NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell looks on prior to the start of the first round of the 2014 NFL Draft at Radio City Music Hall on May 8, 2014 in New York City
Should Goodell stay or go?
05:25 - Source: CNN

Story highlights

NJ law prohibits release of certain evidence during legal matters, NFL boss says

Goodell sends memo to all 32 teams explaining why league hadn't seen video until Monday

TMZ Sports posted a video online showing Ray Rice punching his future wife

Critics said the NFL should also have been able to get the video and an earlier one

CNN  — 

The NFL has a simple answer for critics who claim the league should have been able to get videos of Ray Rice knocking out his future wife and dragging her out of an elevator.

It would have been illegal, Commissioner Roger Goodell wrote in a memo Wednesday to the top officials of the NFL’s 32 teams.

“Once a criminal investigation begins, law enforcement authorities do not share investigatory material (such as the videos here) with private parties such as the NFL,” he wrote in a note to chief executives and club presidents. “In addition, (New Jersey’s) Open Public Records Act excludes material that is generated in the context of an active law enforcement proceeding.”

The Associated Press, however, reported Wednesday that a law enforcement official said he sent a copy of the video in April to an NFL executive and someone called him from an NFL office phone to thank him for sending the video.

The NFL reacted to the story by saying the league is unaware of anyone in its office having the video in their possession and officials would look into the report.

NFL toughens domestic violence policy with six-game bans

Rice has been suspended indefinitely from the NFL and was cut by the Baltimore Ravens after a video surfaced this week showing him punching Janay Rice, who at the time was his fiancee, in an elevator in Atlantic City on February 15.

Rice was eventually charged with third-degree assault by Atlantic County prosecutors, but as a first-time offender was able to enter into a diversionary program. If he successfully completes the program in one year, the charge will be removed from his record.

Timeline of events in the Ray Rice story

Critics have said the NFL should have been able to get the videos and should have banned Rice for life instead of initially giving him a two-game suspension. The ban was increased after the in-elevator video was posted online by TMZ Sports on Monday.

It was the second dramatic video in the case. The first showed the aftermath of the ferocious blow. In it Rice drags his unconscious fiancee off the elevator and talks to a security staffer.

Goodell doesn’t rule out a return for Rice

Goodell also said the hotel couldn’t legally provide the video to the NFL because of the investigation into the incident.

“We did not ask the Atlantic City casino directly for the video,” he wrote. “Again, our understanding of New Jersey law is that the casino is prohibited from turning over material to a third party during a law enforcement proceeding, and that doing so would have subjected individuals to prosecution for interference with a criminal investigation.”

Goodell said the Rice legal proceedings are still an “open matter.”

NFL’s past penalties for domestic violence ‘a different story’

TMZ executive producer Harvey Levin told CNN’s “The Lead with Jake Tapper” on Tuesday that they paid for the videos.

“I think what happened was the casino closed. And when the casino closed, I think there were a lot of employees who just said, you know what: ‘We want to do the right thing.’ And ultimately we ended up getting this video because when you look at the video, clearly you see the NFL did not do the right thing,” Levin said of the second video. “And I think at a point somebody said that the gain here is worse than the risk, in terms of doing what’s right.”

The Revel casino closed eight days ago.

The Baltimore Sun petitioned for the release of the elevator video under the Freedom of Information Act, but its request was denied by New Jersey officials.

What if Goodell ran the NBA and Silver captained the NFL?