Barbour's pardons challenged
02:31 - Source: CNN

Story highlights

Attorney general likens Barbour to "Boss Hogg"

State Attorney General Jim Hood wins temporary injunction

Some misunderstand clemency process, Haley Barbour says

Attorney general calls pardons "a slap in the face ... to law enforcement"

CNN  — 

Hood said he did not know Barbour’s reasons for the pardons and clemencies, but said he owed the public an explanation.

The pardons include four convicted murderers and a convicted armed robber who were released Sunday. The five now must contact prison officials on a daily basis as their fate is adjudicated.

The pardons are “a slap in the face to everyone in law enforcement and Gov. Barbour should be ashamed,” said state Attorney General Jim Hood.

The process of releasing 21 other inmates has been halted, said Hood, who sought the court order.

A court hearing on the matter will be held January 23.

Hood said Barbour violated Mississippi’s Constitution because the pardon requests for many inmates were not published 30 days before they were granted, as required.

“He’s tried to rule the state like Boss Hogg and he didn’t think the law applied to him,” Hood told CNN’s Anderson Cooper on Wednesday night, referring to a character in the 1980s TV series “The Dukes of Hazzard.”

“These families are afraid out here,” Hood said of relatives of crime victims.

What’s behind the pardon battle?

On his way out the door, the governor approved full pardons for nearly 200 people, including 14 convicted murderers, according to documents the Mississippi secretary of state’s office released Tuesday.

The four murderers who received full pardons last week – David Gatlin, Joseph Ozment, Charles Hooker and Anthony McCray – were cited in Green’s order.

They were all serving life sentences and worked as inmate trusties at the governor’s mansion, said Suzanne Singletary, spokeswoman for the Mississippi Department of Corrections. Trusties are inmates who can receive additional rights through good behavior.

Hood told CNN that it’s possible that those who didn’t meet the 30-day requirement may have to return to prison and complete their sentences.

Barbour said Wednesday that some people misunderstand the clemency process and believe that most of the individuals were still jailed.

“Approximately 90 percent of these individuals were no longer in custody, and a majority of them had been out for years,” he said in a statement.

“The pardons were intended to allow them to find gainful employment or acquire professional licenses as well as hunt and vote. My decision about clemency was based upon the recommendation of the Parole Board in more than 90 percent of the cases,” Barbour wrote. “The 26 people released from custody due to clemency is just slightly more than one-tenth of 1 percent of those incarcerated.”

Half of the people who were released were placed on indefinite suspension “due to (chronic) medical reasons because their health care expenses were costing the state so much money,” Barbour said.

Hood said he is questioning the release of many of the 175 individuals who received full pardons.

The pardons are “a slap in the face to everyone in law enforcement and Governor Barbour should be ashamed,” Hood said.

“I feel like my safety is in jeopardy,” Randy Walker, who was shot and wounded by Gatlin, said Wednesday. “I wonder if he’s going to finish what he’s started.”

Gatlin walked into a trailer in 1993 where his estranged wife, Tammy Ellis, lived and shot her in the head as she held their 6-week-old baby in her arms. She died of her wounds.

In an interview with CNN’s Soledad O’Brien, Walker and Tiffany Ellis Brewer – Tammy’s sister – expressed concerns about the release and fears that Gatlin may intend to target them.

“I’m married and have a family again,” Walker said. “I feel the safety for them is an issue. Anybody that might be with me at the time that he decides to do something would be in jeopardy.”

Gatlin’s pardon also raised concerns from John Kitchens, the prosecutor who saw him sent to prison.

“Haley Barbour is insane for granting a pardon to this criminal,” said Kitchens, who is now in private practice.

Brewer said Barbour – who left office this week – hasn’t directly responded to questions about the pardon.

“He will not comment on anything. We have no answers as to why he has done this. I would like to think he did not have all of the facts of the case, if he did have all the facts,” she said.

“Apparently, we haven’t had a really good man for our governor.”

Barbour’s successor, Phil Bryant, was inaugurated Tuesday.

Brewer shared the fears of those families watching convicted killers of their loved ones get blanket pardons and go free.

“I’m sure that they feel basically the same way as Randy and I do. We’re both fearful for our lives, our families’ lives, and we will live with this for the rest of our lives,” she said.

Gatlin’s whereabouts were unknown late Wednesday.

Barbour, who served eight years in the governor’s office, had previously granted full pardons to three other convicted killers in 2008. Another three were awarded conditional or indefinite releases during his time in office – meaning the governor, in total, granted reprieves to 20 convicted murderers, the documents showed.

Since the conservative governor took office in 2004, 222 people were granted clemency for a wide variety of crimes. Those who have been granted full pardons include shoplifters, rapists, burglars and embezzlers.

There were also a number who were found guilty of either manslaughter or homicide, who were given unconditional pardons.

CNN’s Ed Lavandera, Rich Phillips, Vivian Kuo and Joe Sutton contributed to this report.