Steve Wilhite, left, received a Webby Award from Tumblr
Steve Wilhite, left, received a Webby Award from Tumblr's David Karp for his invention of the animated GIF format.
PHOTO: Bryan Bedder/Getty Images

Story highlights

GIF creator: It's pronounced "JIF"

Steve Wilhite created the Graphics Interchange Format in 1987 at Compuserve

He pronounced the issue closed at the Webby Awards

And yet, some partisans remain unswayed

(CNN) —  

We can’t settle iPhone vs. Android or “Star Wars” vs. “Star Trek” for you. But we can settle another long-running geek debate:

Those short, animated loops that have captivated the Web for decades? They’re pronounced like a brand of peanut butter.

Steve Wilhite created the Graphics Interchange Format, or GIF, while working for Compuserve in 1987. When he received a Webby Award in 2013 for it, and delivered his five-word acceptance speech (that’s all the Webbys allow), he flashed a GIF on the big screens at the Cipriani Wall Street in New York.

And, in a flash, it all became clear:

“It’s pronounced JIF, not GIF.”

Of course, in the grand tradition of heated debate, a flat statement of fact by the creator wasn’t enough to sway some partisans. On Twitter, “GIF” became a trending topic as some folks pushed back.

“Graphics Interchange Format. Graphics. Not Jraphics. #GIF #hardg,” wrote Web designer Dan Cederholm.

“So instead of GIF, we’ve got to say JIF? YEAH RIGHT,” chimed in October Jones, creator of the “Texts From Dog” Tumblr and book. “And I suppose those animals with long necks are called ‘JIRAFFES.’”

And, of course, the peanut butter brand was getting lots of free publicity along the way. The always amusing HAL 9000 account (yes, somebody tweets as the robot from “2001”) posted an “animated JIF” – which is to say, a swirling, animated jar of the tasty, high-protein spread.

So, it’s perhaps no surprise that the company got into the act itself. Wednesday afternoon, the company took to Twitter with a post reading, “It’s pronounced Jif® .” The tweet linked to, what else, a multi-colored GIF flashing the same phrase.

Animated GIFs were a staple of the early Internet. Remember The Dancing Baby? That’s a GIF.

They fell out of favor as more advanced graphics technology emerged. But in the past couple of years, the Web has remembered how much fun it is to watch ridiculous things happen over and over again.

Appropriately, Wilhite received his Lifetime Achievement Award from David Karp, the founder of Tumblr, one prominent place where GIFs found a new fanbase.

Wilhite has argued for the soft-G pronunciation for years. Yet no less an authority than the White House has posted an image on its Tumblr feed advocating for the hard-G. And the Oxford English Dictionary says both pronunciations are acceptable.

Maybe not.

Last month, no less an authority than the White House posted an image on its new Tumblr feed advocating for the hard-G. And the Oxford English Dictionary says both pronunciations are acceptable.

So, here’s wishing Mr. Wilhite “Jood Luck.”