Gene therapy no quick fix
September 13, 1996
Web posted at: 11:55 p.m. EDT
From CNN Correspondent Andrew Holtz
PALO ALTO, California (CNN) -- Revolutions take time.
That's what researchers and patients are learning about gene
therapy.
Take cystic fibrosis, for instance. The gene that causes the
potentially lethal breathing disorder was identified in 1989.
But a genetic cure isn't yet in hand.
Hayley Wester knows all too well about the time-intensive
practice of translating discoveries into results. Four times
a day, she thumps her lungs to clear clogging mucus caused by
cystic fibrosis, an ailment that stems from an error in a
single gene.
"I remember the gene was discovered when I was in high
school," Wester said. "I had the newspaper article and I ran
into the lunch room and I went to a really small school so
everybody knew what I was doing and I said, 'Hey, they found
the gene.'"
The next steps seemed obvious: Fix the gene and cure the
patients.
But that's not as easy as it sounds. Since cystic fibrosis
was discovered seven years ago, researchers have learned a
lot about how difficult it is to turn that discovery into
something practical that patients can use.
Wester is part of the latest effort to devise an effective
cystic fibrosis gene therapy. A virus carrying the corrected
gene was squirted into her sinuses. Previous attempts had
disappointing results.
"The virus caused some problems within the cell itself," said
Dr. Phyllis Gardner of Stanford University Medical Center.
"It caused the disease, and the patient's own body reacted
against the virus by producing antibodies."
A more recent experiment used a virus that usually causes no
symptoms.
In an effort to avoid the side effects caused in previous
experiments, researchers removed almost all of the virus's
original genes.
"That makes it a stealthier virus," Dr. John Wagner of the
medical center. "It's harder for the immune system of the
body to find it and react to it."
Researchers monitor the treatment with a flexible scope.
Eventually, they expect gene therapy could be applied with
simple aerosol inhalers.
But hopes for gene therapy are tempered by caution. "We let
the community believe that a cure was around the corner, and
it's not," Gardner said. "We have to work out these
strategies that make this work. I believe that ultimately we
will."
Practical gene therapy is still years away, researchers say.
And that's not soon enough for Wester. Her lungs are so
damaged that she's preparing for a lung transplant. Still,
she believes the experiments will help those who follow her.
"I've seen so many advances just in my lifetime," she said.
"I think that the prospects are very good for the future."
Related stories:
Related site:
Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.
Some newsgroups may not be supported by your service provider.
© 1996 Cable News Network, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.