Skip to main content

Binghamton victims died seeking better lives, relatives say

  • Story Highlights
  • Two of 13 people killed at immigrant service center buried Sunday
  • Both were trying to improve their language skills at the center, relatives say
  • Layla Khalil narrowly escaped bombings in Iraq before coming to U.S., relatives say
  • Parveen Ali, 26, was "the base of our family," brother says
  • Next Article in Crime »
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

BINGHAMTON, New York (CNN) -- Layla Khalil escaped the bombs that rocked Iraq during three years of insurgent and sectarian warfare, only to be gunned down while trying to learn English in her adopted hometown, family and friends said Sunday.

Police say the gunman parked this car to block the back door of the immigration center.

Hundreds took part in a vigil in Binghamton Sunday after an interfaith service for the victims of Friday's shooting.

Khalil, 57, was buried Sunday afternoon, two days after she and 12 others were shot to death Friday at the American Civic Association, an immigrant service center in Binghamton. Before coming to the United States in recent months, she narrowly escaped suicide bombings and a kidnapping in Baghdad, Iraq, where she worked as a librarian.

"The situation in Iraq is dangerous, everywhere dangerous," her 17-year-old son Mustafa told reporters after the funeral. "But we came here, and we hoped we'll get better lives."

He said his mother's death has not changed his feelings about moving to America. But, he said, "The situation has changed. Everything has changed. This is life. You have to expect everything."

"I'm 17 years old. I lose my love, my mother, emotion," he said. "I wish that anyone doesn't lose that."

Also buried Sunday was Parveen Ali, a 26-year-old Pakistani-born woman who was one of the 13 killed. Her brother, Nader, said she was "the base of our family" and a "martyr." Video Watch relatives remember one of the other victims, Roberta King »

Victms Identified

Binghamton, New York, officials released a list of the 13 victims in Friday's shooting, with their hometowns and country of origin:

  • Parveen Ali, 26, Binghamton; Pakistan
  • Dolores Yigal, 53, Binghamton; the Philippines
  • Marc Henry Bernard, 44, Endicott, New York; Haiti
  • Maria Sonia Bernard, 46, Endicott; Haiti
  • Li Guo, 47, Binghamton; China
  • Hong Xiu Mao, 35, Greene, New York; China
  • Lan Ho, 39, Binghamton; Vietnam
  • Hai Hong Zhong, 54, Endwell, New York; China
  • Maria Zobniw, 60, Binghamton; United States
  • Roberta Bobby King, 72, Binghamton; United States
  • Almir O. Alves, 43, hometown unknown; Brazil
  • Jiang Ling, 22, Endicott; China
  • Layla Khalil, 57, Binghamton; Iraq
  • "There's nothing we can do," he said. "She was an innocent person who got killed for no reason."

    Nader Ali said he, his mother, his sister and a brother came to the United States in 2001. His sister became a U.S. citizen and a teacher, so she continued to go to the civic association to improve her language skills.

    "She was like a parent. She was like a friend. She was a teacher. She was a facilitator who always pushed me to go through school, to go through college," he said.

    Police said they believe Jiverly Wong, a 41-year-old Vietnamese immigrant from an ethnic Chinese family, shot 17 people at the center and then killed himself. Four people were in serious condition in local hospitals but were expected to survive, police said. Photo View photos from the scene in Binghamton »

    Wong had been taking English classes at the association and was upset about recently losing a job, but officials said no clear motive for the killings was immediately evident.

    Funerals for Khalil and Ali were held Sunday afternoon at a local mosque. An interfaith memorial service for all the victims was held Sunday evening, and hundreds of people took part in a candlelight vigil afterward.

    Khalil was taking English classes at the civic association. Her husband, Samir, a linguist and education professor, said she spoke English well but wanted "to develop, to have a have a lot of progress in the English language and other things, so perhaps she can teach."


    He said that Friday morning, as his wife of 31 years was getting ready to leave, he urged her not to go to the center every day -- but she wanted to make up for time she had missed earlier, and enjoyed interacting with people at the center.

    Samir Khalil said the killings don't change "the main core of Binghamton -- its reputation, its people, its hospitality to other people."

    All About BinghamtonShootings

    All About ShootingsBinghamton

    • E-mail
    • Save
    • Print