Baseball writers balk at Hall of Fame class of ‘13

Story highlights

NEW: Writer says you don't get pass on steroids because you were great before then

Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens strike out with Hall of Fame voters

None of the 37 players on the 2013 ballot received the 75% support needed to enter the Hall

"This really is a statement on an era," one baseball writer says

CNN —  

Baseball writers balked at naming any new players to the sport’s Hall of Fame on Wednesday, with none of the 37 eligible players drawing enough votes for a ticket to Cooperstown.

The 2013 ballot marked the first year of eligibility for several players who have been named in the probes of performance-enhancing drug use in the major leagues, including all-time home run champ Barry Bonds and seven-time Cy Young winner Roger Clemens.

It’s only the eighth time that no player received the 75% support needed to enter the National Baseball Hall of Fame, and several of the voters said the results reflected the Baseball Writers Association of America’s ambivalence about the sport’s “steroid era.”

“This is really a statement on an era, and it’s really a sad day for baseball,” BBWAA voter Jon Heyman told the sport’s in-house MLB Network. Heyman said he expected the writers who choose hall members would “basically split” on Bonds and Clemens, “and we’re not split. It was two-thirds to one-third against.”

The concerns about players who were linked to steroids “has hurt some of the clean guys” as well, Heyman said.

The head of the players’ union, Michael Weiner, said the decision was unfair.

“To ignore the historic accomplishments of Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, for example, is hard to justify,” he said. “Moreover, to penalize players exonerated in legal proceedings, and others never even implicated, is simply unfair. The Hall of Fame is supposed to be for the best players to have ever played the game.”

Longtime Sports Illustrated baseball writer Tom Verducci said it wouldn’t matter if a player was a Hall of Fame caliber player before baseball had its steroid use problems.

“Based on your career win totals or home run totals, that doesn’t give you the green light then to go ahead and cheat the game and those who played it, (making it) an unfair game.”

The top vote-getter on the 2013 ballot was longtime Houston Astros second baseman Craig Biggio, who racked up more than 3,000 hits in a two-decade career. Biggio received 68% of the vote, falling 39 votes short of election, Hall of Fame President Jeff Idelson announced.

Clemens has denied using performance-enhancing drugs, and in 2012, a federal jury acquitted him of lying to Congress during an investigation of steroid use. Bonds, who topped Hank Aaron’s home run mark in 2007, was sentenced to two years of probation and 30 days of house arrest for obstruction of justice in another federal probe; he also has denied using performance-enhancing drugs.

Other players on the ballot who were linked to the use of performance-enhancing drugs over the past two decades included Mark McGwire, the St. Louis Cardinals slugger who broke the sport’s single-season home run record in 1998; the Chicago Cubs’ Sammy Sosa, McGwire’s major rival in that season-long chase; and four-time All-Star Rafael Palmeiro.

In 2010, McGwire admitted to using steroids during his record-breaking season. Palmeiro was once slapped with a suspension after a positive drug test but denied using any banned substances. Sosa denied using steroids during a congressional hearing but did not respond to requests for an interview by staffers for former Sen. George Mitchell, who led a probe of steroid use in the major leagues in 2007.

Fans’ reactions were mixed.

“I think it’s utter nonsense,” said Darin McAuliffe, an Atlanta IT consultant. “I think if you’re going to be paid tens of millions of dollars a year, you’re going to do what you need to do to stay at the top of your game. And the average Joe gets that. And their owners demand that.”

Opinion: Going after Clemens was stupid

But Carl Bauer, who commented on the National Baseball Hall of Fame’s Facebook page, said the voters got it right.

“I think people confuse the Hall of Fame and Museum with getting a plaque from the Baseball Writers (Association) of America,” he wrote. “All the steroid cheaters (specifically Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Sosa and Palmeiro, etc.) have their accomplishments represented in the Hall of Fame. So the history of baseball, and their history in baseball, is represented. However, we do not need to honor these cheaters and lawbreakers with a plaque.”

Matt Roe, a Cardinals fan who was hanging out at The Post Sports Bar and Grill in Maplewood, Missouri, said he thought some of those on the ballot were punished for the supposed actions of another.

“The fact that nobody got inducted is kind of like the sports writers were making a point out of Barry Bonds,” he said.

Like Bonds and Clemens, Sosa was in his first year of eligibility for the Hall of Fame. McGwire was on the ballot for a seventh time and Palmeiro, a third.

Opinion: Allow doping in sport

Former pitcher Jack Morris received 67.7% of the vote. Morris, who won 254 games in his career, gets one more crack next year, as players are eligible for 15 ballots, beginning five years after they retire.

One of the players who won’t be on next year’s ballot is Dale Murphy, a two-time Most Valuable Player who spent most of his career with the Atlanta Braves.

The fact that no one was voted in this year could muddle the ballot for 2014, when pitchers Tom Glavine and Greg Maddux will be added to the ballot, as will slugger Frank Thomas.

Three people will be inducted into the Hall of Fame on July 28. In December a special panel that looks at people whose career ended before 1947 voted in Jacob Ruppert, the New York Yankees owner who bought Babe Ruth’s contract in 1919; former umpire Hank O’Day; and Deacon White, a catcher in the 19th century.

CNN’s Phil Gast and David Close contributed to this story.