Inside the Middle East - Blog
March 14, 2008
Gay Iranian Man's Asylum Plea Reconsidered
(CNN) -- Britain said Friday it will reconsider the asylum application of a gay Iranian teenager who claims he will be persecuted if he is returned home.

The announcement came after the European Parliament urged a resolution to the case and said Iran routinely detains, tortures, and executes homosexuals.


The case of 19-year-old Mehdi Kazemi has been in limbo after Britain initially rejected his asylum request. He fled to the Netherlands and sought asylum there -- but the government turned him down, saying the case should be dealt with in Britain, where he first applied.

"Following representations made on behalf of Mehdi Kazemi, and in the light of new circumstances since the original decision was made, I have decided that Mr. Kazemi's case should be reconsidered on his return to the UK from the Netherlands," British Home Secretary Jacqui Smith said in a statement.

Kazemi was studying in Britain in 2006 when he learned that his partner in Iran had been arrested, charged with sodomy, and hanged, according to Kazemi's uncle, who spoke to CNN on condition that his name not be revealed because of safety concerns.

"Under torture and pressure, (the partner) revealed Mehdi's name as his boyfriend," the uncle said.

Homosexuality is illegal in Iran, and gay sex is considered a capital crime. Human rights groups allege the Iranian government targets gays with beatings, lashings and execution.

Kazemi applied for asylum in Britain. In his application, he wrote that Iranian police were now after him, and he feared execution if he returned home.

Kazemi's father disowned him when he learned his son was gay, the uncle said.
Britain's Home Office initially rejected Kazemi's asylum application, saying that although homosexuality is illegal in Iran and gays do experience discrimination there, Britain does not believe homosexuals are routinely persecuted purely because of their sexuality.

Kazemi then fled for Canada but wound up in the Netherlands, where he was detained. He made three successive appeals for asylum in the Netherlands before the Council of State -- the Netherlands' highest court -- announced Tuesday that it rejected his plea.

The decision complied with a European Union agreement that an asylum application submitted in any EU country would be handled by that country alone, according to council spokeswoman

Daniela Tempelman. She said the regulation seeks to ensure that an asylum seeker is not redirected from nation to nation simply because none will take responsibility for the case.
In order for the Dutch court to consider Kazemi's asylum application, he needed to prove that Britain did not handle his asylum application properly, but he wasn't able to, Tempelman said.

His chances for appeal in the Netherlands now exhausted, Kazemi faces deportation to Britain.
The European Parliament passed a resolution Thursday demanding that a solution be found to Kazemi's case.

The resolution points out that the Iranian authorities "routinely detain, torture and execute persons, notably homosexuals" and that "Mehdi's partner has already been executed, while his father has threatened him with death."

It says the EU and its member states cannot send people back to countries where they risk persecution, torture and death because that would violate international human rights obligations.

The resolution asked EU member state "to find a common solution to ensure that Mehdi Kazemi is granted asylum or protection on EU soil and not sent back to Iran."
For the West, this is yet another example of "Damned if you do, damned if you don’t."

If we send him back into the arms of the grinning executioner, it's the same thing as if we provided/sharpened his sword for him.

If we (west) give him protection, we are yet again meddling in their business and our innocents have to die.

I say send him back. If one man's blood is the only thing that will soothe them, then I'm all for it.

It's a horrible decision, but it is what it is.
That's the most retarded thing I've ever head "Send him back, one man's blood will soothe them all"
You'd be singing a different tune if you were the person, or the person's partner or close friend.
Furthermore, at least one person's blood has ALREADY been spilled - Kazemi's partner was executed. But, clearly, that does not solve anything at all, because if he gets sent back, he'll die, too.

It's not a simple thing "Oh, let's sacrifice him for the good of everyone" - do you seriously think that sending people back to, literally, their deaths will automatically solve all issues between the West and the Middle Eastern countries and extremist groups? If so, you're dumber than your comment makes you out to be. There's so much more to it than that, and if Kazemi is returned to Iran, then what of any other asylum-seeker from any other country, or even more from Iran? Touting humanitarianism and then rejecting and deporting asylum-seekers is one of the worst offenses ever, reeking of hypocrisy and inhumanity. In a way, the act of sending him (and other such cases) back is even worse than the act of execution and/or other forms of persecution that await; at least the Iranians are up-front and aren't hiding that they persecute and kill... the West, though hides it in paperwork and technicalities.
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Welcome to the Inside the Middle East blog. Our reporters, producers, cameramen and editors will regularly add to this with colorful behind-the-scene stories. This page is about how we put the show together -- from on-location shoots to the editing room -- as well as for anecdotes and stories that don't always make it into our finished on-air product.
SHOWTIMES
Inside the Middle East airs 1st full weekend of every month and the following Thursday.

Saturday (1st Saturday of every month)
0730, 1330, 1830 (all regions)

Sunday (1st Sunday of every month)
1130, 1730 (all regions)

Thursday (1st Thursday of every month)
1330, 1730 (all regions)

(All times GMT)
I-Report
The region is a blend of cultures and landscapes that can be both harsh and beautiful. What is your Middle East like?
Share your stories, photos.
SUBSCRIBE
    What's this?
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. Please note that CNN makes reasonable efforts to review all comments prior to posting and CNN may edit comments for clarity or to keep out questionable or off-topic material. All comments should be relevant to the post and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying information via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  World  |  U.S.  |  Politics  |  Crime  |  Entertainment  |  Health  |  Tech  |  Travel  |  Living  |  Business  |  Sports  |  Time.com
© 2008 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.