Analysis: Obama speech a do-over on 'no strategy' comment

Obama to layout ISIS game plan tonight
Obama to layout ISIS game plan tonight

    JUST WATCHED

    Obama to layout ISIS game plan tonight

MUST WATCH

Obama to layout ISIS game plan tonight 02:15

Story highlights

  • Beheadings of two Americans put ISIS into Americans' consciousness
  • Obama must explain to public the threat ISIS presents
  • The President must also lay out what his strategy is for eliminating the ISIS threat
Consider tonight's speech by President Barack Obama to be the antidote to his now-infamous comments two weeks ago that his administration lacks a strategy for combating ISIS in Syria.
The beheadings of two Americans -- journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff -- have propelled ISIS into the center of the American public consciousness. The group is no longer a distant, local threat, but an immediate threat to American lives. Obama knows he must now give a comprehensive answer to this threat.
Is ISIS a threat to the U.S.?
First, he will need to explain to Americans to what degree ISIS threatens U.S. national security.
The administration's current assessment is that, for now, it is principally a threat to the region, as well as to American diplomats, soldiers and other personnel based in Iraq. However, the U.S. intelligence community believes ISIS also threatens U.S. interests outside the region, including in the U.S. homeland.
Will ISIS attacks spread to U.S.?
Will ISIS attacks spread to U.S.?

    JUST WATCHED

    Will ISIS attacks spread to U.S.?

MUST WATCH

Will ISIS attacks spread to U.S.? 01:49
ISIS: Picking up where Al Qaeda left off
ISIS: Picking up where Al Qaeda left off

    JUST WATCHED

    ISIS: Picking up where Al Qaeda left off

MUST WATCH

ISIS: Picking up where Al Qaeda left off 02:03
Kerry: U.S. will help fight 'evil' ISIS
Kerry: U.S. will help fight 'evil' ISIS

    JUST WATCHED

    Kerry: U.S. will help fight 'evil' ISIS

MUST WATCH

Kerry: U.S. will help fight 'evil' ISIS 01:47
John Kerry rallies Gulf leaders support
John Kerry rallies Gulf leaders support

    JUST WATCHED

    John Kerry rallies Gulf leaders support

MUST WATCH

John Kerry rallies Gulf leaders support 00:54
Intelligence officials tell me that while ISIS is focused on strengthening the Islamic state, or caliphate, in Syria and Iraq, this does not mean its aspirations end there. ISIS is believed to be encouraging the many foreigners now fighting for it (including about a dozen Americans) and other sympathizers to carry out attacks in the West when they return home.
When I asked Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel last week whether ISIS is a threat to the U.S. today or some day down the road, he said the administration doesn't have the luxury of making that distinction.
"We can't take a chance, Jim, on saying, 'Well, let's technically define this -- is it a real threat today or tomorrow, or is it going to be in six months?' " Hagel said. "That's the way the threats don't work in little, neat boxes and emanate on our time frame. They emanate on their time frame. We know they're a threat. We know they're brutal. We know that they are, as I've said, as others have said, something that we've never seen before."
What's Obama's strategy?
Second, the President will need to lay out in detail his strategy for dealing with ISIS. This follows another confusing rhetorical moment for the White House.
Officials including the President now say the goal is "degrading and destroying ISIS," but only after the President indicated last week that his goal may be simply to make ISIS a more "manageable" threat.
Now that the goal is to defeat ISIS, exactly what steps will the President order to accomplish that? Sources tell CNN he is "open to" ordering airstrikes inside Syria. And Hagel told me in our interview that the Pentagon has already presented him with military options to do so.
Paying for the response to ISIS threat
Paying for the response to ISIS threat

    JUST WATCHED

    Paying for the response to ISIS threat

MUST WATCH

Paying for the response to ISIS threat 01:59
President's Plan for Syria, ISIS
President's Plan for Syria, ISIS

    JUST WATCHED

    President's Plan for Syria, ISIS

MUST WATCH

President's Plan for Syria, ISIS 01:57
Pres. backtracks on ISIS 'JV' team comment
Pres. backtracks on ISIS 'JV' team comment

    JUST WATCHED

    Pres. backtracks on ISIS 'JV' team comment

MUST WATCH

Pres. backtracks on ISIS 'JV' team comment 07:01
We also now know that the President is asking for so-called Title X authority to arm and train Syrian rebel groups. However, the President has said, and will likely repeat tonight, that military action alone will not accomplish his goals. He needs an international coalition, particularly involving regional states directly involved in the conflict. He needs a more inclusive government in Iraq. And he needs a continuing and broad humanitarian mission to serve the many Iraqis and Syrians that ISIS is driving from their homes, starving and murdering.
How long will this fight last?
Finally, Obama will need to explain to Americans how long and how intense this new war will be. He campaigned on ending the long American wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Until very recently, his administration continued to emphasize that Americans are war-weary and that the administration was loathe to bring the nation back to war, short of very direct threats to U.S. interests.
Remember the administration's -- also infamous -- mantra "Don't do stupid stuff" as the driving force of the President's foreign policy. Now, the President is taking the nation back to war. For how long? How costly will it be?
As a candidate in 2007, he famously called Iraq "a dumb war." Why won't this war be dumb?