was killed leading Operation Entebbe in 1976. Affected by his brother's death, Netanyahu organized two international conferences on ways to combat terrorism, one in 1979 and another in 1984.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
From 1984 to 1988, Netanyahu was Israel's ambassador to the United Nations.
PHOTO:
DON EMMERT/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu talks to Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir on a stroll in New York's Central Park in November 1987.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, as Israel's deputy foreign minister, goes through some papers as Government Secretary Elyakim Rubinstein recites morning prayers on a flight from New York to Washington in April 1989.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Shamir speaks with Netanyahu at a Middle East peace conference in Madrid in October 1991.
PHOTO:
PATRICK BAZ/AFP/GettyImages
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu celebrates after being elected chairman of the right-wing Likud party on March 21, 1993.
PHOTO:
Esaias BAITEL/Gamma-Rapho/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and former foreign minister David Levy sit in the Knesset during the vote for a new Israeli President on March 24, 1993.
PHOTO:
MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu meets with King Hussein of Jordan, center, and Crown Prince Hassan in December 1994. It was Netanyahu's first visit to Jordan.
PHOTO:
Stringer/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu shakes hands with outgoing Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres before taking the office himself in June 1996.
PHOTO:
David Rubinger/The LIFE Images Collection/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu meets with Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat for the first time on September 4, 1996, at an Israeli army base at the Erez Checkpoint in Gaza.
PHOTO:
Moshe Milner/Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu meets with US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright in Washington in February 1997.
PHOTO:
L. MARK/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu spends the day on the beach with his wife, Sara, and son Avner in Caesarea, Israel, on August 16, 1997.
PHOTO:
SHAUL GOLAN/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Actor Kirk Douglas holds the King David Award, presented to him by the Jerusalem Fund of Aish HaTorah during a dinner in Beverly Hills, California, on November 17, 1997. Douglas was honored for his inspirational commitment to Israel and the Jewish people and in recognition of his new book "Climbing the Mountain." Netanyahu is on the left. To the right is Rabbi Nachum Braverman, director of the Jerusalem Fund of Aish HaTorah.
PHOTO:
PETER HALMAGY/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu looks through binoculars during a tour of the West Bank with the Israeli Cabinet on December 28, 1997.
PHOTO:
Israeli Government Press Office/Getty Imges
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan meet in Annan's office in New York on May 15, 1998.
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
From left, Arafat, King Hussein, US President Bill Clinton and Netanyahu sign an interim Middle East peace agreement in October 1998.
PHOTO:
JOYCE NALTCHAYAN/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu thanks a crowd of supporters in Tel Aviv, Israel, at a Likud party meeting in May 1999. The outgoing Prime Minister announced that he was quitting the Knesset and stepping down as party leader 10 days after being defeated in elections.
PHOTO:
Uzi Keren/Getty Images/
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu testifies before the US House Government Reform Committee on September 20, 2001. The committee was conducting hearings on terrorism following the September 11 attacks.
PHOTO:
LESLIE E. KOSSOFF/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, as Israel's foreign minister, laughs with Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon at the start of a Likud convention in Tel Aviv on November 12, 2002.
PHOTO:
SVEN NACKSTRAND/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his wife, Sara, are seen at a polling station in Jerusalem on August 14, 2007. He was re-elected as head of the Likud party.
PHOTO:
GALI TIBBON/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu shakes hands with Israeli President Shimon Peres in February 2009 after Netanyahu won backing from the Israeli parliament to become Prime Minister again. A close election between Netanyahu and rival Tzipi Livni had left the results unclear until the parliament's decision.
PHOTO:
Ahikam Seri/Bloomberg News/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
From left, Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, Netanyahu, US President Barack Obama, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Jordan's King Abdullah II walk to the East Room of the White House to make statements on the Middle East peace process on September 1, 2010.
PHOTO:
TIM SLOAN/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Obama meets with Netanyahu at the White House in September 2010.
PHOTO:
TIM SLOAN/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton looks on as Abbas and Netanyahu shake hands in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt, on September 14, 2010, during a second round of Middle East peace talks.
PHOTO:
MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
British Prime Minister David Cameron welcomes Netanyahu to 10 Downing Street in London on May 4, 2011.
PHOTO:
BEN STANSALL/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu address a joint session of the US Congress on May 24, 2011. He said that he was prepared to make "painful compromises" for a peace settlement with the Palestinians, but he repeated that Israel will not accept a return to its pre-1967 boundaries.
PHOTO:
MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu uses a diagram of a bomb to describe Iran's nuclear program while delivering an address to the UN General Assembly on September 27, 2012. Netanyahu exhorted the General Assembly to draw "a clear red line" to stop Iran from developing nuclear weapons.
PHOTO:
DON EMMERT/AFP/GettyImages
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and Avigdor Lieberman of the Likud-Beiteinu coalition party greet supporters as they arrive onstage on election night in January 2013. The Likud-Beiteinu won 31 seats in the Knesset.
PHOTO:
JACK GUEZ/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu speaks at the UN General Assembly on October 1, 2013. He accused Iranian President Hassan Rouhani of seeking to obtain a nuclear weapon and described him as "a wolf in sheep's clothing, a wolf who thinks he can pull the wool over the eyes of the international community."
PHOTO:
Andrew Burton/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
In December 2014, Netanyahu called for early elections as he fired two key ministers for opposing government policy.
PHOTO:
GALI TIBBON/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu is greeted by members of US Congress as he arrives to speak in the House chamber in March 2015. He warned that a proposed agreement between world powers and Iran was "a bad deal" that would not stop Tehran from getting nuclear weapons — but would rather pave its way to getting lots of them and leave the Jewish State in grave peril.
PHOTO:
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his family take a vacation in southern Israel in April 2015.
PHOTO:
Amos Ben Gershom/GPO via Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and German Chancellor Angela Merkel talk in Berlin in October 2015.
PHOTO:
Handout/Guido Bergmann/Bundesregierung via Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu speaks to the press in Tel Aviv, Israel, in June 2016. A day earlier, two attackers identified as Palestinians opened fire at a popular food and shopping complex near the Israeli Defense Ministry in Tel Aviv, killing four Israelis and sending other patrons scrambling to safety.
PHOTO:
Lior Mizrahi/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu stands next to US President Barack Obama as they attend the funeral of former Israeli President Shimon Peres in September 2016.
PHOTO:
Abir Sultan/Pool/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu visits Moriah College in Sydney in February 2017. It was the first time an Israeli prime minister had visited Australia.
PHOTO:
Dean Lewins/Pool/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu speaks to US President Donald Trump in May 2017. Trump visited Israel and the West Bank during his first foreign trip as President.
PHOTO:
Kobi Gideon/GPO via Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his wife, Sara, pose for a photo at the Taj Mahal in Agra, India, in January 2018.
PHOTO:
STR/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, speaking at a security conference in Germany in February 2018, holds up what he claimed is a piece of an Iranian drone that was shot down after it flew over Israeli territory.
PHOTO:
Lennart Preiss/MSC 2018 via Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu, giving a speech at the Ministry of Defense in April 2018, accused Iran of "brazenly lying" over its nuclear ambitions. He said Israel had uncovered files that prove his allegation and that the Islamic republic is keeping an "atomic archive" at a secret compound. Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi called Netanyahu's comments "childish" and "laughable."
PHOTO:
AMIR COHEN/REUTERS/Newscom
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
From left, Netanyahu sits beside senior White House adviser Jared Kushner; President Trump's daughter, Ivanka; Israeli President Reuven Rivlin; and US Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin during the opening of the new US Embassy in Jerusalem in May 2018.
PHOTO:
MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and his wife, Sara, pose for a photo with Russian President Vladimir Putin after talks in Moscow in February 2019.
PHOTO:
Alexei Druzhinin/AP
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
The Netanyahus cast their votes during Israel's parliamentary elections in April 2019. The election was seen as a referendum on Netanyahu's long tenure as prime minister.
PHOTO:
Ariel Schalit/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu greets supporters in April 2019.
PHOTO:
Amir Levy/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
An election banner on a Jerusalem building shows Netanyahu shaking hands with US President Donald Trump. Trump remains incredibly popular in Israel — far more popular than he is in the United States.
PHOTO:
Ahmad Gharabli/AFP/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu meets with British Prime Minister Boris Johnson in London in September 2019.
PHOTO:
Alastair Grant/WPA Pool/Getty Images
Photos: Netanyahu's life in pictures
Netanyahu and Israeli Blue and White party chief Benny Gantz reach to shake hands during a state memorial ceremony for former Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and his wife Leah in Jerusalem on November 10. Exit polls for a repeat general election in September failed to give either of the political rivals a majority in the new parliament.