lucie zhang leggings
Leggings as pants? School says, no way
01:07 - Source: WBBM

Editor’s Note: At a school in Illinois, middle schools students are fighting to be allowed to wear leggings to class. Social media strategist and fashion blogger Lucie Zhang originally wrote this defense of leggings in classroom in 2013.

Story highlights

Leggings can be school attire when worn correctly, fashion blogger Lucie Zhang writes

Schools should focus on student development rather than wardrobe, she says

Have an essay to share with the world? Submit at CNN iReport

CNN  — 

Our nation is experiencing a Crisis of Sheer Bottoms. Lululemon recently had to recall its popular yoga pants for being see-through, and now schools across the country are banning leggings from the classroom.

Panic everyone! Girls are walking around with the outlines of their panties showing! And while this practice isn’t what my mother would call “proper ladylike demeanor,” the personal choice of girls to wear leggings has come under attack.

Pajamas in public: The battle of appropriate vs. comfy

It’s the result of a common misunderstanding that leggings are pants. They are not. Yet a few girls’ confusion on whether or not leggings are pants should not ruin the true comfort and convenience of leggings for those who understand the difference.

Lucie Zhang (Courtesy Cole Haan)

I ask you, school administrators, if you have ever tried to put on a pair of freshly dried jeans in the morning, after the bliss of wearing your lightweight, loose PJs. The shock of restriction can be depressing. Devastating. Morale-killing. There are simply some days I cannot mentally handle the thought of wearing pants. And it is in these moments of mental weakness that I turn to my knight in shining cotton-spandex-blend: leggings.

LZ Granderson: Parents, don’t dress your girls like tramps

I make this choice mainly because of the way leggings create a similar silhouette to pants – one that cannot be achieved by wearing other trouser-alternatives such as shorts, skirts or dresses – without creating the dreaded muffin top.

In fact, if you’re going to restrict anything, it should be the extremely distracting bulge that occurs when an individual has on a pair of too tight, too low-rise jeans. Muffin tops are universally uncomfortable and unflattering and should be banned as such.

Leggings, however, fulfill a niche within the wardrobe of every woman. They’re neither pants nor tights. When paired with a tunic – a top that covers the outline of a lady’s underwear – the resulting look is perfectly nondistracting, and shows less skin than shorts or skirts. It’s flattering and a more slimming look than the extra thickness leggings would add under a skirt or dress – the only way some schools want them to be worn.

Ultimately, fashion is a form of self-expression, and students should be allowed to experiment with their personal style, especially during the formative years of middle and high school.

Fashion trucks bring style to you

The problem we have here is an educational one. As places that aim to encourage self-improvement and development, schools should work toward teaching students why social norms – like not wearing leggings as pants – develop before they force students into following questionable dress code solutions. Teach a girl that a fish is not a cow before showing her how you would catch it, rather than forcing her to eat the fish with a side of steak in an attempt to demonstrate the difference.

Otherwise, you might just end up with more muffin tops.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Lucie Zhang.