01:59 - Source: CNN
Teen claims she's killed dozens

Story highlights

NEW: Experts question serial-killing claims

NEW: Without details, "We don't even know where to start," searcher says

Miranda Barbour told reporter that she had killed more than 22 people across four states

Barbour and her husband are charged in a November 2013 killing

CNN —  

Reporter Francis Scarcella walked into the Northumberland County Prison in Sunbury, Pennsylvania, with plenty of questions for the woman accused along with her husband of luring a man with a Craigslist ad, then killing him.

He walked out with a bombshell of a story that’s sent police and the press alike scrambling for answers.

Miranda Barbour told Scarcella, a reporter for the Daily Item newspaper in Sunbury, that she’d killed before. And not just once or twice.

“She said, she has, you know, done this before,” Scarcella told CNN affiliate WNEP of his Friday interview with the 19-year-old murder suspect. “And I said, ‘What’s the actual number?’”

“And she said, ‘Under a hundred,’” Scarcella told the station. Barbour said she had stopped counting at 22 killings, according to Scarcella’s story in the Daily Item.

“She kind of floored me,” Scarcella told CNN affiliate WBRE.

Barbour told the Daily Item that the killings occurred over the past six years in Alaska, Texas, North Carolina and California. That’s sent investigators in those states back to their cold-case files, but it’s also raising questions among people who study serial killers.

“Anything is possible, and of course it’s conceivable that she’s a serial killer,” Northeastern University criminologist Jack Levin told CNN. But he said few women are serial killers, and those few are typically older and don’t use knives, as Barbour is accused of doing in the Pennsylvania case.

Authorities haven’t yet corroborated any of Barbour’s claims, including statements that she was involved in Satanism. Her alleged confession has raised questions among attorneys, missing persons experts and even a representative of the Church of Satan, the nation’s largest satanic body.

“Thorough investigation will likely demonstrate that this cult story is fiction,” said Peter Gilmore, the New York-based head of the Church of Satan.

In Alaska, state police are looking into the claims and will pursue “any leads that may present themselves,” Department of Public Safety spokeswoman Megan Peters told CNN. And Monica Caison, the founder of a missing persons center in North Carolina, said her phone started ringing Sunday night with questions from families whose loved ones haven’t turned up in years.

“It sends everybody into a panic mode – a hopeful panic mode,” Caison said. “They want to be one of those, but they don’t want to be one of those. They want their nightmare to end.”

Police: Newlyweds lure man through Craigslist for thrill killing

2013 killing

In the one case in which authorities say they have pinned down Barbour’s involvement, she and her husband, Elytte Barbour, 22, are accused of killing 42-year-old Troy LaFerrara, who police say responded to a “companionship” ad placed by Miranda Barbour on Craigslist.

The couple just wanted to kill someone together, police said. They had been married for only three weeks at the time of the slaying, and had moved from North Carolina to Pennsylvania after tying the knot.

Police say Elytte Barbour strangled LaFerrara in the front seat of her red Honda CR-V while Miranda Barbour stabbed him at least 20 times in November 2013. LaFerrara’s body was found the next day in the backyard of a home in Sunbury, a small city about 100 miles northwest of Philadelphia. The last number dialed on his cell phone led police to the Barbours, according to authorities.

Barbour claimed she began killing when she was 13 and involved in a satanic cult, Scarcella reported.

“I can pinpoint on a map where you can find them,” he quoted her as saying of the bodies. But she said LaFerrara’s killing was the Barbours’ first as a couple.

Elytte Barbour told police at the time of his arrest that he and his wife had tried to kill others, but the plans didn’t work out.

Both Barbours face several charges in LaFerrara’s death, including murder. Despite Miranda Barbour’s statements to Scarcella, both have pleaded not guilty.

Barbour’s attorney, public defender Edward Greco, told CNN he didn’t know she was planning to give the interview. He declined to comment on her claims.

But Levin said the way LaFerra’s body was left in someone’s yard isn’t typical of serial killers.

“If you’re a prolific serial killer, you’re going to go out of your way to dump the body in a desolate area off a highway so that people don’t find the evidence,” he said.

Satanists: Accused Craigslist killer not one of us

Claims raise doubts

Sunbury Police Chief Steve Mazzeo told CNN that investigators have been in contact with the FBI and law enforcement in some of the states where Barbour has lived. The father of Barbour’s 1-year-old child is dead, and Sunbury police have said that is part of their investigation.

“We investigate all leads just because that’s the proper protocol to follow through,” Mazzeo said.

Authorities also are looking closely at Barbour’s claims that she was involved in Satanism, according to another law enforcement source close to the investigation. But Gilmore, of the Church of Satan, said his church has a “law and order philosophy” that does not condone killing. He said the church has had no contact with Miranda Barbour or her husband.

Caison, the founder of the Wilmington-based Community United Effort Center for Missing Persons, has worked with murderers before in hopes of bringing closure to people whose loved ones haven’t been seen in years. In 2009, her organization helped find the body of Alice Donovan, who was abducted and murdered seven years earlier, after Donovan’s convicted killer wrote to tell Caison where the remains could be found.

“Anytime anything like this happens, we start getting e-mails and phone calls. I started getting texts last night,” Caison said. But she said Barbour will have to be questioned extensively by investigators before those claims can be put to the test.

“You can’t just say you’ve killed 22 people between this region and that region,” Caison said. “You’ve got to give a town or something that only police or an organization like us would know.” Without details like the gender, age or race of a victim, “We don’t even know where to start,” she said.

And like Levin, she cast doubt on Barbour’s claims.

“That’s a lot of people to kill in such a short time, and being so young and never making a mistake, I’m hard pressed to believe that amount,” she said. And for the families she works with, “You don’t want to build any false hope.”

Getting the interview

Scarcella told WNEP he got the interview after Barbour sent him a letter saying she wanted to talk.

Scarcella told CNN on Sunday that he was not allowed to bring a notepad or any other recording device into the interview. He said police allowed him to listen to the interview after it was conducted.

In his interview with WNEP, Scarcella described Barbour as “very meek, very mild” with a “very low voice.”

“She never hesitated once,” he told the station. “She never gave the impression of it was a rehearsal.”

Scarcella said he eventually asked if she had any remorse.

“And she said, ‘None,’” Scarcella told WNEP.

But that’s not what Scarcella said he found most surprising.

That would be, he said, “the fact that she said that if she got out she would do it again.”

Woman pleads guilty in case of pushing newlywed husband off cliff

Two charged in slaying of Iraq war vet who wanted to shop through Craigslist

Ohio man convicted for three murders in Craigslist job ad killings

CNN’s Daniel Burke, Haley Draznin, Susan Candiotti and Chris Welch contributed to this report.