Obama and Netanyahu: A clash of world views, not just personalities
Ad Feedback
Video Ad Feedback
US- Israel Relations
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
U.S. President Barack Obama (R) shakes hands with Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office, September 30, 2013 in Washington, DC
Now playing
02:48
Have U.S.-Israel relations ever been this bad? Yes.
Abid Katib/OREL COHEN/AFP/Getty Images
Now playing
00:51
What's the Israeli-Palestinian two-state solution?
embassy move to jerusalem liebermann lklv_00000411.jpg
Now playing
01:26
Israeli ambassador endorses moving US embassy
Kerry Netanyahu Un resolution origwx cs_00002709.jpg
Now playing
02:23
Back to back speeches from the U.S. & Israel
CNN
Now playing
04:09
W.H.: US would veto plan for Palestinian state
CNN
Now playing
01:15
Kerry: US not driving force behind resolution
CNN
netanyahu kerrry
Now playing
01:23
Netanyahu: Israel blamed for lack of peace
GALI TIBBON/AFP/Win McNamee/Getty Images
Now playing
01:57
Israel cuts working ties with 12 nations
CNN
Now playing
00:47
Kerry: One-state path won't give Israel peace
CNN
Now playing
01:31
Kerry: US acted to save 2-state solution
JACK GUEZ/AFP/Getty Images
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (R) and Daniel B. Shapiro (L) the US Ambassador to Israel listen to the US national anthem during the 14th annual International Conference on Counter-Terrorism in the coastal city of Herzliya, north of Tel Aviv, on September 11, 2014. Netanyahu showed his support for US President Barak Obamas call for united actions against ISIS, calling for "all civilized countries" to stand together in the fight against radical terrorism. AFP PHOTO / JACK GUEZ
(Photo credit should read JACK GUEZ/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
00:46
Israel summons US ambassador over UN vote
DOMINICK REUTER/AFP/Getty Images
International flags fly in front of the United Nations headquarters on September 24, 2015, before the start of the 70th General Assembly meeting.
Now playing
01:35
Israel: US helped craft UN resolution
Now playing
02:11
US refuses to veto resolution on Israel
JIM WATSON/AFP/AFP/Getty Images
US President Barack Obama meets with President-elect Donald Trump on transition planning in the Oval Office at the White House on November 10, 2016 in Washington,DC. / AFP / JIM WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
Now playing
02:01
Trump contradicts Obama throughout transition
CNN
powers
Now playing
00:59
US ambassador to UN: Israel treated differently
Getty Images
Trump Israel ambassador Labott pkg_00003611.jpg
Now playing
02:14
Trump picks Friedman as ambassador to Israel
WashingtonCNN
—
The disconnect between President Barack Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is about a lot more than bad personal chemistry.
Their relationship, which will be played out in all its dysfunctional glory during Netanyahu’s visit to Washington this week, founders on a deep ideological divide and a sharply conflicting world view.
A long, steadily worsening showdown between the rivals is coming to a head in the tense final stages of talks between world powers and Iran in pursuit of a nuclear deal backed by the U.S. but opposed by Netanyahu.
Netanyahu’s visit is highly unusual. Not only will he not meet with Obama, but he is taking the most prominent stage outside the White House available to a foreign leader in Washington and directly campaigning against one of the president’s top second-term priorities – a nuclear deal with Iran. Netanyahu appears to have concluded that the proposed agreement is so bad that, in a highly unorthodox move, he will actively join Obama’s political adversaries in an effort to derail the president’s Iran deal-making.
Highly unusual
The Israeli leader will make the case against the proposed deal in an address to Congress on Tuesday, against the wishes of the White House, at the invitation of GOP House Speaker John Boehner.
The speech, likely to delight Republicans, who are also trying to thwart Obama’s Iran diplomacy, will be the starkest illustration yet of the estrangement between Netanyahu and Obama.
“Each one is convinced that the other one doesn’t get the other side’s core interests,” said David Makovsky, a former advisor on Secretary of State John Kerry’s Middle East team.
“Beyond all the grievances and the slights, that is the fundamental issue.”
Both Obama and Netanyahu see themselves as historic figures, elected at fateful moments in the lives of their nations.
Obama sees his mission as ending foreign land wars, putting the campaign against terrorism on a sustainable footing and honoring John F. Kennedy’s dictum that the United States should “never fear to negotiate” with its enemies.
Netanyahu believes he is “entrusted with the awesome responsibility of ensuring the future of the Jewish people and the future of the Jewish state” against an existential threat from Iran’s nuclear program.
In his more optimistic outlook, Obama, the first African-American president, puts his faith in the power of aspirational political movements and grass roots organizing. He ran for office arguing that recent approaches to foreign policy had not worked — hence his willingness to engage U.S. enemies.
But Netanyahu has a more hardened view of the world, forged by decades in Israel’s treacherous neighborhood, the threats Jews have faced throughout their history and his close ties with foreign policy hawks who believe that military strength and vigilance are the best ways to ensure security and peace.
“I do think that it is important to understand this is more than simply a little personality clash,” said Jeremy Ben-Ami, president of J Street, a liberal pro-Israel advocacy group in Washington.
“It really is a fundamental disagreement over policy and it reflects the underlying world views that are held not just by the two men but by the two camps in each country,” Ben-Ami said.
Obama and Netanyahu have never been friends. And now their personal antipathy is beginning to infect national political ties, which are as bad as they have been for decades.
Obama and Netanyahu did not set out to have a bad relationship, and there are plenty of instances where world leaders who did not like each other still worked well together. But this feud has certainly made it easier for both sides to question the other’s motives and to see deliberate slights even when none are intended.
Their differing personality traits almost guaranteed a collision. Obama has an author’s temperament. He doesn’t enjoy politics and seeks to avoid public confrontations. Netanyahu is blunt, a skilled wheeler-and-dealer and a bruiser in the tradition of Israel’s in-your-face politics. And one trait they share, a deep confidence in their own convictions, only increases their head-butting.
“I sometimes wonder if we have a situation where we have someone who is a law professor and is very cerebral and has this universal sense of how things are supposed to unfold under international law,” Makovsky said, referring to Obama.
“On the other side, you have someone who is convinced he lives in a region called the Middle East and believes that a lot of the categories that they teach in law school are not always applicable in this neighborhood.”
Their disconnect has played out in testy photo ops, and even in an over-the-top stroll, with jackets slung over their shoulders, on the baking runway of Ben Gurion airport outside Tel Aviv in 2010, in an apparent bid to scotch reports that the leaders were at odds.
But events soon belied the encounter. Obama was caught in 2011 on an open mic complaining to then-French President Nicolas Sarkozy about Netanyahu after Sarkozy branded the Israeli leader a “liar.” Last year, an anonymous quote attributed to a senior White House official calling Netanyahu a “chicken sh**t” caused a storm.
Administration officials, meanwhile, were furious over what they saw as several patronizing lectures on Jewish history and the threat from Iran that Netanyahu delivered before the cameras to Obama in the Oval Office.
And Netanyahu’s speech to Congress, just before the Israeli election on March 17, is seen by critics in the administration and elsewhere as at least in part another attempt to play politics, following what the White House perceived as his open backing of Mitt Romney during Obama’s re-election campaign in 2012.
The administration also largely blames Netanyahu for blowing up its two thwarted efforts to make peace between Israel and the Palestinians. They see him as having appeased right-wing elements in his fragmented coalition by endorsing settlement building on lands Palestinians envision as part of their future state at the expense of talks between the two sides.
Iran
But the most consequential dispute between Obama and Netanyahu is on Iran.
Both men have placed the Islamic Republic at the center of their political projects and understand that they can only achieve the legacy they seek by outmaneuvering the other.
“I don’t want to be coy. The prime minister and I have a very real difference around Iran,” Obama said earlier this month.
Netanyahu weighed in on Saturday before leaving for the United States. “I respect U.S. President Barack Obama,” he said, but warned that he had an obligation to make clear his fears about Tehran’s nuclear program.
Obama has tried to coax Iran out of decades of hostility towards the United States, which it sees as the “great Satan,” and has made historic gestures by speaking to President Hassan Rouhani on the phone and carrying out a correspondence with Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
But Netanyahu has repeatedly warned that Rouhani is a “wolf in sheep’s clothing” and sought to bring attention to what Israel considers deceptions by Tehran over its nuclear program and violations of international restrictions on its activities.
Details of a proposed nuclear deal with Iran ahead of a deadline for a framework agreement next month have widened the divides.
Moshe Arens, a former Israeli defense minister, said that while Netanyahu is convinced that the proposed deal is dangerous, Obama doesn’t agree: “He thinks it is the best he can get at the moment. My impression is that he doesn’t want to get into a confrontation with Iran at the moment.”
The U.S. president has long warned that the kind of “perfect” deal that Netanyahu envisages – which would completely strip Tehran of centrifuges and nuclear infrastructure – is not realistic.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Sean Gallup/Getty Images
U.S. President Barack Obama attends the Nuclear Security Summit in the Hague, Netherlands, in March 2014. As Obama's second term nears its close, here's a look at some key moments of his administration.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/Chicago Tribune/MCT/Getty Images
First lady Michelle Obama brushes specks from the coat of then-Sen. Obama in Springfield, Illinois, just before he announced his candidacy for President in February 2007. Their daughters Malia, left, and Sasha wait in the foreground.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Eric Thayer/Getty Images for Meet the Press
Obama appears on "Meet the Press" with Tim Russert, right, in Des Moines, Iowa, in November 2007.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Obama shakes hands with supporters after addressing a rally in Concord, New Hampshire, in January 2008.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP/Getty Images
Obama gives a speech at the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia in March 2008.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty Images
Obama speaks at the 2008 Democratic National Convention in Denver.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Obama stands on stage in Chicago with his family after winning the presidential election on November 4, 2008.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
Obama poses in the Oval Office with several former U.S. Presidents in January 2009. From left are George H. W. Bush, Obama, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Obama is sworn in by Chief Justice John Roberts as the 44th President of the United States on January 20, 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
As retired military officers stand behind him, Obama signs an executive order to close down the detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in January 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images
Obama and Vice President Joe Biden look at solar panels as they tour the solar array at the Denver Museum of Nature and Science on February 17, 2009. That same day, Obama signed the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images
A soldier hugs Obama during his surprise visit to Camp Victory just outside Baghdad, Iraq, in April 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/White House
Obama bends over so the son of a White House staff member can pat his head during a visit to the Oval Office in May 2009. The boy wanted to know if Obama's hair felt like his.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Joshua Roberts/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Obama kisses Sonia Sotomayor's cheek after announcing her as his nominee for Supreme Court justice in May 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAIF DAHLAH/AFP/Getty Images
Palestinian security forces in Jenin, West Bank, listen to Obama speak from Cairo University in Egypt in June 2009. The Palestinian Authority hailed as a "good beginning" Obama's speech to the Muslim world in which he reiterated his support for a Palestinian state.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/The White House via Getty Images
Obama and the first lady meet with Pope Benedict XVI in Vatican City in July 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Obama hosts the Apollo 11 astronauts -- from left, Edwin "Buzz" Aldrin, Michael Collins and Neil Armstrong -- in the Oval Office on July 20, 2009. It was the 40th anniversary of the moon landing.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
Police Sgt. James Crowley, second right, of Cambridge, Massachusetts, speaks with Harvard Professor Henry Louis Gates Jr., second left, alongside Obama and Biden as they share beers on the South Lawn of the White House in July 2009. The so-called Beer Summit was held after Crowley arrested Gates at his own home, which sparked tensions and racial furor.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
Obama salutes during the transfer of Sgt. Dale R. Griffin at Dover Air Force Base in Dover, Delaware, in October 2009. Obama traveled to the base to meet the plane carrying the bodies of 18 U.S. personnel killed in Afghanistan.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
Obama walks along the Great Wall of China in November 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images
Obama delivers a speech after receiving the Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo, Norway, in December 2009.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
Obama and former Presidents Clinton and George W. Bush walk to the White House Rose Garden to speak about relief efforts for earthquake-stricken Haiti in January 2010.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/White House
First daughters Sasha and Malia Obama play in the snow with their father after a snowstorm hit Washington in February 2010.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Chuck Kennedy/White House
Obama's signature on the Affordable Care Act is seen at the White House in March 2010.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
G Fiume/Getty Images
Obama throws out the opening pitch before a baseball game between the Philadelphia Phillies and the Washington Nationals in April 2010.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/The White House via Getty Images
Obama and his daughter Sasha swim in Panama City Beach, Florida, in August 2010, to encourage people to come back to the Gulf Coast after a devastating oil spill.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images
Obama laughs as he makes a statement on his birth certificate in April 2011. Obama said he was amused over conspiracy theories about his birthplace, and he said the media's obsession with the "sideshow" issue was a distraction in a "serious time."
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/The White House via Getty Images
Obama, Biden, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and members of the national security team receive live updates on the mission to capture or kill Osama bin Laden on May 1, 2011.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images
U.S. Marines watch from Afghanistan as Obama announces the death of bin Laden on May 2, 2011.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Irish Government/Pool/Getty Images
Obama enjoys a pint of Guinness in his ancestral home of Moneygall, Ireland, in May 2011.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Charles Dharapak/WPA Pool/Getty Images
Obama and the first lady meet with Britain's Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, at Buckingham Palace in May 2011.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Obama and Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon walk together in May 2011 during a tour of the tornado devastation in Joplin, Missouri.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images
Obama delivers remarks to troops and military families at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, on December 14, 2011, marking the exit of U.S. soldiers from Iraq.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Kevin Dietsch/Pool/Getty Images
Obama pays for a dog toy as he shops with his dog Bo at a PetSmart in Alexandria, Virginia, in December 2011.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/White House Photo via Getty Images
Obama sits on the famed Rosa Parks bus at the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn, Michigan, in April 2012.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/The White House via Getty Images
British Prime Minister David Cameron, Obama, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and others watch the overtime shootout of the Champions League final between Chelsea and Bayern Munich in a conference room at Camp David, Maryland, during a G-8 Summit in May 2012.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Pete Souza/White House
Obama sits in his chair during a Cabinet meeting in July 2012. This image was tweeted by his official Twitter account in August 2012 in response to Clint Eastwood's "empty chair" speech at the Republican National Convention. The tweet simply said, "This seat's taken."
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Win McNamee/Getty Images
Obama casts a shadow in this picture as he accepts the 2012 Democratic nomination for President during the final day of the Democratic National Convention in September 2012.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty images
Obama and Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney participate in the first presidential debate of the 2012 election.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images
Obama celebrates on stage in Chicago after defeating Romney on Election Day in 2012.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images
Obama pauses during his speech at a memorial service for the victims of the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre in December 2012.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Charles Ommanney/Reportage by Getty Images
Hundreds of thousands gather at the U.S. Capitol building as Obama is inaugurated for his second term on January 21, 2013.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images
Israeli President Shimon Peres, left, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, right, stand with Obama after Obama arrived in Tel Aviv, Israel, in March 2013.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Charles Dharapak/AP
Obama adjusts an umbrella held by a Marine during a White House news conference with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan in May 2013.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Paul Drinkwater/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images
Jay Leno interviews Obama on "The Tonight Show" in August 2013.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
White House press secretary Jay Carney fields questions from reporters during a daily press briefing at the White House in September 2013. Obama had just pushed for congressional approval for limited military strikes against the Syrian government.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Funny Or Die/AP
Actor and comedian Zach Galifianakis interviews Obama during his appearance on "Between Two Ferns," a digital video series with a laser focus on reaching people aged 18 to 34. The President urged young people to sign up for his new health care plan in the video posted on the website Funny or Die.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
Obama walks to the Oval Office on August 7, 2014, the same day he announced the beginning of airstrikes on ISIS.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Doug Mills/Pool/Getty Images
Obama speaks to the nation about normalizing diplomatic relations with Cuba in December 2014.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Alex Wong/Getty Images
From left, House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi and House Speaker John Boehner listen as Obama speaks during a meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House on January 13, 2015.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
Obama responds to a heckler who interrupted his speech during a White House reception for LGBT Pride Month in June 2015.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images
Obama cries in January 2016 as he delivers a statement on his executive action to reduce gun violence.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/Getty Images
Cuban President Raul Castro tries to lift up Obama's arm at the end of a joint news conference in Havana, Cuba, in March 2016. Castro hailed Obama's opposition to a long-standing economic "blockade," but said it would need to end before ties between the two countries are fully normalized.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
Kensington Palace/PA Wire via Getty Images
Obama visits Prince William, Duchess Catherine and their son, Prince George, during a trip to London in April 2016.
Photos: Barack Obama's presidency
David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Obama hugs Hillary Clinton after speaking at the Democratic National Convention in July 2016. Obama told the crowd at Philadelphia's Wells Fargo Center that Clinton is ready to be commander in chief. "For four years, I had a front-row seat to her intelligence, her judgment and her discipline," he said, referring to Clinton's stint as secretary of state.
The administration argues that the deal being negotiated would keep Iran in a box, freeze the “breakout” period at which it could race to a bomb at around one year and include monitoring and inspections that would thwart any covert bid by Tehran to make a nuclear weapon.
Administration officials have also argued that diplomacy is preferable to a military strike on Iran’s nuclear infrastructure, reasoning that such an approach would only set back its ambitions for several years while jeopardizing the willingness of the international coalition to maintain sanctions key to keeping Iran in check.
Netanyahu, however, considers the deal taking shape in the talks a “bad” one and says the idea of lifting sanctions that have Iran “on the ropes” is nonsensical. He has also pointed to Iran’s duplicity – concealing entire nuclear sites, for instance – as reason to doubt that Iran could be effectively monitored and that the breakout period could be limited if Tehran maintains facilities for nuclear production.
Obama has repeatedly said that he will never allow Iran to get a nuclear bomb and threaten the Jewish state. But Netanyahu’s trip to Washington appears to indicate that the prime minister doesn’t trust that assurance.
U.S. power
In a wider sense, Obama and Netanyahu are also at opposite ends of a debate on the use of U.S. power that emerged as a fault line in American politics after the September 11 attacks in 2001.
Netanyahu’s Likud Party is a much better fit with neoconservatives and Republican hawks who prospered in the early years of George W. Bush’s presidency than with Obama’s doctrine of “strategic patience” when deploying U.S. power abroad.
“I think Bibi has always been close to the American right, it is partly where he got his political education,” said Daniel Levy, who worked as an advisor to former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak, referring to Netanyahu by his nickname.
And from the start, it was clear that the two figures’ political ideologies were not in line.
During the 2008 campaign, Obama told a Jewish group that “there is a strain within the pro-Israel community that says unless you adopt an unwavering pro-Likud approach to Israel, then you’re anti-Israel.”
That, he told them, “can’t be the measure of our friendship with Israel.”
