Conversation with a killer: woman describes encounter with Navy Yard shooter

Updated 6:38 AM EDT, Thu September 19, 2013
02:54 - Source: CNN
Conversation with the Navy Yard shooter

Story highlights

Benita Bell travels often to Washington

She exchanged phone numbers with Aaron Alexis

Bell found Alexis "very cordial," says he had a "warm smile"

(CNN) —  

For scientist Benita Bell, memories of an encounter with a stranger last week took on a different light after the shooting Monday at the Navy Yard in Washington that left 12 people dead, one of the worst mass murders in the United States.

Turns out, that friendly stranger was the gunman.

Bell met Aaron Alexis, the man police say opened fire in a building at the Navy complex, at the Residence Inn in southwest Washington on September 10. Her work in astrobiology often brings her to the area.

“When I met him the first time, it was a very hot day that day. We crossed paths and he had this warm smile so we both said ‘hello.’ That was the first time we met and we commented on how hot the weather was that day.”

In an exclusive interview with CNN, Bell said she ran into Alexis again later that night in the hotel lobby. She said they chatted for about 15 minutes, discussing a range of topics including their careers and their love for the south. She’s from North Carolina and he told her he was from Fort Worth, Texas. The information technology contractor said he was in Washington for a “couple of weeks” for work.

When Alexis said he didn’t know anyone in D.C., Bell offered her cell phone number in case he needed help to get around the city. Bell said they exchanged phone numbers and he said “let’s keep in touch.”

Bell remembers Alexis as “very cordial, very engaging, very present. It was a connection, nothing at all suspicious about his demeanor.”

But that changed the following day, September 11. Bell said she ran into her new acquaintance again during happy hour at the hotel, and his demeanor was markedly different.

Alexis appeared “extremely tired, exhausted” and told her, “I got to go. I got to go. I’m going to take my food up to the room,” she remembered.

She didn’t see or speak to him again.

Flags in shooter’s past apparently not red enough

Five days later, Alexis walked into Building 197 at the Naval Yard carrying a bag. He ducked into a restroom and emerged with a shotgun, which he carried to a perch above the atrium and started firing. Twelve civilian contractors were killed and eight others wounded.

When the FBI released a photo of Alexis, who was killed in a gun battle with police, Bell said she had “absolutely no doubt” it was the man she met days earlier at the hotel.

She’s still “a bit shaken today, because there was there was nothing about his countenance, nothing at all that raised a red flag on Tuesday when I met him.”

“He didn’t look around, he didn’t appear paranoid, he didn’t appear as if he was wondering if anyone was looking. When I saw him on the news there was no doubt whatsoever.”

Federal officials said Alexis, 34, stayed in hotels after arriving in the Washington area on or about August 25.

After the shooting September 16, investigators searched for clues in his room at the Residence Inn, hoping that whatever he might have left behind – either in writing or on any computers – explained his actions.

So far, authorities haven’t offered any clues about a motive. But friends say Alexis had been frustrated over pay and benefits issues from a previous contracting job, and federal law enforcement sources said he may have contacted Veterans Affairs hospitals for possible treatment of psychological issues.

Since the shooting, Bell said she’s gone over her interaction with Alexis numerous times in her head, wondering if she missed something.

There’s “no excuse for the crime he committed,” she said, but she wonders “if there is anything I could have said, not knowing, but you wonder, is there anything that I could have said that would have given him a different thought?”

There was “something inside of this gentleman that literally he flipped from the person – I didn’t know him before, but from the person I met to being able to murder 12 people. I can hardly believe it.”