Fat-shaming Trump might be a public service

Is the topic of weight Trump's go-to defense?
Is the topic of weight Trump's go-to defense?

    JUST WATCHED

    Is the topic of weight Trump's go-to defense?

MUST WATCH

Is the topic of weight Trump's go-to defense? 02:13

Story highlights

  • Meredith: Donald Trump, while criticizing others' weight, is not exactly slender himself...
  • Perhaps he is doing us a favor by making it fair game to talk about size

Sheena Meredith is a doctor, writer and healthcare communications consultant. The opinions in this article belong to the author.

(CNN)There are two major factors that influence life expectancy: smoking habits and weight. And they're heading in opposite directions.

While smoking's popularity has been plummeting for decades -- fewer than one in five people still smoke -- obesity has climbed to epidemic proportions and now affects more than one in three American adults.
Obesity -- dragged into the presidential race last week by Republican nominee Donald Trump -- is a bigger threat to health and linked to higher rates of chronic illness than smoking, problem drinking or poverty.
These two trends are not unconnected. The average tobacco quitter gains 11 or 12 pounds over the long run. Although the benefits of not smoking are calculated to offset damage from the increased risk of obesity, the obesity tide is eroding some of the gains in life expectancy from reduced smoking.
Obviously, therefore, physicians are enthusiastically advising their heavier patients to lose weight, hoping for the same success as they have achieved with smoking, right? Well, no. In fact, even when doctors inform patients that their body mass index (BMI) is too high, few offer constructive guidance about how to lose weight, citing barriers such as lack of time, training and confidence.
Donald Trump weighs in on weight
Donald Trump weighs in on weight

    JUST WATCHED

    Donald Trump weighs in on weight

MUST WATCH

Donald Trump weighs in on weight 01:31
Although physician advice can significantly boost the success of weight-loss efforts, the proportion of people receiving such advice has fallen. Even among patients consulting for obesity, physicians offer diet and nutrition education to only one in three.
Why is it that the public health approach applied so effectively to tobacco fails to translate to being overweight? Doctors have little hesitation about telling their smoking patients to quit, but a certain ambivalence seems to creep in when it comes to talking to patients about being overweight.
This is mirrored by official guidance. On smoking, the Surgeon General's advice to physicians is blunt: "Talk to your patients. Tell them that quitting smoking is the most important step they can take to improve their health. They will listen to you."
In contrast, six pages of advice from the National Institutes of Health on talking to patients about weight loss describes obesity as a "sensitive topic," advises speaking "caringly," opening discussion "in a respectful way" and using the patient's preferred terms to describe being overweight.
Being overweight is less obviously a choice, and not a yes-no lifestyle issue where doctors can confidently say, "just stop." Moreover, official guidelines on diet and weight are notoriously inconsistent, and environmental influences on weight are far more widespread.
While stigmatizing smokers is almost de rigueur, there has been a considerable backlash against "fat shaming." One article in the Washington Post by an emergency physician describing the difficulties of dealing with a morbidly obese patient provoked one commentator to say she wanted to slap the doctor for his "smug and insincere pity."
Clinton: Who gets up at 3 a.m. for a Twitter attack?
Clinton: Who gets up at 3 a.m. for a Twitter attack?

    JUST WATCHED

    Clinton: Who gets up at 3 a.m. for a Twitter attack?

MUST WATCH

Clinton: Who gets up at 3 a.m. for a Twitter attack? 01:56
Unlike smoking, a person's flab is very much a part of them. Saying "you're fat" comes to seem almost on a par with saying "you're ugly."
However, Donald Trump has recently bucked this trend. The presidential candidate has talked publicly and disparagingly about the weight of Alicia Machado, a Miss Universe winner, and has previously called talk-show host Rosie O'Donnell a "pig."
The irony, not lost on many commentators, is that Donald Trump is not exactly slender himself. In fact, at 6 feet 3 inches and 236 pounds, according to his doctor, his body mass index (BMI) is 29.5, putting him on the cusp of obese (a BMI of 30 or greater).
Follow CNN Opinion

Join us on Twitter and Facebook

Unlike the yoga-posturing, vegetable-munching Hillary Clinton, Trump doesn't exercise. He eats buckets of fried chicken. He knows he should lose weight but his lifestyle gets in the way. He says he's always been overweight.
In other words, he's like an awful lot of Americans. So perhaps Trump is doing us a favour, making it fair game to talk about his size as a way to open discussions about obesity without upsetting those of a more sensitive disposition.
Perhaps fat-shaming Donald Trump might even count as a public service.