|
Friday, January 26, 2007
The lives they left behind
There is no one word to describe a battlefield or the aftermath.
For the most part, all you find are traces of civilian lives, the lives that they left behind. Dusty photo frames, unfinished meals, a child's shoe. During the November 9 battle for Haifa Street in Baghdad, all that was left behind in the luxury apartments U.S. and Iraqi troops had taken position in were these small clues of the life that once was Haifa Street. Outside the firefight was still raging, an explosion shook the building, and someone yelled "mortar!" I was staring at a little yellow sequined flip flop. It was probably around hour five of what would end up being a 10-hour gun battle and I was already exhausted. And so when I saw the dirty and dusty couch in the poorly lit entrance to one of these apartments and the unit that I was with paused for a moment - I sank into it. And then I saw the flip flop discarded and dusty. Who was she? I pictured her as being slender, maybe eight years old, slightly curly hair in pigtails. Where did she go? Was she still alive? I could imagine her laughter echoing in the hallway and I wondered if it ever would again. Back out on patrol the day after the second battle for Haifa in as many weeks - a quick embed facilitated by the 1-23 Stryker Battalion that we had covered the fighting with - we were finally able to snatch brief conversations with some of the civilians that endured life on Haifa street. There's were stories of killing at the hands of the "others" (the insurgents,) fear of "down there" (where most of the fighting was centralized,) and raw anger at just about everything. On the southern tip of Haifa life looked almost normal. Kids played soccer in front of the Stryker vehicles as if a major battle had not just raged for eight hours, as if it might not just flare up again. "Down there" - an unnerving ghost town. Shops shut, laundry still fluttering from deserted apartments. Just the boots and chatter of Iraqi and U.S. forces and the knowledge that something probably still lurks in these buildings. In the slums behind the luxury apartment complexes that line Haifa, not far from where a precision guided missile had flattened a building that insurgent machine gunners had holed up in, two women were walking around. What were they thinking walking around what was once alley-to-alley fighting? They were in fact fuming. At the helplessness of their situation, at life that forced them to endure mortars falling in their backyard and snipers, at visions of dogs gnawing at dead bodies. They were stuck with nowhere else to go and no one to help them.
flaten all of them / then bulldose them , at least they will not have them to hide in to kill our troops
this post shows so much of the pure abject misery that is common in Iraq now. A misery that was created by 1 rich stupid american and his followers. Others hold the guns but 1 Idiot In Chief created the strings attached to them to pull the triggers on all sides. For every dead soldier, child, man, woman, family pet .... fore every dead LIFE, 1 rich safe spoiled brat cowardly American president is responsible. The same man that said in a speech that "all life is sacred". Yeah Right. I can taste and smell your post.Thanks.
the first post depicts the cold-blooded views of an american, living in the supposed 'civilised' west. Full of pure hatred and ignorance
As a follow up to the comment on "yas", I am happy that person from Utah was not referred to as a "typical American"; he is a breed apart although typical enough to re-elect a moron in 2004.
Wars, particularly the ill-conceived ones, are messy and bring out the worst in people; particularly those that can sit back unaffected and look at it like a video game. Until more people can actually see the devastation, smell the stench of death and realize that a "body bag" actually contains the remnants of someone's dreams, hopes and fears, this debacle will seem like nothing more than an idiot's adventure claoked in anti-terrorism rhetoric. More reports should be sent by the brave people that bring news to us all and perhaps the next time a life and death decision has to be taken, it will be by a person who knows what the downside contains. Bring back the draft and let the rich and powerful place their children in harms way, or in the VA hospitals at the very least, and then lets see how quickly the politicians repeat the mistake of Iraq.
I would say the first poster has the same attitude towards Iraqis as the insurgents have towards Americans: if 'we' kill all of 'them', the problem will go away. This attitude (from people on both sides) is responsible for most of the problem...
That Idiot the is running the US should be sent over there and smell the death a destruction that he is causing. The Devil will not have far to go for fuel when that bastard arrives
The Baghdad violence is Sunnis killing Shias and vice versa. This won't stop if U. S. troops leave; it will get worse. This isn't happening because U. S. troops are there; it's happening because Saddam is no longer around to keep the minority Sunnis in power, through the simple expedient of killing hundreds of thousands of his countrymen.
Read the article again; the insurgents were killing Iraqi civilians before the troops moved in. Why are the other commenters not condemning that? And would you rather the U. S. and Iraqi forces simply stand by and watch? Blaming President Bush for the sectarian violence after Saddam's removal from power is like blaming Mafia violence on the FBI for arresting John Giotti. The plain and simple truth is that if the various Iraqi factions stopped killing each other, Baghdad would be a peaceful city.
I'm curious, if Duck Sic is so invested in this particular outcome, why is he posting from Utah instead of Haifa Street?
The recruiting offices are still open.
Emotions cloud clear thinking. Focus on who benefits. Arms sales, reconstruction contracts, cheap oil are the dessert. The main objective is to stop the fundamentalist revolution started by Khomeini (thats why US hired Saddam to gas the iranians). What better way then to neutralize them by using the sunnis. Divide and conquer, once again. War in Iraq is a total success for US. Bush is the smartest guy around and we are all suckers thinking he blundered. CIA is fueling the civil war.
Arwa,
The horrific violence will not end if the US troops leave Iraq,it would escalate into genocide if the US pulled out it's brave troops that lay their life on the line, you can't even distinguish what sect Sunni/ Shia or even insurgents are killing one another, they have even infiltrated the Iraqi army backed by Iran, the complexities of this war exceed what anyone could even come close to understanding, blaming president Bush is cliche and just a cheap shot ,he has to weigh each life and bare the responsibility, the democtrats are quick to criticize but fail tremendously in proposing and implementing solutions to move forward in this war. I thank you in your reporting what you see on the ground, but there is the larger picture beyond one's personal take. Maritza San Jose, Ca |
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.
ARCHIVE
• December 2006• January 2007 • February 2007 • March 2007 • April 2007 • May 2007 • June 2007 • July 2007 • August 2007 • September 2007 • October 2007 • November 2007 • December 2007 • January 2008 • February 2008 |

