01:48 - Source: CNN
Man acquitted of punching priest

Story highlights

William Lynch was accused of confronting retired priest Jerold Lindner in 2010

Lynch and his younger brother had claimed they were abused by Lindner decades earlier

A civil suit by the brothers against Lindner led to a $625,000 settlement in 1998

A jury Thursday acquitted Lynch on three counts, with a fourth dismissed after a deadlock

San Jose, California CNN —  

A California jury Thursday acquitted a man charged with assaulting a retired Catholic priest, in a case that prosecutors had described as a vigilante attack.

William Lynch, 44, was accused of confronting the Rev. Jerold Lindner, 68, during a visit at Sacred Heart Retirement home for Jesuit priests in Los Gatos, California, where Lindner had been living since retirement in 2001.

Prosecutors claimed that Lynch walked into the retirement center on May 10, 2010, under the pretense of delivering news about a relative, and attacked his former pastor.

Lynch and his younger brother had claimed more than a decade earlier that Lindner sexually molested them during church-led camping trips in northern California when they were 7 and 5 years old.

Pennsylvania: Catholic cleric behind bars in landmark sex abuse case

During Lynch’s assault trial, Lindner denied abusing the boys and maintained his innocence from the witness stand.

But two days into Lindner’s testimony, his attorney notified the court that his client was invoking his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination and would not testify further for fear of a perjury prosecution.

Lynch also took the witness stand and testified that he only had wanted the priest to sign a confession, and he said he had punched him after experiencing an irrational fear triggered by memories of the alleged abuse.

Lynch’s defense attorney, Pat Harris, claimed Lindner was responsible for his client’s actions.

“Society is the victim in all this … because there’s a man sitting up there at Los Gatos who is a rapist, who molests children, and he’s allowed to go free,” Harris said.

The statute of limitations on criminal molestation allegations had expired when Lynch and his brother went public with their allegations in 1997.

But in a civil lawsuit that was settled in 1998, Lynch and his brother asserted that Lindner sodomized them and forced them to have sex with each other while Lindner watched. In that suit, Lynch and his brother received a $625,000 settlement with the Jesuits of the California Province.

In the assault case against Lynch, he faced four counts stemming from the 2010 incident. The jury Thursday acquitted him on three counts and was unable to reach a decision on the fourth charge. The judge declared a mistrial on that count, and dismissed the charge.

Connecticut priest charged with possession of child porn

Dozens of Lynch supporters, including his parents, gathered with demonstration signs outside the Santa Clara County Courthouse proclaiming the defendant’s innocence.

Before the trial, prosecutors offered Lynch a plea deal offer that would have required a year in jail.

In closing arguments, prosecutors urged the jury to refrain from being swayed by Lynch’s emotional testimony describing the alleged childhood trauma he claimed to have endured at the hands of Lindner.

After the verdict, Jim Muyo, a spokesman for the California Province of the Society of Jesus, released a statement saying they respect “the legal process and the findings of the judge and jury in the case of William Lynch.”

Church report: Children are safer from abuse

Opinion: Teach children to protect their bodies