CNN  — 

On Thursday night, America learned what a GOP presidential debate looks like without Donald Trump. Now see what it looks like in GIFs.

The moderator asked Sen. Rand Paul if he regrets not backing his father, Ron Paul, politically.

Sen. Ted Cruz really wanted to get his point across. With. His. Hands.

Ben Carson said the world is a crazy place.

Sen. Marco Rubio couldn’t help but laugh at his own joke about not leaving the stage, a response to Cruz.

Jeb Bush shrugged off the idea that anti-establishment and establishment candidates are splitting the GOP vote.

Ben Carson was – at moments – the most animated person on stage.

Jeb Bush and Rubio went back and forth over who changed positions on illegal immigration.

Paul realized that nothing drives home a point like props.

Gov. Chris Christie said the days of the Clintons in public housing is over, and by golly he meant it.

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story misidentified whom Jeb Bush argued with over immigration during the debate. It was Marco Rubio.