|
 |
SEARCH
ASIAWEEK
Intelligence:
Welcome to the World
ASEAN
Day Five: Pyongyang makes a splash
By ALEJANDRO REYES in Bangkok
July 28, 2000
Web posted at 5:30 p.m. Hong Kong time, 5:30 a.m. EDT
It is hard to know what Paek Nam Sun made of all the attention he got as
soon as he stepped off the Thai Airways flight from Beijing. Though he looked
a little dazed, the North Korean foreign minister must have expected that
he would be hounded by the media pack from the moment he arrived in Bangkok
for his heavy schedule of bilateral meetings and sessions of the ASEAN Regional
Forum. Pyongyang is participating for the first time in the security panel,
which was officially set up in 1994. It tried to get in years ago, but had
remained out for various reasons -- either it wasn't wanted or it wouldn't
join -- until this year. Now, after the recent historic inter-Korean summit
in June, North Korea was welcomed to the table, partly thanks to ASEAN chair
Thailand which pulled off a diplomatic coup by arranging for ARF admission
in short order.
|
INTERACTIVE |
|
Talk back to Asiaweek's correspondents on our
message boards
|
|
In Bangkok,
Paek had a series of groundbreaking face-to-face talks with his counterparts
-- South Korea, Japan, and on July 28, the U.S. (Madeleine Albright arrived
in Thailand late, delayed by the prolonged Camp David Israeli-Palestinian
peace negotiations. Paek insisted on meeting the American secretary of
state and not her stand-in, deputy Strobe Talbott.) Countries seemed eager
to meet the newcomer. Canada's Lloyd Axworthy even announced that Ottawa
had decided to establish diplomatic relations with North Korea later this
year. In the actual ARF plenary, Paek said his country, which has alarmed
its neighbors and the U.S. with its ballistic missile program, "has the
desire and will to exert concerted effort to build an independent, peaceful
and prosperous Asia." He took what was perceived as a swipe at Washington:
Peace and stability on the Korean peninsula rested on "terminating the
interference of the outside forces," he explained. "The Cold War is over,
yet we have failed to establish a new international political and economic
order."
While Paek's presence was one of the highlights of the ASEAN meetings,
some ministers warned that one big splash on the international scene did
not mean that Stalinist North Korea, once roundly condemned as a rogue
state, was somehow suddenly worthy of trust, the darling of the diplomatic
set. "We're a long way from having any confidence over North Korea's actions,"
said Axworthy. "There's going to be a very steep learning curve for them.
In this region, it has been a problem and remains a problem." Meanwhile,
Paek was doing his duty. In his ARF statement, he credited Pyongyang's
warming relations with Seoul and its neighbors to "the broad-minded generosity,
tolerant magnanimity and great all-embracing politics of the great leader
of our people, General Kim Jong Il." Old habits die hard.
The
"Airborne" ARF
True to form, Thai foreign minister Surin Pitsuwan was similarly upbeat
after chairing the ARF meeting on July 27 as he was at the end of the
ASEAN foreign ministers' retreat four days earlier. With all the major
security protagonists of the region in attendance -- let's pause here
to remember Pakistan, which wants in, but is still out -- "ARF is now
airborne." Again, Surin hailed the open and lively discussion. "Nobody
fell asleep."
Thank goodness. Indeed, if anybody had taken a snooze, they might have
missed a few poignant moments. Myanmar's Win Aung groused about Yangon's
persistent critics, questioning whether they really "want to see Myanmar
in flames and burnt to ashes." Said the foreign minister: "The olive branch
we've offered has been spurned by those who are opposing us in the belief
that increasing pressure, isolating us and putting sanctions on us would
work." From July 28, Myanmar is now the only ASEAN member shut out of
participating in a European Union development scheme for the region.
Also at the closed-door meeting, China came out gunning for the U.S. on
the issue of Washington's planned Theater Missile Defense (TMD) program.
While Talbott listened tight-lipped, Chinese foreign minister Tang Jiaxuan
criticized the "Cold War mentality [that] is still affecting the way some
countries perceive world politics and international relations." He added:
"Some people are hawking the TMD program against the tide of our times.
Such developments are compromising regional confidence-building and aggravating
the instability of regional security." The Russians chimed in, with foreign
minister Igor Ivanov critical of both TMD and the National Missile Defense
system, also planned by the U.S.
Is the ARF soaring? Well, maybe not. But it has taken a major step forward
with the inclusion of Pyongyang. I covered the group's very first gathering
-- an informal dinner in Singapore in 1993. At that time, the big news
was that then-U.S. secretary of state Warren Christopher sat next to Nguyen
Manh Cam, his opposite number from Vietnam, which was yet to join ASEAN.
Now, Vietnam is a full ASEAN member, the incoming chair in fact, and the
new coordinator for the next 12 months of the organization's dialogue
with its most important partner, the U.S. Times have changed.
Yet ARF still seems to have little bark and no bite. It remains primarily
an annual discussion forum. So-called "inter-session" meetings have been
moving forward on so-called confidence-building measures (CBM) such as
cooperation in regional search and rescue and a proposed training program
to prepare for U.N. peacekeeping operations. In the policy-wonk vernacular,
ARF is in between the CBM stage and the next level: preventive diplomacy.
That means that the group is likely to need more active leadership and
possibly a more formal structure.
But for that to happen requires the consensus of the 23 participants.
It won't come easily. I asked a Southeast Asian diplomat why the international
meeting on East Timor which took place on the sidelines of last year's
APEC summit in Auckland wasn't held under the banner of the ARF when it
was attended by practically all the same players, including -- controversially
-- British foreign secretary Robin Cook, representing the EU. He asked
me to shut off my tape recorder. "The ARF was just not ready for it,"
he lamented. "There was a lot of discussion about it. But there would
have been opposition. East Timor, after all, was a U.N. issue. But the
ARF was not yet at the level [where it could have happened]." Such are
the ways of ASEAN diplomacy.
Big
Man in Conference
With all eyes in Bangkok on Paek Nam Sun, many are wondering where North
Korea all of a sudden found urbane, well dressed diplomats to plead its
case around the world. ASEAN Secretary-General Rodolfo Severino points
out that North Korea has been a member of the U.N. for some time so the
country hasn't exactly been a complete hermit. And it had maintained ties
with a range of countries in what had been the Communist bloc. About Paek,
not that much is known. He became foreign minister nearly two years ago,
having served in the Workers Party propaganda department for some time,
overseeing South Korea policy. Born in 1929, he is said to have graduated
from Kim Il Sung University. He became Pyongyang's man in Poland in 1974,
serving for five years. Later he headed the Foreign Language Press Group
and was vice chair of the Central Committee of the Democratic People's
Republic of Korea Journalists Union. In his capacity as an adviser to
the DPRK Red Cross and as a member of its standing committee, he participated
in intermittent North-South talks for some years and visited Seoul at
least four times.
Write to Asiaweek at mail@web.asiaweek.com
Asiaweek.com
home
Quick
Scroll: More stories from Asiaweek, TIME and CNN
|
 |
 |
 |
ASIAWEEK'S
LATEST |
Web-only Exclusives
November 30, 2000
| | | |