|
| ASIAWEEK.COM |
|
CNN.COM |
|
east asia |
|
southeast asia |
|
south asia |
|
central asia |
|
australasia |
|
BUSINESS |
|
SPORTS |
|
SHOWBIZ |
|
ASIA WEATHER |
|
ASIA TRAVEL |
|
From TIME Asia
Culture on Demand: Black is Beautiful The American Express black card is the ultimate status symbol Asia Buzz: Should the Net Be Free? Web heads want it all -- for nothing JAPAN: Failed Revolution Prime Minister Yoshiro Mori clings to power as dissidents in his party finally decide not to back a no-confidence motion Cover: Endgame? After Florida's controversial ballot recount, Bush holds a 537-vote lead in the state, which could give him the election |
|
TIME Digest
FORTUNE.com FORTUNE China MONEY.com |
|
TIME Asia Services |
|
Subscribe to TIME! Get up to 3 MONTHS FREE!
Bookmark TIME TIME Media Kit Recent awards |
|
 |
|
about Asia Buzz | more Asia Buzz Maelstrom in Malaysia Gentlemen, start your legal arguments By JOHN WHITE October 22, 1999 Web posted at 2 a.m. Hong Kong time, 2 p.m. EDT More than just speed records were broken at the inaugural Formula 1 race at Malaysia's Sepang International Circuit Sunday. Also shattered were Ferrari fans' hopes of seeing their beloved prancing horse at the top of the F1 standings. There would be no championship for at least another year.
But things were just getting started. Even as the awards were being handed out--which appeared to put Ferrari into the lead of the World Driver's and Constructor's championships--McLaren was mounting a challenge. Team boss Ron Dennis was already questioning the legality of Schumacher's badly worn front tires and making accusatory noises about an "unsportsmanlike" pass when Schumacher slowed to allow Irvine to take the lead three laps from the finish. Dennis' ace in the hole was his knowledge of Ferrari's illegal barge boards (aerodynamic devices behind the front wheels), which he had known about since last month's European Grand Prix. In the cutthroat, multimillion-dollar world of F1, a team's secrets are a valuable currency to their rivals. For McLaren, such insights couldn't possibly have more value, as both world championships are at stake. If judges uphold Ferrari's disqualification, McLaren will have secured the Driver's Championship for 1999. However, all is not yet lost for Ferrari's "tifosi." Friday in Paris, the F1's ruling body, the FIA, will listen to Ferrari's appeal and hear McLaren's counter-arguments. Ferrari's only hope of overturning the ruling would be if the FIA believes that the illegal dimensions of the barge boards did not offer any performance advantage--and that it was an honest mistake made during the manufacturing process and overlooked during tech inspection at the previous race on Germany's Nurburgring. Irvine didn't score any points there, so it could be argued that the barge boards didn't give him an edge. McLaren is convinced otherwise. If it knew about the illegal barge boards at Nurburgring, then surely Ferrari must have as well. And that may be the crux of the FIA's decision. A team that knowingly uses illegal components doesn't stand a chance of having its appeal upheld. If, however, the FIA believes this was a bona fide manufacturing mistake, the ruling could be similar to one made in 1995. Back then, Schumacher and David Coulthard were found to be using illegal fuel during the Brazilian Grand Prix. The FIA ruled there was no performance advantage and allowed the drivers to keep the points earned in the race. However, their team had to forfeit its Manufacturer's Championship points. A similar decision would give McLaren the Constructor's Championship it deserves. And it would also give the fans what they want: a Driver's Championship decided at the final race on Japan's Suzuka circuit, rather than in a courtroom in Paris. Write to us at mail@web.timeasia.com Search for recent Asia Buzz
|
ASIA BUZZ
ASIAWEEK
