Some writers suggest women who participate in hookup culture often feel like outsiders struggling to navigate a territory where young men set the terms of sexual activity. Still, with similar proportions of college men and women hooking up, others wonder if hookup culture might be liberating for young women. Perhaps it's even a sign that the traditional sexual double standard is a thing of the past.
This isn't an easy question to answer. On the one hand, college hookup culture allows women to explore their sexuality in ways that previous generations of women could not. On the other hand, it is a deeply gendered custom
that can enhance a man's reputation and damage a woman's.
As a sociologist who studies gender and sexuality, I decided to explore the status of the traditional sexual double standard in college hookup culture. Do college students today support it, and if so, to what degree?
Contemporary status of the traditional double standard
In 1960 sociologist Ira Reiss
published "Premarital Sexual Standards in America,"
inspiring decades of research on a traditional double standard that is used to judge women more harshly than men for engaging in similar sexual behaviors.
So, what does all this subsequent research say about the status of this double standard today?
indicate the traditional double standard is still relevant. Others
indicate it has been surpassed by an egalitarian standard where men and women are judged similarly for engaging in similar behaviors and that some college students even use a reverse sexual double standard to judge men more harshly than women.
Why are these findings so mixed? One explanation
is that contemporary college students tend to believe that the traditional double standard exists in society, but not in their own minds. In other words, they think they don't judge women more harshly than men, but they believe others do.
In fact, findings from a number of studies indicate both men and women expect college women to be negatively judged (presumably by others) for "going too far" on a hookup. This can have real implications for power dynamics in sexual encounters.
In their interviews with college women, sociologists Laura Hamilton and Elizabeth A. Armstrong
found that some attributed their negative experiences with hookups to men's endorsement of the traditional double standard. These women believed the traditional double standard gave men power in hookups and justified the disrespectful treatment of women.
This suggests that when men endorse the traditional double standard it has implications for women's experiences with college hookups. So how common is it for men to endorse the traditional double standard? Do women tend to endorse a different standard? And what does judgment of sexual behavior mean for power dynamics in hookups?
I explored these questions
using data from a sample of over 11,000 students who responded to the Online College Social Life Survey
Sexual double standards and power in college hookups
Since college students often believe that double standards exist in society, but not in their own minds, I paid particular attention to respondents' belief that a past hookup partner had lost respect for them after a hookup.
I found that most respondents judged men and women similarly for similar sexual behaviors. However, when I broke the results down by sex, an interesting pattern emerged. Approximately 45 percent of men endorsed the traditional double standard, while about 33 percent of women endorsed the reverse double standard. In other words, men's judgments of women were generally harsher than women's judgments of men.
Additionally, over half of women reported feeling that they had been disrespected for hooking up, compared to 22 percent of men. This suggests that the traditional double standard is still relevant, even if college students believe that it only exists outside of their own minds.
I also found that a respondent's belief that he or she had been personally disrespected by a previous hookup partner was associated with power disadvantages in their most recent hookup.
The respondents who reported feeling disrespected were more likely to engage in sexual acts that they did not personally desire. This included performing sexual acts to please their partner and giving in to verbal pressure to have sex when they didn't want to. Importantly, this was the case for both men and women in the study.
Stigma about sex doesn't help anybody
It's possible that popular discourse about hookup culture may benefit young people if it promotes neutral perspectives that do not portray anyone negatively for hooking up.
The fact is, as these findings show, there is a relationship between stigmatization of sexual behavior and sexual disempowerment for young people. When young adults feel judged for past sexual behavior, they may have trouble expressing their desires and setting limits with future partners.
Ultimately, judgment does nothing to promote the development of healthy sexuality among young people.