ad info

CNN.com
 MAIN PAGE
 WORLD
 ASIANOW
 U.S.
 LOCAL
 POLITICS
 WEATHER
 BUSINESS
 SPORTS
 TECHNOLOGY
 NATURE
 ENTERTAINMENT
 BOOKS
 TRAVEL
 FOOD
 HEALTH
 STYLE
 IN-DEPTH

 Headline News brief
 daily almanac
 CNN networks
 CNN programs
 on-air transcripts
 news quiz

  CNN WEB SITES:
CNN Websites
 TIME INC. SITES:
 MORE SERVICES:
 video on demand
 video archive
 audio on demand
 news email services
 free email accounts
 desktop headlines
 pointcast
 pagenet

 DISCUSSION:
 message boards
 chat
 feedback

 SITE GUIDES:
 help
 contents
 search

 FASTER ACCESS:
 europe
 japan

 WEB SERVICES:
US

Overview | Map: Gun laws by state | Map: Cities vs. Guns | Discussion | Sites

N.Y. jury finds some gun makers liable in shootings

graphic


 


RELATED VIDEO
CNN's Gary Tuchman reports on the negligence verdict in the gun lawsuit
Windows Media 28K 80K
 
February 11, 1999
Web posted at: 10:39 p.m. EST (0339 GMT)

In this story:

Arguing the case

Trouble in the jury room

RELATED STORIES, SITES



NEW YORK (CNN) -- In a case bound to rock America's gun industry, a federal jury Thursday found 15 of the nation's largest handgun makers negligent in their marketing and distributing practices.

"I thank God, we absolutely won," said lead plaintiff Freddie Hamilton, whose son, Njuzi, was slain in 1993. She predicted the verdict would bring a "new phase" of litigation against the firearms industry.

"I don't think they felt they needed to care, and this verdict will have them rethinking that," said Hamilton.

Another 10 manufacturers were cleared of negligence. "We have seen some things they did that helped take guns off the street ... and stuff like that, that a lot of others didn't do," juror Charles Beatty said.

The mixed verdict required 42 pages of explanation. Jurors found nine companies partly responsible for the shooting death of one man. Four of the companies were found partly responsible for the shooting death of another, and three of the companies were found partly responsible for the wounding of a third man.

A lawyer representing six of the companies said all efforts will be made to have the verdict overturned.

Families of six homicide victims and the severely wounded man brought the civil lawsuit, seeking millions of dollars in what's being viewed as a test case for similar anti-gun suits brought by several large cities.

In the one case where the shooting victim survived, the jury assessed the gun manufacturers $4 million in damages. But the victim, Steven Fox, and his mother will get only a portion of that, a sum in excess of $500,000.

No damages were awarded to families of the dead, an issue that one juror said divided the panel in its six days of deliberations.

Beatty said he wanted to pay more damages to more victims, but other jurors felt otherwise.

"I think when you go on jury duty, everybody's got to compromise a little," he said.

Arguing the case

Guns Under Fire
BACKGROUND
  • CNN's Allan Dodds Frank examines the municipal movement against guns
    (Windows: 28K 80K)

  • Targeting guns at the source

    GUNS AND THE LAW
  • At a Glance
  • Interactive Timeline

    INTERACTIVE MAPS
  • Cities vs. Guns
  • Gun laws by state

    MESSAGE BOARD
  • Who's responsible for gun violence?

    POLL
    Should gun manufacturers be held liable for gun violence?
    Yes    No
    Sometimes

    or View Results
  • The plaintiffs argued handgun makers "oversupply" gun-friendly markets, mainly in the South, aware that the excess guns flow into criminal hands via illegal markets in New York and other states with stricter anti-gun laws.

    Lawyers for the plaintiffs accused the defendants of dumping handguns onto the black market like "toxic waste," making no effort to identify and discipline dishonest distributors.

    Gun industry attorney James Dorr told the jury it was unfair to "hold the manufacturers of a lawful, legitimately sold product responsible for acts of outlaws who are totally outside their control.... The case is simply wrong."

    The gun makers also asserted that in most of the shootings the plaintiffs never presented evidence conclusively linking the weapons used to harm their relatives to specific defendants.

    The plaintiffs countered that the "chain of title" is irrelevant, instead accusing the entire industry of creating a widespread risk with negligent marketing -- a concept known as collective liability.

    However, the jury decided that 10 of the 25 companies in this case had no liability whatsoever.

    Trouble in the jury room

    The mixed verdict followed six difficult days of deliberations, during which the jury told the judge several times that it was deadlocked.

    Early Thursday, the jury sent a note to U.S. District Judge Jack Weinstein implying 10 of the 11 jurors were prepared to decide against the gun manufacturers. The note also stated that that 11th juror was holding out because of concern that such a verdict would "open the floodgates of lawsuits across the country."

    Legal experts have compared the New York case to coordinated legal assault by numerous states on the tobacco industry and said that it could set a precedent for cities trying to recoup the costs of battling gun violence.

    Bridgeport, Connecticut, Chicago, New Orleans and Miami-Dade County, Florida, are suing the industry. Pro-gun groups have responded by lobbying state legislatures to pass laws prohibiting such suits. Georgia has passed a law to do that, and Louisiana is considering a similar measure.

    The Associated Press contributed to this report.


    RELATED STORIES:
    New York gun lawsuit deliberations resume
    February 9, 1999
    Gunmaker negligence trial in jury's hands
    February 3, 1999
    New Orleans under fire for gun swap with Glock
    January 29, 1999
    Shooting victims' suit against gun industry opens in New York
    January 6, 1999
    Two more cities sue gun manufacturers
    January 27, 1999
    U.S. mayors' group pushing for gun violence law
    January 28, 1999

    RELATED SITES:
    Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms
    National Rifle Association
    Smith & Wesson
    Cease Fire
    Handgun Control, Inc. and The Center To Prevent Handgun Violence
    Gunlaws.com
    Bradybill.com
    Second Amendment Law Library
    Handgun Control Inc. and The Center to Prevent Handgun Violence
    Violence Policy Center
    PAX organization, dedicated to ending gun violence in America
    Gunfree, a coalition to stop gun violence
    Violence Policy Center, online resource center
    Pledge.org, students pledge against gun violence
    Join Together Online, national resource center for communities working to reduce substance abuse and gun violence.
    Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
    External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.
     LATEST HEADLINES:
    SEARCH CNN.com
    Enter keyword(s)   go    help

    Back to the top   © 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.
    Terms under which this service is provided to you.
    Read our privacy guidelines.