|Editions | myCNN | Video | Audio | Headline News Brief | Feedback||
Judge rules testimony concerning alleged Perez murders is irrelevant
LOS ANGELES, California (CNN) -- A judge ruled Thursday that former Los Angeles police officer Rafael Perez does not have to testify any further in the trial of two men who accuse Perez of framing them.
Attorneys for the two defendants wanted to call Perez, who testified in the case last month, back to the witness stand to question his credibility. Since his previous testimony, his former girlfriend, Sonya Flores, went public with allegations that she saw Perez kill two people in a botched drug deal. She also alleged that Perez and his partner, former LAPD Officer David Mack, dumped the bodies in a Tijuana, Mexico, ravine.
Superior Court Judge Larry Fidler said, "I find the Flores matter to be totally irrelevant to these proceedings."
The ruling is significant because four floors below Fidler's courtroom, testimony continued for a fifth day in the trial of four Los Angeles police officers accused of conspiring to frame innocent people. Perez is the key witness in that case. Attorneys for the two sergeants and two officers on trial say they also want to ask Perez about the alleged murders. Judge Jacqueline Connor, the presiding judge in that case, will rule on the admissibility of that testimony. It's not known what bearing Fidler's ruling will have on the case.
Winston Kevin McKesson, Perez's attorney, said he expects his client's testimony to be ruled irrelevant in the trial of the four officers also.
"I think he's probably put a close on the Sonya Flores chapter by ruling it is irrelevant. And I really applaud Judge Fidler for that courageous and bold and intellectually sound ruling," he said.
McKesson said there is no evidence to back up Flores' accusations.
"We're talking about a murder allegation of people we don't even know ever existed. We're talking about no bodies. We're talking about digging up half of Tijuana and not finding any bodies," he said.
Mexican police began digging last week in a ravine but have found nothing so far.
One defense attorney in the officers' trial said he doesn't think Fidler's ruling will have any impact on his case.
"These are entirely separate cases, and separate proceedings," said Joel Isaacson, who represents Officer Paul Harper. Harper is charged with perjury and conspiracy to obstruct justice.
When asked if he thinks the ruling may set a precedent for Judge Connor, Isaacson said, "Absolutely not," although he did acknowledge that prosecutors may "take a lead" from the ruling.
Prosecutors, who were informed by CNN of Fidler's ruling as they left court, said they could not comment on it.
Perez agreed to testify about alleged officer misconduct in the LAPD anti-gang units in exchange for a lenient sentence for stealing six pounds of cocaine from the police evidence locker.
Prosecutors had planned to call him to the witness stand, but when Flores' allegations came to light recently, his already-questionable credibility became even more of an issue.
Since Perez began detailing stories of officer misconduct within the LAPD, 106 criminal convictions have been overturned, and at least 70 officers are under investigation.
LAPD officer's ex-lover talks to CNN
Department of Justice proposed consent decree
The Los Angeles Police Department
|Back to the top||
© 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.|
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.