Skip to main content
CNN EditionU.S.
The Web     
Powered by
powered by Yahoo!

NYC councilman killed by political rival

Gunman, accompanied by victim, bypassed metal detector

A woman, left, who identified herself as a goddaughter of James E. Davis, reacts outside Davis' offices after news of his violent death.

Story Tools

more video VIDEO
CNN's Maria Hinojosa reports on the slaying of Councilman James E. Davis inside New York City Hall.
premium content

NYC Councilwoman Gale Brewer: "A very very frightening experience."
premium content

Geoffrey Davis asks how his brother could have been shot inside City Hall.
premium content

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg explains what happened.
premium content
A Brooklyn native and former police officer, Councilman James E. Davis, D-Brooklyn, has been involved in public policy since 1983, when he was falsely arrested (and, he said, beaten) for stealing a car that was, in fact, his mother's.

After graduating from Pace University, Davis became a corrections officer at New York's Rikers Island. In 1991 he went to work for the Transit Police, then transferred to the NYPD in 1993. Later that same year, he went to work as a social science instructor at the police academy.

Davis headed "LOVE YOURSELF" Stop the Violence, a non-profit organization he founded in 1990. Among other efforts, the group in 1994 convinced Toys 'R' Us to stop selling realistic-looking toy guns. Davis was elected to the New York City Council in November 2001.

Sources: New York City Council, "LOVE YOURSELF" Stop the Violence
• Gallery: City Hall Shooting 
• Audio Slide Show: City Hall horror 
• Obituary: James E. Davis 

NEW YORK (CNN) -- In a crime that sent shock waves across New York City, a political rival of City Councilman James E. Davis opened fire in the chamber's balcony, killing Davis just minutes after the two had entered City Hall together, authorities said.

The gunman, Othniel Askew, 31, was shot and killed by a plainclothes officer who was on the council speaker's security detail.

"It's a very sad day for New York," Mayor Michael Bloomberg told reporters. "It is a great tragedy."

Bloomberg said Davis -- a 41-year-old former police officer known as a crusader against urban violence -- and Askew had entered through the west entrance at 1:44 p.m. EDT.

The two did not pass through a metal detector, which is not unusual for elected officials, apparently allowing Askew to slip his silver .40-caliber Smith & Wesson handgun into the council chamber undetected, along with an extra four bullets in his socks.

As a result of the security breach, Bloomberg said that effective immediately he and all other elected officials and their guests must go through the metal detectors.

Bloomberg and other city officials said there was no sign of a verbal or physical altercation between Davis and Askew before the shots rang out. Authorities said Askew fired shots at Davis on the balcony and never appeared to fire down below at the rest of the city council members.

"The city council meeting was going along normally when all of a sudden there were screams and shots," Bloomberg said.

One city councilman, Charles Barron, who represents Brooklyn, said shortly before the shooting, Davis had introduced him to Askew, saying, "This is the guy who was once against me, but now he's with me."

FBI: Man claimed he was harassed

Police Commissioner Ray Kelly said a police officer on the main level of the chamber fired six shots at Askew. Askew suffered multiple wounds to his chest and arms. Kelly said it was unclear if any of his wounds were self-inflicted.

Davis was shot in the torso. Davis was known to carry a licensed gun, but was unable to draw the weapon, Kelly said.

With the investigation focusing on the suspect and his motives, FBI spokesman Joe Valiquette told CNN that a man identifying himself as Othniel Askew called their office earlier in the day and accused Davis of harassment.

"The person who took the call said he sounded very cool, calm and collected," Valiquette said, adding that the caller made no threats.

Witnesses in the chamber gave a harrowing account of chaos and mayhem, with council members and their staff ducking for cover -- papers flying in the air -- as screams and shots echoed through the room. The main floor of the chamber seats the city's 51 council members and their staff, while the balcony allows the public to observe the meetings.

"All pandemonium broke out," Councilman Michael McMahon said.

Manhattan Councilwoman Gale Brewer said, "This was a very, very, very frightening experience."

"We dove under our desks and we were piled on top of each other because so many of us had never experienced something like this," she said.

Soon, everyone was trying to escape, she said.

"We were running really fast. People were tripping, they were falling -- they were even falling over the line in front of the guard rail. And then we ran down into the rotunda of the City Hall and then we were told by the police to run even further. People were jumping over the fence that is in City Hall parking lot to get out into the street," she said.

Bloomberg said he was sitting in his office at the time.

"I was at my desk working and all of a sudden I heard screams and a loud noise," he said.

He immediately thought about a group of children who were there to watch the council meeting. They were immediately corralled into a secure room and received grief counseling, he said.

The attack, Bloomberg said, "strikes at the very essence of democracy."

'How did this happen at City Hall?'

Geoffrey Davis, the brother of the assassinated councilman, was outraged.

"The system killed my brother," he shouted. "Just the same way they killed Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, the system knew that my brother would continue fighting for the betterment to stop violence. That's who killed my brother. The system."

He also demanded: "How did this happen at City Hall?"

Friends and colleagues of Askew were equally shocked.

Cheni Yerushalmi, who worked on his city council campaign, said Askew was running for office because he wanted "to make things better for the underdog. He was an upstanding guy."

Yerushalmi said Askew did have a license to own a gun.

"I can't believe this. I'm shocked," Yerushalmi said.

Asked whether Askew had a history of violence, Yerushalmi said, "He's not violent. He gets angry; we all get angry. But he's never been violent in terms of rage. He's never been violent towards me."

"I can't even imagine what triggered something like this," said Yerushalmi, who met Askew 10 years ago when the two were vacationing in the Hamptons, where they became fast friends. "He's a great guy, very understanding."

Yerushalmi, who described himself and Askew as real estate entrepreneurs who worked independently of each other, added, "He's been there for me a thousand times. I feel very terrible about this incident and the whole situation. I don't know what could have led to it. It's just totally out of character."

Joe Raby, a friend who's known Askew for nearly a decade, said of Wednesday's attack: "It's just astounding."

Story Tools
Subscribe to Time for $1.99 cover
Top Stories
Father guilty of killing 9 of his children
Top Stories
CNN/Money: Security alert issued for 40 million credit cards

International Edition
CNN TV CNN International Headline News Transcripts Advertise With Us About Us
   The Web     
Powered by
© 2005 Cable News Network LP, LLLP.
A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines. Contact us.
external link
All external sites will open in a new browser. does not endorse external sites.
 Premium content icon Denotes premium content.
Add RSS headlines.