Kim Jong Il's death leaves a combustible region on edge

Leader's death shocks region
Leader's death shocks region


    Leader's death shocks region


Leader's death shocks region 02:56

Story highlights

  • NEW: Fate of six-party talks "is the really important question now," James Rubin says
  • NEW: Rubin, others note that hereditary succession complicates matters
  • NEW: Many will be watching to see if challengers arise, says Asia expert Victor Chu
  • Tensions between North and South Korea had already spiked last year
The death of the North Korean leader Kim Jong Il has ushered in a period of tremendous uncertainty in Northeast Asia, with every move by countries in the region risking unpredictable reactions from others.
South Korea ramped up its level of military alert Monday following the announcement of Kim's death, while Japan held emergency military meetings. The United States said it was in close contact with the South Korean and Japanese governments.
"It's a moment that's rife for miscalculation and unintended consequences," said CNN's Wolf Blitzer.
The region is a combustible geopolitical mix. The South, which has the support of the United States, and the nuclear-armed North, allied with China, have technically remained at war since the conflict that split the peninsula in the 1950s.
Even before Kim's death, tensions had spiked between the two Koreas last year. The North was accused of sinking a South Korean naval vessel in the Yellow Sea and fired artillery at a South Korean island in November 2010, killing two civilians.
But the United States and other parties had appeared to make progress in recent weeks to try to rekindle negotiations over the North's nuclear program, known as the six-party talks.
Those efforts now seem to have been in vain.
Even such steps as food aid and nascent diplomacy "are very difficult to orchestrate ... in the best of circumstances with North Korea," former U.S. Assistant Secretary of State James Rubin told CNN on Monday. He said the fate of the talks "is the really important question now."
"I kind of wonder whether a new regime ... will be prepared to take these steps that they may have agreed to last week, last month," Rubin said. "So if I were in the administration, I would be wondering whether this deal they had struck would really be carried out."
Kim's death makes the negotiations "seem even further out of reach than they were before," said Stephanie Kleine-Ahlbrandt, project director for Northeast Asia at the International Crisis Group, a nonprofit organization that works to prevent and resolve conflicts.
Kim had controlled the opaque, authoritarian North Korean regime for more than 15 years. The sudden announcement of his death thrusts his youngest son, Kim Jong Un, onto center stage. But the younger Kim's intentions and leadership capabilities remain murky.
Kim Jong Un is young and inexperienced, said Mike Chinoy, a senior fellow at the U.S.-China Institute. He added that it remained to be seen whether he would be able to consolidate his power and whether he would actually lead or just be a figurehead.
The danger, according to Kleine-Ahlbrandt of the International Crisis Group, is if the younger Kim and his close supporters find themselves in a weak position domestically and feel the need to make a show of military muscle to appear stronger.
"Then you get into the fireworks and provocation side of North Korean policy," she said.
Rubin said he "wouldn't bet on a perfectly stable transition." Rubin noted that North Korea's habit, unique among communist nations, of passing leadership "from father to son" has led to complications.
"That's because there are many different power centers -- the military, the party, the security apparatus, the secret police, whatever," Rubin said. "And you know, some of them may not feel comfortable with the fact that this young man who hasn't done very much will be in charge of this country and its nuclear weapons."
South Korea was already nervous about 2012, since the North was planning a nationwide, yearlong celebration in as a show of strength and to honor the 100th anniversary of the birth of Kim Il Sung, the founder of the communist nation and Kim Jong Il's father.
In October, South Korean Defense Minister Kim Kwan-jin said, "I believe that the possibility of North Korea conducting additional provocations is ... very high" in the new year.
This summer, the commander of American troops in South Korea told Congress that the United States does not believe Kim Jong Un will differ much in decision-making from his father, or adjust the country's strategic priorites.
However, Gen. James Thurman told the Senate Armed Services Committee in a written answer, Kim Jong Un's "youth and inexperience increase the likelihood of miscalculation, as does the imperative for him to establish credibility with the military hardliners he needs to support succession."
Questions remain about whether Kim Jong Un will be accepted -- or whether another entity might attempt to wrest control.
"He is so untested, and there has been little opportunity for him to develop the sort of networks he needs to develop in a system like this in order to maintain security of his position and security of power," said Victor Cha, former director of Asian affairs with the National Security Council.
"I think all of us are going to be watching this very closely to see what his next steps are," Cha told CNN, "and indeed whether there are groups within the North that are so unhappy with the current state of the country that they seek to try to challenge his leadership."
The prospect of an even more volatile situation on the peninsula comes at an inconvenient time for China. Beijing is heading into a major leadership transition in 2012 and will have little enthusiasm for unpredictable moves from Pyongyang.
"China's top priority on the Korean Peninsula is maintaining stability," said Kleine-Ahlbrandt, adding that it wants to avoid an imploding North Korea, refugees flooding across the border and the risk of an increased U.S. military presence on the Korean peninsula.
China has devoted considerable economic resources to maintaining the status quo in Pyongyang.
The new leadership in North Korea could indeed present an opportunity for the United States to test Kim Jong Un's openness to change, said RAND's Bruce Bennett, an Asia analyst who has worked with the U.S. Department of Defense, as well as the South Korean and Japanese militaries.
"We ought to try to float things to see," he said.
But China is not the only member of the six-party talks preoccupied by internal politics in 2012: the United States and Russia both have presidential elections taking place, which could distract attention from the complex diplomatic wrangling on the Korean peninsula.